Food and service is great. I've never had a problem here. The inside dining needs an extreme make over tho. It looks so worn out. But I'd get there food any day. Chicken Club is soooo good!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charles Moore
Best pizza in my town
Paige Yocum
Pizza was great. Service was friendly and quick. Highly recommend!
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Stull
I grew up in Newcomerstown and this place hasn't changed a bit and that's the problem it needs repairs the inside looks dirty the wallpaper is peeling off the walls and hanging. The teenager at the counter had a horrible attitude when taking our order once we got the pizza it was okay but honestly you could tip the pizza and watch the grease run off of it. Great childhood memories but it honestly still looks the same as it did 21 years ago not a single thing has been updated or changed other than the price of things
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
Rj Lynch
Really good food and service would recommend to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ethan Murray
Ordered a dinner tonight for delivery and paid quite a nice tip, called an hour and a half later to find out they marked my order for pickup instead of how it was supposed to be. Terrible service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Devony Pugh
Love their sauce.Parking: Not a ton of parking spots, but I've never had to wait on a spot or park somewhere else. ?
Good, but only if you like sweet marinara sauce. Sweetest I’ve ever
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Robert L.
This is a gem in Newcomerstown. Working this far from major businesses leaves people lacking in options for lunch. The pizza here I would compare to Flyers, Joeseppies, etc in Columbus but some of the options are not as good as them either. The pepperoni pizza or all meat pizza for example are top notch but everything else is above average. I order chicken bacon ranch subs often from them but only because it's better than Subway chicken and fresher tasting due to the oven baked method versus the microwave Subway uses but the sub is not as good as Penn Station or Charley's subs. The steak sub is not great but better than Subway due to being baked. The service is fast and friendly and they always deliver on time or ahead for me. The ambience, well this is in a run down looking building and I am not sure why but this could be out of their hands. They do appear to keep it clean every time I have been in there but it does need a facelift inside and out, and better sign for location and door to distinguish it from the other businesses. Overall not a bad place.
Mary Service
Wow awesome crust, good sauce, generous toppings, yummy cheese and piping hot!! We were driving to Hocking Hills from the Canton area and wanted to grab a pizza on our way. The pizza shop is on an old building, but don't judge a book by its cover. What a wonderful surprise!!
You know the saying,"better late than never"? This place has a tendency to choose never. Placed an order and was told 25min. Still waiting for that order to this day. A simple call would've been nice
Zoie Cole
Ordered a salad and boneless wings was told 20-25 minutes for delivery waited over and hour and a half and still no food. I called 6 times no answer. How disappointing and rude.
Rebecca Ickes
Waited 25minutes on a 15 minute order . Sub was cold , cheese wasn't even melted.Hey but my cheese was melted on my salad. Tried to call in order but over and went to voice mail.
Bryce Rhodes
Me and my friends go here every now and than, great place to just hangout inside and have a good time with great food and good laughs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MedievalSiren
Me and my friends go here every now and than, great place to just hangout inside and have a good time with great food and good laughs.
Food and service is great. I've never had a problem here. The inside dining needs an extreme make over tho. It looks so worn out. But I'd get there food any day. Chicken Club is soooo good!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in my town
Pizza was great. Service was friendly and quick. Highly recommend!
Food: 5
Service: 5
I grew up in Newcomerstown and this place hasn't changed a bit and that's the problem it needs repairs the inside looks dirty the wallpaper is peeling off the walls and hanging. The teenager at the counter had a horrible attitude when taking our order once we got the pizza it was okay but honestly you could tip the pizza and watch the grease run off of it. Great childhood memories but it honestly still looks the same as it did 21 years ago not a single thing has been updated or changed other than the price of things
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
Really good food and service would recommend to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a dinner tonight for delivery and paid quite a nice tip, called an hour and a half later to find out they marked my order for pickup instead of how it was supposed to be. Terrible service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Love their sauce.Parking: Not a ton of parking spots, but I've never had to wait on a spot or park somewhere else. ?
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesestix, Homerun Pizza, Mexican Stix, Meat Pizza
Good, but only if you like sweet marinara sauce. Sweetest I’ve ever
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
This is a gem in Newcomerstown. Working this far from major businesses leaves people lacking in options for lunch. The pizza here I would compare to Flyers, Joeseppies, etc in Columbus but some of the options are not as good as them either. The pepperoni pizza or all meat pizza for example are top notch but everything else is above average. I order chicken bacon ranch subs often from them but only because it's better than Subway chicken and fresher tasting due to the oven baked method versus the microwave Subway uses but the sub is not as good as Penn Station or Charley's subs. The steak sub is not great but better than Subway due to being baked. The service is fast and friendly and they always deliver on time or ahead for me. The ambience, well this is in a run down looking building and I am not sure why but this could be out of their hands. They do appear to keep it clean every time I have been in there but it does need a facelift inside and out, and better sign for location and door to distinguish it from the other businesses. Overall not a bad place.
Wow awesome crust, good sauce, generous toppings, yummy cheese and piping hot!! We were driving to Hocking Hills from the Canton area and wanted to grab a pizza on our way. The pizza shop is on an old building, but don't judge a book by its cover. What a wonderful surprise!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
You know the saying,"better late than never"? This place has a tendency to choose never. Placed an order and was told 25min. Still waiting for that order to this day. A simple call would've been nice
Ordered a salad and boneless wings was told 20-25 minutes for delivery waited over and hour and a half and still no food. I called 6 times no answer. How disappointing and rude.
Waited 25minutes on a 15 minute order . Sub was cold , cheese wasn't even melted.Hey but my cheese was melted on my salad. Tried to call in order but over and went to voice mail.
Me and my friends go here every now and than, great place to just hangout inside and have a good time with great food and good laughs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Me and my friends go here every now and than, great place to just hangout inside and have a good time with great food and good laughs.