Porters Coffee House and Bakery

194 W Church St, Pickerington
(614) 783-4830

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Staci Inskeep Schutzler

Quiet surroundings and yummy coffee! ☕️

Riley Asher

Amazing coffee and treats, plus a beautiful spot. They never disappoint.

Hem Rizal

This is our favorite coffee shop in the area. The selections are great and our favorite is The Islander. We frequent this place every time we feel like this.

Fourcorner

Very disappointed, the manager with the black hair was very disrespectful and gave a disgusting look after asking a simple question. She seemed very uninterested in helping her guests and gave a bad taste to the company.

Erica Howe

I just love this place. Everyone is friendly. The food and drinks are always so fresh and tasty. The atmosphere is great. Thanks for being an amazing attribute to your community. 🖤 Ps they did our wedding cake and cupcakes back in 2021 and were wonderful!

Ariana Semon

My favorite coffee shop! The baked goods and breakfast items are always so amazing as well as the coffee. My husband and I also got our wedding cake from hoarders and had so many compliments on how good it was.

Carolina B.

If you're looking for a cozy, welcoming spot to enjoy a great cup of coffee and delicious homemade baked goods, Porters Coffee House & Bakery is the place to be! From the moment you walk in, the warm and inviting atmosphere makes you feel right at home.

The coffee is top-notch—smooth, rich, and expertly brewed. Whether you prefer a classic espresso, a creamy latte, or a seasonal specialty, they have something to satisfy every coffee lover. Their pastries and baked goods are just as impressive—freshly made, beautifully presented, and absolutely delicious. The selection includes everything from flaky croissants to decadent cakes and cookies, perfect for pairing with your drink.

The staff is friendly and attentive, always ready with a smile and helpful recommendations. It's the kind of place where you can relax with a book, catch up with friends, or even get some work done in a peaceful setting.

If you haven’t been to Porters Coffee House & Bakery yet, do yourself a favor and stop by—you won’t be disappointed!
I do recommend this place !

Cassie B

Their baked goods are delicious, but their coffee definitely needs a lift, I’ve gone back for coffee 3 times hoping maybe it was just an off day but no, it’s just the coffee.

Kaitlin Robbins

Went to porters at 4pm they don’t close until 6. I sat at the speaker in the drive through for a couple minutes without anyone taking my order. I even honked and nothing. I could see an employee walking around inside and the Open Sign was light up so I just left without getting coffee.

Erin MC

Love this coffee so much I wish they would expand into Lancaster. We have no coffee shops the north end of town. No coffee compares. There are very few places that make me a latte and I can actually taste the coffee. Best coffee I’ve had since my time in Australia.

Ashley Lyon

We love Porters! Their food is amazing and their coffee is the best in town!

Tara Bebinger

I would give this 10 stars if it was a choice. The cinnamon roll is a must and it's not overly sweet either...just perfect. Ask them to warm it up for you. I also tried the maple oat hot chai, also not overly sweet and a nice mild flavor. The decor here, especially in the bathroom is rustic, charming, eclectic. Staff were very friendly. They have a cooler of ready made crossaint sandwiches and other items as well. Small parking lot but easy to park on one side of Church St. The other side is permit parking only. There is a front porch with seasonal seating and two interior rooms for seating. Overall, a top notch coffee shop with wonderful pastries and breakfast/brunch options.

Bobby Griffith

Great place!

Jennifer Hess Ramsey

Porters made the cake for our wedding and it was so beautiful and delicious! It was easy to order online for the date we needed and they provided a classic design that we loved. We received many compliments from our guests about the cake! We’ve visited Porters many times for coffee and baked goods, and we were so happy to be able to include them in our wedding celebration!

Rebecca Dillon

Love this coffee shop! The drowsy traveler is one of my favorites! Also love that they have a reward system to earn free drinks! The chocolate eclair seasonal drink is also one of my favorites around Valentines Day! The cheesecakes and cinnamon rolls are also great.

Loading...