Waitress HAYLIE R. was FANTASTIC!! ASK FOR HER!! it was our first time here and she was right on top of things explaining that their subs are about 6 inches. All the pizzas are the same size around 10 inches and that we are perfectly welcome to order the lunch special even on Saturday, ABSOLUTELY Great service & good food. Pizzas are all the same size with a thin crust & chewy not crisp. Sauce is a little on the tart side with diced tomatoes in it. We each had French onion soup which is very flavorful!! (No pic-we were HUNGRY!) hubby had a 1/2 Reuben which was DELISH! We would stop in again.
Amanda D.
First time trying. Not a huge menu but everything looked and sounded good. I tried two cocktails and both were very good. All 3 appetizers were delicious. The meatballs were really good. The humans plate was delicious. Loved the wood fired bread to dip. Hummus was very good, nice flavor. My husband liked it and he doesn't normally eat hummus. The cheese curds were good. The breading wasn't super heavy. We were all kind of full after all the appetizers so we just got a pizza to split. The Buffalo chicken pizza was good. Not super spicy. We would definitely go back.
Kyla D.
Everything about this place is phenomenal. The food, the drinks, the service!! Love coming here with my friends to have an amazing night.
Emily Huff
Great food! We had the smash burger, meatball sub, and bruschetta. Classics done extremely well, reasonably priced and super friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bryan Hackenberger
My favorite meatball sub in the area. Get a side of their beer cheese to go with your fries. Service is always great, and they turn it up for Buckeye games.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Meatballs, Street Tacos, Cheese Curds
Dan Seas
Good food and service. Fried raviolis were very tasty. Normally I would not get a chicken enchilada pizza, but it really turned out delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kayla H.
I am currently house sitting in Pataskala. And I have been to this place on two separate occasions and their pizza is amaziiiinnnng!!! I have had the Margherita and the red roasted pepper and goat cheese specialty pizzas- both of which are absolutely delicious. Absolutely recommend this place if you live in or are just randomly find yourself in Pataskala.
Mike M.
It's the ONLY sit down place in town tbh, other than the same Mexican places- bar food, or 'a' breakfast spot.. Normally everything is on par with a 3 +* restaurant but when they get behind there is zero potential for a decent meal. The back of the house definitely needs some in the weeds training or to 86 the weekend cooks because they cannot keep up with a crowd for the life of them. Which in turn really impacts the front of the house staff.
Danny L
First visit to Elliot’s. Wife and I split the chicken, bacon and ranch pizza and a taco. Very good and service was great too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Street Tacos, Chicken Bacon Ranch
Really like this place. Wood fired pizza, nice interior, bar, good service and food. First time here and it was busier than expected on a Monday night. We were still able to get a high top at the bar upon arrival . Casual atmosphere with music playing in the background. Pizza was very good. Apple crisp desert wasn't the best I've had but still good . This is probably one of the better places to have a meal in Pataskala, OH. They have a location in New Albany as well.
Eddie Mac
Wanted to get some bruschetta but they were all out, no worries, Sunday night. Ordered a margarita pizza and it came out with nothing on it. So basically a cheese pizza. Server said they were out of basil. Ok, what about the sliced mozzarella, tomato’s and olive oil. Nothing on it but regular cheese. Should have told me that so I could get something else. One and only time at this joint
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
T W
Great place but very expensive compared to other places. When you're on a fixed income you can't afford to pay $16 for a sandwich and a few fries. My wife and I walked out of there with a $49 bill for two sandwiches fries and cheese curds. We could have went to a local steakhouse and had steaks baked potato salad for less than that.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jay Evans
We quite enjoy Elliot’s. The tacos are great but the thing that has always been missing is a hamburger. This time they had a hamburger offering it was called a slab burger and actually very very good. We tried to keep it light and shared one of the burgers and got a portobello appetizer, the portobello appetizer is excellent as always.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Street Tacos
Diana B.
Wonderful food, wonderful service. All at an excellent price. The space reminded me of a chilled out "Cheers" pub. This was our first visit (we usually "do" pizza in Granville) since we were on our way back from Columbus this afternoon. Heather was our server...she was AWESOME. We had the hummus platter... excellent and enough for four. And a Margherita pizza with pepperoni -- wonderful too! Will be back when we want a wood fired pizza.
Waitress HAYLIE R. was FANTASTIC!! ASK FOR HER!! it was our first time here and she was right on top of things explaining that their subs are about 6 inches. All the pizzas are the same size around 10 inches and that we are perfectly welcome to order the lunch special even on Saturday, ABSOLUTELY Great service & good food. Pizzas are all the same size with a thin crust & chewy not crisp. Sauce is a little on the tart side with diced tomatoes in it. We each had French onion soup which is very flavorful!! (No pic-we were HUNGRY!) hubby had a 1/2 Reuben which was DELISH! We would stop in again.
First time trying. Not a huge menu but everything looked and sounded good. I tried two cocktails and both were very good. All 3 appetizers were delicious. The meatballs were really good. The humans plate was delicious. Loved the wood fired bread to dip. Hummus was very good, nice flavor. My husband liked it and he doesn't normally eat hummus. The cheese curds were good. The breading wasn't super heavy. We were all kind of full after all the appetizers so we just got a pizza to split. The Buffalo chicken pizza was good. Not super spicy. We would definitely go back.
Everything about this place is phenomenal. The food, the drinks, the service!! Love coming here with my friends to have an amazing night.
Great food! We had the smash burger, meatball sub, and bruschetta. Classics done extremely well, reasonably priced and super friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My favorite meatball sub in the area. Get a side of their beer cheese to go with your fries. Service is always great, and they turn it up for Buckeye games.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Meatballs, Street Tacos, Cheese Curds
Good food and service. Fried raviolis were very tasty. Normally I would not get a chicken enchilada pizza, but it really turned out delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am currently house sitting in Pataskala. And I have been to this place on two separate occasions and their pizza is amaziiiinnnng!!! I have had the Margherita and the red roasted pepper and goat cheese specialty pizzas- both of which are absolutely delicious. Absolutely recommend this place if you live in or are just randomly find yourself in Pataskala.
It's the ONLY sit down place in town tbh, other than the same Mexican places- bar food, or 'a' breakfast spot.. Normally everything is on par with a 3 +* restaurant but when they get behind there is zero potential for a decent meal. The back of the house definitely needs some in the weeds training or to 86 the weekend cooks because they cannot keep up with a crowd for the life of them. Which in turn really impacts the front of the house staff.
First visit to Elliot’s. Wife and I split the chicken, bacon and ranch pizza and a taco. Very good and service was great too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Street Tacos, Chicken Bacon Ranch
Great food, plenty of drink options, friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Reuben Sandwich, Crust, Pretzel Sticks with Beer Cheese, Chicken Bacon Ranch
Restaurantji Recommends
Really like this place. Wood fired pizza, nice interior, bar, good service and food. First time here and it was busier than expected on a Monday night. We were still able to get a high top at the bar upon arrival . Casual atmosphere with music playing in the background. Pizza was very good. Apple crisp desert wasn't the best I've had but still good . This is probably one of the better places to have a meal in Pataskala, OH. They have a location in New Albany as well.
Wanted to get some bruschetta but they were all out, no worries, Sunday night. Ordered a margarita pizza and it came out with nothing on it. So basically a cheese pizza. Server said they were out of basil. Ok, what about the sliced mozzarella, tomato’s and olive oil. Nothing on it but regular cheese. Should have told me that so I could get something else. One and only time at this joint
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Great place but very expensive compared to other places. When you're on a fixed income you can't afford to pay $16 for a sandwich and a few fries. My wife and I walked out of there with a $49 bill for two sandwiches fries and cheese curds. We could have went to a local steakhouse and had steaks baked potato salad for less than that.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
We quite enjoy Elliot’s. The tacos are great but the thing that has always been missing is a hamburger. This time they had a hamburger offering it was called a slab burger and actually very very good. We tried to keep it light and shared one of the burgers and got a portobello appetizer, the portobello appetizer is excellent as always.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Street Tacos
Wonderful food, wonderful service. All at an excellent price. The space reminded me of a chilled out "Cheers" pub. This was our first visit (we usually "do" pizza in Granville) since we were on our way back from Columbus this afternoon. Heather was our server...she was AWESOME. We had the hummus platter... excellent and enough for four. And a Margherita pizza with pepperoni -- wonderful too! Will be back when we want a wood fired pizza.