Pizza Cottage

1000 Old Diley Rd, Pickerington
(614) 856-3333

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dawn Grieves

Our pizza was great. Love their sauce.

Mark Nicholas

You can count on goodness and friendly staff.

Mrace43

Food and service are 5 star. Dining room is okay. Nice patio though if the weather cooperates. Pepsi instead of coke is a downer. I realize this is only an opinion. Coke is too important with pizza. However, the pizza is very good and if you like Pepsi this place is 5 stars!

sylvina nwagbo

Floors extremely dirty

Nebiyu G

Best 🍕

Darlene Lewis

Great food and Kaitlyn and Beth are amazing

George

Have been searching for a new pizza place…..this is definitely not it. Over the years we’ve heard great glowing appraisals of PC. Boy…..are others wrong.

Tried dine in this Monday night 4-21-25. Arriving about 5:10. First impression was the lack of impression what with the basic Formica decor. Just a box. Also interesting groups of people.

Menu was not impressive. Fortunately we had sense to take two when we sat ourselves. Booths soft squishy seating. Get a table if you really have to try it.

Two thin and boy are the cardboard thin all the way personal small pizzas. When presented the is come on a white card board circle the exact diameter of the pie. Hard to handle. However there were black plastic dishes with thin metal knife and fork that are water spotted.

Unsweet tea at least good but served in a blue plastic glass so you have no idea of the looks of whatever drink it contains.

We looked at the pies and each other and knew we’d made a very bad choice picking this wonderous place.

Well when hungry. You eat. Did stop at a store on the way home to buy makings for a second dinner. Pie ingredients included poverty sliced thin thin onions and peppers that were mostly unbaked. Mushrooms pepperoni and sausage mystery meat globuals.

Used restrooms on the way out that were dank and cold with and extra strong wafting of fabulous or some such smelly cleaner. Great when mixed with damp restroom smell.

Impressed by the wad of napkins used to hold a meeting room door open.

Thus is my one only and never again experience!

Received a nice message regular mail from I presume corporate. A money off coupon for a second visit was included.

That immediately went into the trash as who’d wanted to return after our first experience.

DeSean Herself

I don’t like having to talk with an AI for
Placing an order now but still was still great & young lady at the drive thru provided awesome service!

Chad M

Excellent restaurant. We used the party room which is very convenient.

Sarah Mathys

Good food, unclean seats, opened my menu and there was something inside of it. But service was good, very quiet and kind of dystopian but still a great restaurant

Susan Safreed

Had a small gathering on 3/29/25. We used the party room and could not have been more pleased. The staff was super helpful in setting up the tables so we could communicate to one another. Our server went out of her way to make sure we were satisfied! Great job!

Dee Sims

So I came here after a doctors appointment hungry wanting something good to eat. I didn't actually have a pizza so I may give them another chance for the pizza, but I definitely did not like the sub sandwiches. I had an Italian sub that was just mediocre at best. I asked for extra cheese and was charged for extra cheese, but I did not receive it. They also have vinaigrette dressing which I am not a fan of oil based dressing. Overall, the customer service was great my server her name is Lisa and she was nice.

Terie Lynne

Great pizza and subs

Linda Shoot

We had the party room for my granddaughter's 1st birthday party. It was very clean and waiters were great supplying pizzas, pop, and salads. We will definately use room again!

Kelsea Caldwell

Potatoe pizza was really good! Just not enough sour cream

Loading...