P.Jay's Pizza

Name: P.Jay's Pizza
Address: 5859 Ridge Rd, Parma, Ohio, 44129, US
Telephone: (440) 885-4355
Price range: $
Rating: 3.9

$ • Pizza, Vegetarian

Hours:
5859 Ridge Rd, Parma
(440) 885-4355

Menu Order Online

About P.Jay's Pizza

P.Jay's Pizza is known for having the best pie around. Their food is phenomenal, featuring a great BBQ wings flavor and perfectly cooked chicken. The owner, Lee, makes a fantastic pepperoni and banana pepper pizza. The service is excellent, with quick pickup times and delivery drivers who communicate well. Customers frequently praise the pierogi pizza, which is perfectly cooked with the right amount of ingredients, cheese, and potatoes, and the flamingo sauce with Jo Jo’s is highly recommended. The meatball sub is also a standout, with a crispy bun, well-seasoned meatballs and sauce, and plenty of cheese, earning high praise. While the wings can sometimes be undercooked, putting them in the oven makes them very good.

Recently, some customers experienced issues with to-go orders, mentioning that entrees were sometimes smashed during transport. However, many others have loved their meals, including spaghetti and meat sauce, wings, and the P.Jay's special salad. One customer even claimed that the Jumbo Cheese and Large Pepperoni pizza was the best they have ever had, even compared to homemade options, and was eager to try more from the menu. Overall, P.Jay's remains a favorite in Parma, offering delicious food and great staff, making it a must-visit. Cheers to P.Jay's!