the food was amazing. the waitress was wonderful. very short wait for food. prices were very good. will definitely be going back.
Krystal Hughes
the food was amazing. the waitress was wonderful. very short wait for food. prices were very good. will definitely be going back.
Kimberly Walter
Great food
Kimberly Leeser
My husband and I had an amazing dinner Saturday night. I had the ribs, which were out of this world, and my husband had an amazing burger! So thankful to have this gem in downtown Newcomerstown, and can't wait to get back!
larrytheTAR
It is a neighborhood establishment in a rural village of 3600 fine, everyday folks. You will not find 'fancy people, dignitaries or pop culture icons' here. So, my experience, thoughts and ratings are offered with that in mind. My wife and I were here once before, Saturday evening, both times. They have limited hours/days that they are open. They have the usual menu of a bar/family type establishment. We had the haddock special that they offered. It was perfect. A side salad and home cut fries were the sides. Nice portions served by the bar maid/waitress who was friendly and attentive. She was also taking care of all the other patrons, about 20 people, both couples and families, efficiently with a smile. Prices were fair, and the atmosphere low key, typical of a bar without the blaring juke box. We will definitely return.
Junebug_1313
Good food. Great service with a comfortable environment
One of our favorite restaurants. Excellent food, service and the desserts are amazing!! In Florida until probably June and will truly miss this place.
Tom Harris
I love this place. First the food is of excellent quality and you get good portions. I ordered medium rare sirloin and it was cooked to perfection. Second, the service is excellent even though there's only one server. She really hustles to get everyone served. Third, the atmosphere is one of the best you will find with old pictures of the town and tribute pictures of Cy Young. I eat here every time I visit New Philadelphia. Recently this restaurant was for sale and I am so glad (so is the town of Newcomerstown) that they are still open. What a hidden gem. Forget the chain restaurants...eat here!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
carol rubis
Service super attentive considering she was the only waitress. Place was packed. The food was delicious. Large portions. Great prices. Didn't have a long wait for service or food. Large selection on the menu and Great prices on their specials. I had chopped steak, which was so tender plus mashed potatoes. My husband had open roast beef which he said melted in his mouth, mashed potatoes and green beans. Then strawberry cheesecake.
Food was delicious and service was great! Not real crowded and a very good atmosphere. I definitely recommend stopping in for some great food and a drink or two.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nathan C
The finest restaurant in Newcomerstown hands down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ben Croghan
My son and I call this Our Restaurant. The food and staff are great. It goes well beyond expectations!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chandis Linkinogger
They have steak and shrimp on fist fight over!!! ;)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Denisha Noviski
Wasn't sure what to think about having dinner with my family here, but it turned out delicious! The service was great for our party of 10! Can't wait to go again!!
the food was amazing. the waitress was wonderful. very short wait for food. prices were very good. will definitely be going back.
the food was amazing. the waitress was wonderful. very short wait for food. prices were very good. will definitely be going back.
Great food
My husband and I had an amazing dinner Saturday night. I had the ribs, which were out of this world, and my husband had an amazing burger! So thankful to have this gem in downtown Newcomerstown, and can't wait to get back!
It is a neighborhood establishment in a rural village of 3600 fine, everyday folks. You will not find 'fancy people, dignitaries or pop culture icons' here. So, my experience, thoughts and ratings are offered with that in mind.
My wife and I were here once before, Saturday evening, both times. They have limited hours/days that they are open. They have the usual menu of a bar/family type establishment. We had the haddock special that they offered. It was perfect. A side salad and home cut fries were the sides. Nice portions served by the bar maid/waitress who was friendly and attentive. She was also taking care of all the other patrons, about 20 people, both couples and families, efficiently with a smile.
Prices were fair, and the atmosphere low key, typical of a bar without the blaring juke box. We will definitely return.
Good food. Great service with a comfortable environment
Kid-friendliness: Yes
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Cut Fries, Taco Salad, Roast Beef
One of our favorite restaurants. Excellent food, service and the desserts are amazing!! In Florida until probably June and will truly miss this place.
I love this place. First the food is of excellent quality and you get good portions. I ordered medium rare sirloin and it was cooked to perfection. Second, the service is excellent even though there's only one server. She really hustles to get everyone served. Third, the atmosphere is one of the best you will find with old pictures of the town and tribute pictures of Cy Young. I eat here every time I visit New Philadelphia. Recently this restaurant was for sale and I am so glad (so is the town of Newcomerstown) that they are still open. What a hidden gem. Forget the chain restaurants...eat here!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service super attentive considering she was the only waitress. Place was packed. The food was delicious. Large portions. Great prices. Didn't have a long wait for service or food. Large selection on the menu and Great prices on their specials. I had chopped steak, which was so tender plus mashed potatoes. My husband had open roast beef which he said melted in his mouth, mashed potatoes and green beans. Then strawberry cheesecake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was delicious and service was great! Not real crowded and a very good atmosphere. I definitely recommend stopping in for some great food and a drink or two.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The finest restaurant in Newcomerstown hands down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My son and I call this Our Restaurant. The food and staff are great. It goes well beyond expectations!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They have steak and shrimp on fist fight over!!! ;)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wasn't sure what to think about having dinner with my family here, but it turned out delicious! The service was great for our party of 10! Can't wait to go again!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Cut Fries
Loading...