Jersey Mike's Subs

1213 Hill Rd N, Pickerington
(614) 863-3316

Recent Reviews

Sort by
D Ross

The staff hates working here and it shows. The most mediocre and talentless crew of all Jersey Mikes. Embarrassing.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Jon S

Ordered a cold sub 45 minutes ago, when I arrived, they hadn't started working on it and had 5 folks working with only a few customers in the store. I had to wait an additional 25 minutes to get the sub. This happens nearly every time I come here. Poor management.

John McConeghey

Ordered on app to save time. Pickup expected at 11:42am. Still waiting at 12:12pm and order hasn't even been started. New management here is lacking badly. Was never this bad, been eating here for 3 years.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Brody

I love jersey mikes but this store has messed up my order twice and they don’t customize your sandwich as requested.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Myrna Washington

I was so disappointed in how dry my giant pastrami sandwich was. They used to be so much better. Bread was nice and fresh, and it made it possible to eat the sandwich. Will not buy that type of sub again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Gezim Saciri

DO NOT ORDER ONLINE OR THRU THE APP. Otherwise you’ll be waiting around for half an hour past the pickup time watching walk ins get their food before you.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Mickey

We've been going to this location for some time now , but lately the music has been so loud the workers can not hear you and vise versa . During the preparation of the subs , the guy moves so slow you'd think his arms were made of lead , no pep in his step. And to here them say only one slice of cheese per sub , crazy . I had the Philly Steak which was dry with no cheese , he had the #9, Mike's Way , why do we need to tell the work what's on a Mike's way ? Very disappointed. Won't be going back .

Douglas DeVaul

Worst experience I've had at a Jersey Mikes. I hit alot of different locations. Did not follow my special instructions at all. Every pre order was waiting very long time. 4 employees there. 1 not doing anything. The only female employee had a horrible attitude. She asked me my name, then proceeded to lay my subs in a bag at the back of the counter where you couldn't see and didn't even tell me they were laying back there. On top of that, they were the worst made subs I've ever had at a Jersey Mike's. Most of the time our subs are phenomenal. Will not go back to that location.

Charles Trask

They make a good sandwich but whatever you do, don't use the app if you can avoid it. They seem to put you behind all the walk-in orders, even if you come in after your pickup time and stand and wait.. at least 10 people came in waited in line and left before I got food that I had ordered 15 minutes before I arrived. I left extremely unhappy.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Micah George

Very dirty, cleaned same cutting board with same rag for ten + sandwiches. 30 minute wait still no food, had to reorder twice due to incompetence , do not recommend

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Adam Hampson

Don't have one of these where I live so every time I'm some place that has one I'm stopping for sure. This location made me the best Philly I've ever had from there. And it's always good

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Original Sub

Dominiccarson Carson

My steak sub was so dry no lovin in it I though u cook with loving in it

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

Chico13

Got a sub a few weeks ago, food was good, service was good, but it smelled like someone actually took a dump somewhere in the store. It seemed like it was coming from the back, because it smelled the worst as I was ordering and getting my drink. It reeked of straight sewage.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 5

Maya

my family loves jersey Mikes and we honestly prefer jersey mike's over subway , the staff are amazing and polite

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joe John

I'd like some roast beef on my roast beef sub. What is this? I really don't like spending over $10 on a sandwich only to be given a couple thin slices of meat. I'm a regular customer and I've had good experience with this location, but my last couple sandwiches were like this. I guess I'll be taking my money elsewhere in the future.

Edit: I'm still hungry after eating the sub. And for the owner, you can save the canned response.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...