Papa Johns Pizza

1201 Hill Rd N, Pickerington
(614) 864-7272

Recent Reviews

Sort by
John Schmoll

I've always enjoyed my pizza from this location. Some of the other locations are hit & miss, but this location nails it every time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jenita Johnson

I went to pick up my pizza and bites from this place and the food tasted old and burnt. They gave me 1 pepperoni on every other slice. I called to speak to the manager and all he said was I'm sorry but there is nothing I can do about it. I will not go to this place again. Horrible customer service and the food was burnt and not good.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Christina Dawkins

Went into the store tonight first guy that helped us was very nice and helpful , when we went to pick up the pizza they forgot the sauce so we advised the tall guy with blondish hair wearing glasses in the front of the store ,so he went and grabbed the sauce and threw it on the box we asked if he was okay and he gave us the thumbs up, then we were asking for a bag he ignored us so I asked again, and he went to grab one and again just threw it towards us, very rude guy, he definitely should not be working there. I called the store and spoke with the same guy who first helped us, and advised him of what happened and asked for corporate phone number, he didn't give it and said he would talk to the guy and tell him that was not acceptable. If the rude guy doesn't like his job, he should find another one. Not a good look for the store especially when this was our first time there.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Cjj

Extremely unhappy. Ordered two pizzas and didn't notice a FULL ACRYLIC NAIL in my pizza. Called the store and pressed the extension to speak to a manager feeling sick to my stomach to let them know what happened and got hung up on!!! Came to the store and everyone inside started deflecting responsibility telling me the only girl there didn't lose any nails. She walked around the corner with several nails missing. Got a refund but still terrible customer service and a terrible experience. Also nobody in the store wearing gloves was the root of the issue.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Erin Salisbury

I had quite a few boxes to carry by myself & Natalie offered to help immediately, I didn’t even ask. Great customer service. Food was great too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shaunie Castle

If this is the thickness of their original crust, I'd hate to see what their thin crust is like.

Audrey Stine

Management said they wouldn't help me after overcharging me for something they ran out off….. It would be okay if they would charge the price in the menu but i never got my refund .

ChaKira Flenory

Waited almost 2 hours for my food that was quoted 42 minutes. Called to speak to a manager who told me 3 times that the driver had forgotten my food & there was no way it was cold because it was under a warmer in the store. It was in fact cold. Was told he couldn't do anything about it, call back later & then he hungup on me.

Terry Jones

Last three pizzas have been horrible. There was hardly any cheese and the crust wal about 1 1/2 from the edge. I'm done with this joint. I hope all the other franchise is not like this location. Not worth anyone's money!

J J

Ordered a large the works pizza with epic stuffed crust. I just received my order and it was missing the stuffed crust. Tried call and let them know...but no answer 😒

Food: 2

Service: 2

Kim Howard

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and paid $15.99 then while eating it saw the commercial it was $9.99! Ripped me off

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Shirley Hartsell

Large works , center of pizza soggy very wet

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Steve Smith

Domino's is better and cheaper.

William Stringer

Papa Johns is a good pizza option. The sauces they provide on the side plus the banana pepper differentiates then from other national pizza places.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Extra Large New York Style Pizza, Cheese Pizza

Olga L

Great service, very friendly, good pizza. Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...