Salvatore's Pizzeria

5555 Youngstown Warren Rd, Niles
(330) 544-5333

Recent Reviews

Tiffany Parsons

Cheese pizza was good! Customer service was horrible! I normally always tip.... but not this time.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 1

Cindy Stuart

We stopped at the mall today and had lunch while there. I tried Salvatore’s for the first time. I ordered a pepperoni roll. It was the best pepperoni roll I’ve ever tried. Fresh ingredients and so good! I live an hour away but will definitely make the drive again to get another roll.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Roll

Krystle Nowakowski

Pizza looks really good, but not much flavor.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Michael Komacko

I didn’t order burnt, dried out pizza…but here is what I got. $8.00 for 2 slices of garbage. Sucks I can’t complain or take it back because I have a store to run. We order here a few times a month and always recommend them to our customers. Not at all pleased with this tonight. Thankfully I ordered a thin crust for my wife, stuck eating that. Hope this is an isolated incident, but I would have preferred being told it was not available than to be handed this to eat. Not a good representation of our usual experience.Wheelchair accessibility: Open space food court with plenty of room for the wheelchair bound.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Wendy Prox

Pizza was very good.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amy S.

Every time we get New York thin pizza here we all get diarrhea, stomach pains, there's a fat guy w grey hair who don't wear gloves when making pizzas I have watched him touch his phone touch the I pad then go stick his hand in the dough and cheese that's very unsanitary they should be wearing gloves when preparing food and they should not be touching there phones or the I pad where they make pizzas.we will not be buying any more pizzashere for this reason, not to mention 4 slices of pizza cost $17 ridiculous no more pizza at the mall.

Food: 1

Service: 2

Brionna Neely

I came up to order a pizza and the lady who helped me grabbed the pizza with her bare hands!! I saw other employees eating in front of customers and on their phones near the food. I don’t know if the food is safe to eat here ..

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Maria T

This is the best (thin crust) pizza around here. I only do thin crust.

Food: 5

Jon Doe

One of the best pizzas I have had in the area!!

Tanya Zupanchick

The entire team today on June 9,2023 were not practicing safe food handling. They were seen on phones then serving food without washing hands or wearing gloves. Also wiping down trays without washing hands or wearing gloves went to serving and prepping food. Hopefully no one gets sick, but the staff needs

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 3

Markella P

Food was ok but bought at the mall and the price was 3 dollars different at the register from posted prices and they dont honor the marked price. I was told there are signs that covid made price increases but its a digital sign. Not even an apology about it, the lady acted like I was the issue for bringing it up. Its shady business practice.

Joe Syvertsen

I had set up a large order to pick up from them this Sunday for my daughter's baby shower..I found out that I was wrongnon the date 2 hours before the shower..Called and they had everything ready to go in an hout!Were talking 40 subs...2 trays of pasta and 2 trays of brownies!I'm so thankful for what they did for me..Excellent people that work there and ofcourse all of there food is amazing!!Highly and I mean HIGHLY reccomend this place.

Joe Albergo

Called to order delivery at 7:00 they told me it's only through the Door Dash and GrubHub. I get on Door Dash, the application says the restaurant is closed. That totally bites the dust, was really looking forward to trying their pizza. Oh well.

Tim Mcmahon

Pizza is very bland and flavorless. Maybe im bias from being from philly/nj area. Friendly staff and fast service.

Tavonte S.

This place is hot buns served on a flavorless platter. They hide the fact the food isn't seasoned by just making sure it's extremely hot. Ended up getting the Philly and loaded fries huge mistake as the fries were soggier than my pillow after a teenage break up. The Philly was hot but nothing stood out. The wife ended up grabbing the chicken parm. The chicken was under cooked smothered with a decent amounts of sauce and cheese the only plus about it. She also ordered a brownie I would've rated that except the employee behind the counter didn't give it to us. Overall 2 stars seeing as I probably won't be back but I want others to try and hope their experiences are better than ours. The first impression is the best one and these guys know how to blow it.

Load More