This place has the BEST sauce on their pizzas! So sweet! If you haven't tried Romeos you will not be disappointed. The deep dish pizza is just omg! Mouth watering right now.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Romeo's Deluxe Pizza, Breadsticks, Plates and Napkins 4
Larry Reams
This is really a takeout or delivery business only in Pickerington Ohio. Everyone has their own favorite type of pizza taste. Strangely enough my favorite pizza is just to the east of the capital of Iceland. My destiny United States is MOD Pizza which is similar with a thinner crust and high quality fresh ingredients with a very friendly staff. But if I'm looking at what we consider we regularly find as pizza then Romeo's Pizza certainly is my favorite by far. The combination of crust taste and thickness as well as the overall flavor profile simply hits me as much more desirable than the other types I have tasted. Since this is decidedly a bit different the best thing to do is try it out and see what you think because you're still going to enjoy a meal and you might find something that you want to come back to often.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Romeo's Deluxe Pizza
Chris Hiles
The cashier was super nice. ☺️ (I was there 09/18/2025 around 7:30pm. I wish I could remember her name.) BOGO on Tuesday's Price point is pretty good. The pizza was OK.
Food: 3
Service: 4
Kelley Forsythe
The best. Capone sauce is special.
Update: Now I don't like them! Apparently they have changed their ordering ap. It's absolutely impossible! Where is my data? Where are my points? Where is my credit card information. Sorry romeo's. I will not be ordering from you anymore.
Food: 5
Service: 1
Drew Riley
Would have been nice to put some cheese on the pizza. I received two pizzas with sauce and peps and VERY little cheese.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Jamison Poore
Didnt get to try the food. Ordered an online order around 6:45pm a timed delivery for 7:30pm Around 7:45pm I called to see what the status was. Waited for 20 mins and talked to no one. Called back at 8:30pm they said they haven't even started it. And would cancel the order and give me my money back.... ill never order here again. No call no sense of urgency to fix the issue from the mgmt. Just sorry you trusted us to make your dinner tonight. I hope your not hungry at 8:30pm. Incredibly disappointed.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tyler Dietrich
They blamed a new system for their lack of customer service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pat Lee
I ordered one large pizza. I had trouble using the online tracker so I had to call to confirm the status of my order. The young lady I spoke with was pleasant, however, she told me the delivery would take an additional 20-30 minutes from the time I was quoted when the order was placed. Order to delivery took 1 hour and 5 minutes. I would have been okay with this if the pizza wasn't cold when it arrived. One slice looked as if someone missed a spot when sprinkling the cheese on. I'll accept this as a lesson learned. Still looking for a good pizza spot in the area!
Tequilla Washington
One of my favorite pizza places.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Jane Mahaffey
Ordered delivery. One pizza was supposed to be a Tuscan with mushrooms. Didn't have any pepperoni on it at all. Not sure it was the right pizza. Other pizza and wings were fine. Normally don't have any issues.
Unique take on pizza and deep dish pizza. if you like sweet sauce this place is pretty good, but if you don’t like sweet sauce, you’ll be confused. Wish they had a more savory tomato sauce option that they top their pizza with. Their ingredients other than the sauce is really good.
Greg McMillin
Prompt service and friendly staff. Pizza order confirmed at time of pick-up for accuracy. Everything was accurate and ready on time.
Green Bastard
Excellent pizza. However the center pieces were a bit soggy.
Colin Schmitt
Wonderful pizza, it’s always hot and fresh when I come to pick up and is always ready by the specified timeframe (20 minutes if ordering ASAP) and sometimes is even done earlier.
Sometimes the pizza can get really greasy and get all over the box making a mess but it has been a rare occasion for me. The Capone sauce makes up for it though; it is a flavorful and unique spicy sauce that any spice-tolerant person would enjoy.
The people in there are always nice, they welcome me in and assist me promptly. It also seems like their teamwork and morale is high as I always notice the workers laughing and working well together.
The app is pretty barebones but it gets the job done. I prefer ordering on there so I can receive rewards points because I don’t think you can in the web browser version. My only complaint is I wish the rewards system was fleshed out a bit more. Every 100 points ($100) you get a $10 off coupon for your next order. It’s nice but I wish there were more options for redeeming.
Overall, great food, atmosphere, and experience. Love the stuffed crust!
This place has the BEST sauce on their pizzas! So sweet! If you haven't tried Romeos you will not be disappointed. The deep dish pizza is just omg! Mouth watering right now.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Romeo's Deluxe Pizza, Breadsticks, Plates and Napkins 4
This is really a takeout or delivery business only in Pickerington Ohio. Everyone has their own favorite type of pizza taste. Strangely enough my favorite pizza is just to the east of the capital of Iceland. My destiny United States is MOD Pizza which is similar with a thinner crust and high quality fresh ingredients with a very friendly staff. But if I'm looking at what we consider we regularly find as pizza then Romeo's Pizza certainly is my favorite by far. The combination of crust taste and thickness as well as the overall flavor profile simply hits me as much more desirable than the other types I have tasted. Since this is decidedly a bit different the best thing to do is try it out and see what you think because you're still going to enjoy a meal and you might find something that you want to come back to often.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Romeo's Deluxe Pizza
The cashier was super nice. ☺️
(I was there 09/18/2025 around 7:30pm. I wish I could remember her name.)
BOGO on Tuesday's
Price point is pretty good.
The pizza was OK.
Food: 3
Service: 4
The best. Capone sauce is special.
Update: Now I don't like them! Apparently they have changed their ordering ap. It's absolutely impossible! Where is my data? Where are my points? Where is my credit card information. Sorry romeo's. I will not be ordering from you anymore.
Food: 5
Service: 1
Would have been nice to put some cheese on the pizza. I received two pizzas with sauce and peps and VERY little cheese.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Didnt get to try the food. Ordered an online order around 6:45pm a timed delivery for 7:30pm
Around 7:45pm I called to see what the status was. Waited for 20 mins and talked to no one.
Called back at 8:30pm they said they haven't even started it. And would cancel the order and give me my money back.... ill never order here again. No call no sense of urgency to fix the issue from the mgmt.
Just sorry you trusted us to make your dinner tonight. I hope your not hungry at 8:30pm.
Incredibly disappointed.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
They blamed a new system for their lack of customer service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I ordered one large pizza. I had trouble using the online tracker so I had to call to confirm the status of my order. The young lady I spoke with was pleasant, however, she told me the delivery would take an additional 20-30 minutes from the time I was quoted when the order was placed. Order to delivery took 1 hour and 5 minutes. I would have been okay with this if the pizza wasn't cold when it arrived. One slice looked as if someone missed a spot when sprinkling the cheese on. I'll accept this as a lesson learned. Still looking for a good pizza spot in the area!
One of my favorite pizza places.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Ordered delivery. One pizza was supposed to be a Tuscan with mushrooms. Didn't have any pepperoni on it at all. Not sure it was the right pizza. Other pizza and wings were fine. Normally don't have any issues.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Very good pizza. Very limited parking.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Unique take on pizza and deep dish pizza. if you like sweet sauce this place is pretty good, but if you don’t like sweet sauce, you’ll be confused. Wish they had a more savory tomato sauce option that they top their pizza with. Their ingredients other than the sauce is really good.
Prompt service and friendly staff. Pizza order confirmed at time of pick-up for accuracy. Everything was accurate and ready on time.
Excellent pizza. However the center pieces were a bit soggy.
Wonderful pizza, it’s always hot and fresh when I come to pick up and is always ready by the specified timeframe (20 minutes if ordering ASAP) and sometimes is even done earlier.
Sometimes the pizza can get really greasy and get all over the box making a mess but it has been a rare occasion for me. The Capone sauce makes up for it though; it is a flavorful and unique spicy sauce that any spice-tolerant person would enjoy.
The people in there are always nice, they welcome me in and assist me promptly. It also seems like their teamwork and morale is high as I always notice the workers laughing and working well together.
The app is pretty barebones but it gets the job done. I prefer ordering on there so I can receive rewards points because I don’t think you can in the web browser version. My only complaint is I wish the rewards system was fleshed out a bit more. Every 100 points ($100) you get a $10 off coupon for your next order. It’s nice but I wish there were more options for redeeming.
Overall, great food, atmosphere, and experience. Love the stuffed crust!
Loading...