Red Eye Pie and Frozen Fantasty's

3219 Seaman Rd, Oregon
(419) 277-4010

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Philly Cheesesteak Thin Crust Pizza

Buffalo Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Pepperoni Pizza Slice

Cheese Pizza Slice

Specialty Pizzas

All Meat Pizza

Supreme Pizza

Photos

+23 photos

+22 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Redeyepiefrozenfantastys

Slicelife

Recent Reviews

This pizza is AMAZING! Listen, I know garbage when I see it.....and this is NOT garbage! This classic, and arguably thin, pizza is baked perfectly! The right amount of pizza sauce combined with the perfect amount of cheese makes my mouth water EVERY time! I must admit that the employees here are absolutely amazing as well! They are always so helpful & so friendly. My ONLY complaint is that the pizza box is square and it makes it difficult to bring it into my trash...

August 2025

We came from Van Wert Ohio for the Jake and Cooper Bark Park 5k. We stopped in and tried the amazing ice cream. The pizza was DELICIOUS! 10 out of 10. The young man who helped us was super sweet and friendly.

May 2025

I rolled past this place today by chance during work, having never heard a peep about it before and WOW. I LOVE that they have slices, I loved the pierogi pizza, and the pepperoni was amazing too.

This is (unfortunately) the Toledo area’s best kept secret. I’m looking forward to returning and trying everything else.

January 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Oregon, OH

Red Eye Pie and Frozen Fantasty's

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Red Eye Pie and Frozen Fantasty's