Im pretty upset. Save your money and skip going to " pizzeria new york " in pickerington. Ive wanted to check this place out for months. $24 for a medium white pizza $26 for large so i got a half cheese half pep for $17.50. When i arrived i opened it and felt immediate regret. I asked where the rest of the peperonis were. I mean the cheese covers 80% of the pizza and it doesnt even look appealing. The crust looked and taste like gas station pizza. Its spongy. The kid working the desk was of no help just said this is how it normally looks. If I wasn't starving I would've left it there. Overpriced below average definitely 100% not New York pizza, what a joke.
Reply to owner, you should go to New York and get pizza and realize your name should be changed its nothing close. Brooklyn pizza in Powell wayy more on target. Train adequate staff helps.
Corey Thompson
The pizza is delicious but whatever time they quote for pick up add at least 10 minutes. The food may be a little late but it’s worth it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
J WV
This is, in my opinion, tied for the best pizza in the Columbus area. Especially if you are looking for pizza that is similar to what is served in the NYC/NJ area. It can be hard to find a pizzeria that doesn't cut the pies into squares and has decent sauce and crust. These guys know what they are doing when it comes to making a cheese pie. When ordering, def go for the XL.
l k
Good eating I'm originally from New York the pizza reminds me of the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
George Wilson
Great pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
wesley weist
We live in carroll and love to try new smaller businesses we loved the food and service was absolutely great
Whenever I crave a New York slice, this is my go-to spot. I always order my pizza with triple cheese, and it never disappoints. However, we decided to try the boneless wings this time, and I can't recommend them. The wings were drenched in sauce, the breading was falling off, and the chicken didn't taste good. We'll stick to just the pizza from now on, and I strongly advise against ordering the boneless wings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Extra Cheese Pizza
Tineal O
Last night was the second time we ordered pizza within the last two weeks here. The first time it was amazing so we decided to return and invite our family from out of town. I ordered the Paps special 16 inch. My brother and sister ordered stuffed shells, meatballs, and a 14 inch Philly cheese steak pizza. We made it to the next light and called because we’ve never had a Philly cheese steak with pizza sauce. We called and asked for something else. We were advised that we would receive the difference in price, but they never processed it. I then decided to eat a slice of my pap while we waited and immediately noticed there was no sausage. I went inside to show him. He laughed and said “Oh I forgot to tell you we have no sausage.” He promised a difference in the price. I paid $27 for an incorrect pizza that is still sitting in the refrigerator. The taste was not as good as the first time. I also noticed while we were waiting that the guy taking the pizzas out of the oven did not wash his hands. He would sweep the floor and then take a pizza out of the oven and cut it with his hands on the crust. This is unacceptable. I will wait the remainder of this week for both refunds that were promised before reaching out to my bank.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Stan Thomas
Ordered here about 5 times and each time my pizza has been bland at best. Pizza is a three stars and their website is a one star. Sorry, there is just a better pizza and an experience in all categories locally.
We found this place about a year ago and we absolutely love it!! Everything that we have tried there has been phenomenal!! The customer service is amazing, the prices are just right and if I could eat it everyday I would. You have got to try the pinwheels they are out of this world and totally addictive.
Best brick oven pizza! Half cheese, half extra extra cheese is a favorite in our house!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Shells
rae whoo
Best brick oven pizza! Half cheese, half extra extra cheese is a favorite in our house!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Shells
John mcneely
Last night was the first night I have ordered from here. I've lived in canal winchester for 6 years and will have to say this was by far the best cheese pizza I have ever had. Definitely found my new pizza place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breadsticks, Cheese Pizza
Kaitlin Smart
Just came to say the customer service here is wonderful. I had a small issue with a charge on my credit card and the owner of the business gave me her personal cell phone number, told me to message her the details, and even replied to my texts when she was on vacation out of the country!!
Im pretty upset. Save your money and skip going to " pizzeria new york " in pickerington. Ive wanted to check this place out for months. $24 for a medium white pizza $26 for large so i got a half cheese half pep for $17.50. When i arrived i opened it and felt immediate regret. I asked where the rest of the peperonis were. I mean the cheese covers 80% of the pizza and it doesnt even look appealing. The crust looked and taste like gas station pizza. Its spongy. The kid working the desk was of no help just said this is how it normally looks. If I wasn't starving I would've left it there. Overpriced below average definitely 100% not New York pizza, what a joke.
Reply to owner, you should go to New York and get pizza and realize your name should be changed its nothing close. Brooklyn pizza in Powell wayy more on target. Train adequate staff helps.
The pizza is delicious but whatever time they quote for pick up add at least 10 minutes. The food may be a little late but it’s worth it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
This is, in my opinion, tied for the best pizza in the Columbus area. Especially if you are looking for pizza that is similar to what is served in the NYC/NJ area. It can be hard to find a pizzeria that doesn't cut the pies into squares and has decent sauce and crust. These guys know what they are doing when it comes to making a cheese pie. When ordering, def go for the XL.
Good eating I'm originally from New York the pizza reminds me of the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We live in carroll and love to try new smaller businesses we loved the food and service was absolutely great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Teriyaki Chicken Wings
Whenever I crave a New York slice, this is my go-to spot. I always order my pizza with triple cheese, and it never disappoints. However, we decided to try the boneless wings this time, and I can't recommend them. The wings were drenched in sauce, the breading was falling off, and the chicken didn't taste good. We'll stick to just the pizza from now on, and I strongly advise against ordering the boneless wings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Extra Cheese Pizza
Last night was the second time we ordered pizza within the last two weeks here. The first time it was amazing so we decided to return and invite our family from out of town. I ordered the Paps special 16 inch. My brother and sister ordered stuffed shells, meatballs, and a 14 inch Philly cheese steak pizza. We made it to the next light and called because we’ve never had a Philly cheese steak with pizza sauce. We called and asked for something else. We were advised that we would receive the difference in price, but they never processed it. I then decided to eat a slice of my pap while we waited and immediately noticed there was no sausage. I went inside to show him. He laughed and said “Oh I forgot to tell you we have no sausage.” He promised a difference in the price. I paid $27 for an incorrect pizza that is still sitting in the refrigerator. The taste was not as good as the first time. I also noticed while we were waiting that the guy taking the pizzas out of the oven did not wash his hands. He would sweep the floor and then take a pizza out of the oven and cut it with his hands on the crust. This is unacceptable. I will wait the remainder of this week for both refunds that were promised before reaching out to my bank.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ordered here about 5 times and each time my pizza has been bland at best. Pizza is a three stars and their website is a one star. Sorry, there is just a better pizza and an experience in all categories locally.
Never disappoints! Fast, friendly and delicious.
Restaurantji Recommends
We found this place about a year ago and we absolutely love it!! Everything that we have tried there has been phenomenal!! The customer service is amazing, the prices are just right and if I could eat it everyday I would. You have got to try the pinwheels they are out of this world and totally addictive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Onion Rings, Garlic Knots, Garlic Bread, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, 6in Grilled Chicken Sub, Lasagna, Pinwheels, Meat Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Breadsticks, House Salad, Cheese Cake
Best brick oven pizza! Half cheese, half extra extra cheese is a favorite in our house!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Shells
Best brick oven pizza! Half cheese, half extra extra cheese is a favorite in our house!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Shells
Last night was the first night I have ordered from here. I've lived in canal winchester for 6 years and will have to say this was by far the best cheese pizza I have ever had. Definitely found my new pizza place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breadsticks, Cheese Pizza
Just came to say the customer service here is wonderful. I had a small issue with a charge on my credit card and the owner of the business gave me her personal cell phone number, told me to message her the details, and even replied to my texts when she was on vacation out of the country!!
Service: 5
Loading...