Graeter's Ice Cream

1500 Cross Creeks Blvd, Pickerington
(614) 755-9865

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Double Scoop Waffle Cone
Black Raspberry Chip
Birthday Cake Pint
Cotton Candy Pint
Ice Cream Cakes
Turtle Sundae
Waffle Cones
Mocha Chip
Pints

Menu

Featured items
Perfect Indulgence™ Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip Pint
Our signature flavor is now animal and lactose-free! Made with black raspberries from Oregon's Williamette Valley and our gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips.
Perfect Indulgence™ Madagascar Vanilla Bean Pint
There is nothing plain about our vanilla! Sourced from the Bourbon Isle off the coast of Madagascar, the fresh ground vanilla beans we use are considered the world's finest.
Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip Family Size
Our signature flavor in a larger family size! Made with black raspberries from Oregon's Williamette Valley and our gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips.
Perfect Indulgence™ Cookies & Cream Pint
Oreo® cookies in our Perfect Indulgence™ vanilla. This ice cream is loaded with "America's favorite cookie."
Perfect Indulgence™ Black Cherry Chip Pint
Brimming with sweet dark cherries from the Pacific Northwest in a Perfect Indulgence™ black cherry base, chock full of our dark chocolate chips.

PINTS & FAMILY SIZES
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Pint
Our combination of peanut butter ice cream and milk chocolate chips puts a frozen spin on one of America's favorite treats.
Cookies & Cream Pint
Pieces of America's favorite cookie dunked into Graeter's sweet ice cream will delight every child, including the one inside you!
Midnight Snack Pint
Sweet malt ice cream with chocolate-covered pretzels, brownie bites, and chocolate peanut butter cups.
Mint Chocolate Chip Pint
Pure peppermint oil provides a blast of minty freshness that is pure perfection when matched with our gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips.
Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip Pint
Our signature flavor! Made with black raspberries from Oregon's Williamette Valley and our gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips.
Cotton Candy Pint
Spun with a mouth-watering cotton candy crunch, this nostalgic flavor memories of state fairs, ballgames, and summers gone by, delighting kids of all ages.
Mango Sorbet Pint
Bright and light, our Mango Sorbet is a fresh, cool escape from even the hottest summer day.
Buckeye Blitz Pint
We pay tribute to our home state's famous Ohio buckeye candy with this flavor's blend of peanut butter, cocoa, peanut butter cookie dough, and our gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips.
Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip Pint
We made our Original Salted Caramel ice cream even more decadent with the addition of our gourmet dark chocolate chips.
Vanilla Bean Pint
There is nothing plain about our vanilla! Sourced from the Bourbon Isle off the coast of Madagascar, the fresh ground vanilla beans we use are considered the world's finest.
Dark Chocolate Brownie Pint
A chocolate lover's delight packed with chewy brownie bits complementing the richness of the Dark Chocolate ice cream.
Brown Butter Bourbon Pecan Pint
Gourmet bourbon-glazed pecans in a sweet, boozy brown butter ice cream.
Cookie Dough Chocolate Chip Pint
Our classic vanilla ice cream loaded with bits of cookie dough and our signature dark chocolate chips.
S'mores Pint
Our S'mores ice cream captures the essence of this campfire tradition by adding our signature milk chocolate chips and soft mini marshmallows to a rich, creamy graham cracker ice cream.
Vienna Coffee Pint
Our homage to Vienna Coffee, a traditional espresso and whipped cream pairing, is brewed with a special blend of roasted Sumatran and Columbian Arabica beans. A frozen delight that will warm the soul!
Double Chocolate Chip Pint
A decadent duet of Dutch cocoa and our gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips that will satisfy even the most demanding chocoholic.
Pumpkin Pint
We source the same pumpkin and spices grandma used for her holiday pies, to capture the essence of autumn in our Pumpkin ice cream.
Birthday Cake Pint
Yellow cake flavored ice cream loaded with white cake pieces and colorful sprinkles. A celebration in a pint for our 150th anniversary season!
Oregon Strawberry Pint
We use a special variety of strawberries grown on family farms in Oregon's Williamette Valley that are selected to retain their fresh picked flavor and color.
Boldly Bearcat Pint
a creamy mascarpone ice cream, filled with Oreo cookies and our signature chocolate chips.
Caramel Macchiato Pint
A blend of caramel and coffee ice cream with milk chocolate caramel truffles and toffee pieces.
Toffee Chocolate Chip Pint
We start with our classic vanilla ice cream, mix in crunchy pieces of genuine Heath brand toffee candy, and then perfect it with our gourmet milk chocolate chips.
Butter Pecan Pint
With a generous amount of roasted, buttered, and salted fancy pecans, this is one of our most luxurious flavors.
Coconut Chocolate Chip Pint
Escape to a tropical paradise of frozen delight, combining grated coconut and our gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips
Raspberry Sorbet Pint
Fruity and cool, our Raspberry Sorbet is reminiscent of fresh ripe raspberries on a hot summer day.
Vanilla Chocolate Chip Pint
We make this quintessential American classic by pouring our bittersweet chocolate into a spinning pot of sweet cream flavored with pure Madagascar vanilla extract.
Original Salted Caramel Pint
This is one of our original flavors that we first made over a century ago, and still do by cooking brown sugar and cream with a pinch of salt. Simple, subtle, and sublime!
Mocha Chocolate Chip Pint
Made with our proprietary blend of dark roasted Columbian and Sumatran Arabica coffee beans, mixed with fresh sweet cream, made sublime with the addition of our gourmet bittersweet chocolate.
Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip Family Size
Our signature flavor in a larger family size! Made with black raspberries from Oregon's Williamette Valley and our gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips.
Dutch Milk Chocolate Pint
We source the very finest European cocoa to produce a smooth and sophisticated milk chocolate that is unrivaled.
Black Cherry Chocolate Chip Pint
We make this flavor by pairing sweet dark cherries from the Pacific Northwest with our gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips.
Lemon Sorbet Pint
Bright and light, our Lemon Sorbet is a fresh, cool escape from even the hottest summer day.
Double Chocolate Chip Family Size
Our signature flavor in a larger family size! A decadent duet of Dutch cocoa and our gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips that will satisfy even the most demanding chocoholic.
Vanilla Bean Family Size
There is nothing plain about our vanilla! Sourced from the Bourbon Isle off the coast of Madagascar, the fresh ground vanilla beans we use are considered the world's finest.
Vanilla Chocolate Chip Family Size
Our signature flavor in a larger family size! We make this quintessential American classic by pouring our bittersweet chocolate into a spinning pot of sweet cream flavored with pure Madagascar vanilla.
Peppermint Stick Pint
Get ready for the holidays with a classic red and white treat, dotted with candy and holiday cheer! Our handcrafted, Peppermint Stick ice cream is bejeweled with bits of peppermint candy and flavored with peppermint oil.

PERFECT INDULGENCE™ PINTS
Perfect Indulgence™ Cookies & Cream Pint
Oreo® cookies in our Perfect Indulgence™ vanilla. This ice cream is loaded with "America's favorite cookie."
Perfect Indulgence™ Madagascar Vanilla Bean Pint
There is nothing plain about our vanilla! Sourced from the Bourbon Isle off the coast of Madagascar, the fresh ground vanilla beans we use are considered the world's finest.
Perfect Indulgence™ Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip Pint
Our signature flavor is now animal and lactose-free! Made with black raspberries from Oregon's Williamette Valley and our gourmet bittersweet chocolate chips.
Perfect Indulgence™ Black Cherry Chip Pint
Brimming with sweet dark cherries from the Pacific Northwest in a Perfect Indulgence™ black cherry base, chock full of our dark chocolate chips.

ULTIMATE GIFTS & TRAVEL PACKS
Small Travel Pack
*ONLY guaranteed to stay cold for 24 hours of traveling*Pick up to 6 pints packed and sealed with dry ice. Perfect for traveling! Pints not included in $10 price.
Large Travel Pack
*ONLY guaranteed to stay cold for 24 hours of traveling*Pick up to 12 pints packed and sealed with dry ice. Perfect for traveling! Pints not included in $12 price.
Ultimate Gift
Graeter's cooler, Graeter's scooper, Cups, Spoons, and Napkins. Pints not included in $23.00 price.

CHIP WHEELIES
Vanilla Chocolate Chip Wheelie
Our Madagascar vanilla ice cream with our bittersweet chocolate chips sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies and rolled in chocolate sprinkles.
Double Chocolate Chip Wheelie
Our Dutch cocoa ice cream with bittersweet chocolate chips sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies and rolled in chocolate sprinkles.
Black Raspberry Chip Wheelie
Our signature ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies and rolled in chocolate sprinkles.

ICE CREAM CAKES & PIES
Black Raspberry Pie
Black raspberry chip ice cream, bittersweet topping, and chocolate curls, in a chocolate pie shell.*Custom messaging unavailable for app and online orders.
Cookie Dough Chip Cake
Cookie Dough Chocolate Chip ice cream, yellow cake, bittersweet chocolate, butterscotch whipped topping, mini chocolate chips.*Custom messaging unavailable for app and online orders.
Strawberry Shortcake
Strawberry ice cream, yellow cake, strawberry fruit, strawberry whipped topping.*Custom messaging unavailable for app and online orders.
Cookies & Cream Cake
Cookies and Cream ice cream, chocolate cake, bittersweet chocolate, whipped topping, and mini sandwich cookies.*Custom messaging unavailable for app and online orders.
Celebration Cake
Vanilla ice cream, chocolate cake, bittersweet topping.*Custom messaging unavailable for app and online orders.
Turtle Pie
Butter pecan ice cream, bittersweet chocolate, butterscotch, and pecans in a chocolate pie shell.*Custom messaging unavailable for app and online orders.
Buckeye Pie
Buckeye Blitz® Chocolate Chip ice cream, chocolate graham cracker shell, bittersweet chocolate and peanut butter.*Custom messaging unavailable for app and online orders.

ICE CREAM ESSENTIALS
Waffle Cones
Pack of 4 empty waffle cones.*Price altering additions or substitutions will not be honored.
Sugar Cones
Pack of 12 empty sugar cones.
Cups Spoons & Napkins
8 disposable Graeter's logo cups with spoons and napkins
Graeter's Pint Koozie - Brown
Butterscotch Topping
Rainbow Sprinkles
Graeter's Pint Koozie - Red
Bittersweet Topping
Chocolate Sprinkles
Graeter's Ice Cream Scooper
Ice cream scooper with Graeter's logo
Black Raspberry Topping

DOGGIE DELIGHTS
Dogster Treat 4 Pack
Ice Cream style treats for Dogs!
Dogster Treat
Ice Cream style treats for Dogs!

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: nextdoor
+69 photos
Photo credit: nextdoor
+68 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

It's been around a while in pickerington and a bit hidden, with a great staff and selection of ice cream to choose from and plenty of parking in the front or back of the area. It's a premium ice cream shop so expect to spend more then you would somewhere else but worth the visit!
October 2025
The ice cream was delish and the Teddy bear i bought for my grandsons 11th bday is beautiful,the teddy bear was only $15, reasonable priced,just a nice experience overall its my grandsons 11th birthday weekend. Your staff was so friendly and even gave my grandson a sample of the cookie doh ice cream which he loved and we bought him a waffle sprinkle cone to go with it.
August 2025
Staff is friendly & quick at this location. They have a decent size menu. Drive thru is convenient but parking lot is awful. Limited parking, narrow to get around drive thru and pot holes.
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

CM Chicken - 1510 Cross Creeks Blvd
Korean, Chicken Wings
Skyline Chili - 1530 Cross Creeks Blvd
Fast Food, Hot Dogs
Firehouse Subs Pickerington - 152 Clint Dr
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food

Graeter's Ice Cream

1500 Cross Creeks Blvd, Pickerington, OH 43147
(614) 755-9865