Pizzeria New York
833 Hill Rd N, Pickerington
(614) 862-4743
Customers' Favorites
6in Grilled Chicken Sub
Teriyaki Chicken Wings
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Extra Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Zucchini Sticks
Stuffed Shells
Garlic Bread
Garlic Knots
Breadsticks
Menu
Photos
+25 photos
+24 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This is, in my opinion, tied for the best pizza in the Columbus area. Especially if you are looking for pizza that is similar to what is served in the NYC/NJ area. It can be hard to find a pizzeria that doesn't cut the pies into squares and has decent sauce and crust. These guys know what they are doing when it comes to making a cheese pie. When ordering, def go for the XL.
Whenever I crave a New York slice, this is my go-to spot. I always order my pizza with triple cheese, and it never disappoints. However, we decided to try the boneless wings this time, and I can't recommend them. The wings were drenched in sauce, the breading was falling off, and the chicken didn't taste good. We'll stick to just the pizza from now on, and I strongly advise against ordering the boneless wings.
Ordered here about 5 times and each time my pizza has been bland at best. Pizza is a three stars and their website is a one star. Sorry, there is just a better pizza and an experience in all categories locally.
You May Also Like
Finnegan's Wake - 841 Hill Rd N
![]()
Bar, Irish Pub, Music Venues
Reunion Asian Kitchen - 805 Hill Rd N
![]()
Asian, Chinese, Soup, Thai, Vegetarian
The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Pickerington - 797 Hill Rd N
![]()
Fish & Chips, Irish, American, Vegetarian