The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Pickerington

797 Hill Rd N, Pickerington
(614) 834-3927

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Gay Lord's Favorite Burger
Chicken Tenders Basket
Hand-Battered Mushrooms
Jumbo Bavarian Pretzel
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Kid's Fish and Chips
Double Cheeseburger
Philly Cheese Steak
Loaded Potato Skins
Fish \u0026 Chips

Menu

Featured items
Fish & Chips
Traditional British style, hand-battered & fried Cold Water Atlantic Haddock. Served with steak fries, a side garnish of coleslaw & tartar sauce
Traditional Reuben
House made corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut & 1000 island dressing between two slices of grilled marble rye
Chicken Tender Basket
Hand-battered & fried. Served with a choice of dipping sauce
French Dip
Shaved tender ribeye topped with sautéed onions & melted Swiss cheese on a hoagie. Served with hot au jus
Carrot Cake
An old family recipe made in-house and topped with cream cheese icing. Each piece sliced to order
Chicken Cobb
Large bed of chopped romaine topped with tomato, diced egg, feta cheese, bacon & marinated onion. Served with freshly grilled chicken & choice of dressing
Atlantic Salmon
Char-grilled or blackened, served with wild rice, a choice of side & dill cream sauce | Choose two sides
Spicy Chicken Quesadilla
Philly Cheese Steak
Mussels & Jumbo Shrimp

Starters (3PD)
Fried Pickles
Jumbo Pretzel
Loaded Skins
Fried Mushrooms
Fresh button mushrooms battered & deep fried, served with a horseradish dipping sauce
Nachos
Cheese Curds

Wings (3PD)
10 Bone-In Wings
A classic - fried & tossed in a choice of sauce
5 Bone-In Wings
A classic - fried & tossed in a choice of sauce
12 Bone-Out Wings
6 Bone-Out Wings

Soups & Salads (3PD)
Full Spinach Salad
Baby spinach topped with mushrooms, bacon, chopped egg & fresh red onion. Served with choice of dressing on the side
Chicken Cobb
Large bed of chopped romaine topped with tomato, diced egg, feta cheese, bacon & marinated onion. Served with freshly grilled chicken & choice of dressing
French Onion
Full House Salad
New England Clam Chowder
Half House Salad
Wedge Salad
Half Caesar Salad
Full Caesar Salad
Half Spinach Salad
Soup of the Day

Hand Helds (3PD)
Spicy Chicken Quesadilla
Chicken Tender Basket
Hand-battered & fried. Served with a choice of dipping sauce
Philly Cheese Steak
French Dip
Shaved tender ribeye topped with sautéed onions & melted Swiss cheese on a hoagie. Served with hot au jus
Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Burgers & Reubens (3PD)
Traditional Reuben
House made corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut & 1000 island dressing between two slices of grilled marble rye
Bernie Chicken Sandwich
New England Reuben
Gaylord Burger
Rustic Burger
Cowboy Burger
Bernadette Burger
Sesame Ginger Chicken Sandwich

Seafood & Steak (3PD)
Fish & Chips
Traditional British style, hand-battered & fried Cold Water Atlantic Haddock. Served with steak fries, a side garnish of coleslaw & tartar sauce
Mussels & Jumbo Shrimp
Fish Tacos
Our Cold Water Atlantic Haddock, blackened or deep fried, served inside three soft flour taco shells topped with a spicy shredded lettuce slaw & salsa. Served with tortilla chips & a side of sour cream
Atlantic Salmon
Char-grilled or blackened, served with wild rice, a choice of side & dill cream sauce | Choose two sides
Shrimp & Chips
Shrimp hand-battered & fried, served with steak fries, a side garnish of coleslaw & cocktail sauce
Fish Sandwich
Our Cold Water Atlantic Haddock hand-battered & fried Traditional or Eddie Style, blackened or pan seared, served with lettuce, tomato, onion on a hoagie roll & a side of steak or thin fries
Shrimp & Fish Platter
Shrimp Po'Boy

Sides (3PD)
Steak Fries
Fried Corn
French Fries
Onion Ring Side
Coleslaw
Wild Rice
Tots
Kabob Veggies
Garlic Bread
Applesauce
Kettle Chips
Fruit Cup
Tortilla Chips

Desserts (3PD)
Carrot Cake
An old family recipe made in-house and topped with cream cheese icing. Each piece sliced to order
Bread Pudding
Chocolate Cake

Kids Menu (3PD)
Kid Chicken Tenders
Kid Fish & Chips
Kid Cheeseburger
Kid Grilled Cheese
Kid Mini Corn Dogs
Kid Mac & Cheese
Kid Shrimp & Chips

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+45 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+44 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We’ve always loved Old Bag of Nails! Last night I got the boneless wings, they are always my go-to, so good and crispy. My husband loves the buffalo chicken wrap. We also got the spinach artichoke dip, very yummy! I got a fun Watermelon drink, it was so good! Service here is always great, pleasant and helpful!
October 2025
The food was fresh. That's all I was worried about to begin with. Very tasty food and the TV was right at our booth and I like that. We chatted with our waitress about our pets and she was so nice.
October 2025
We ventured here tonight for the first time. Wanted a quick bite before going to the Pickerington North band competition to watch our son. Food was excellent! Our server was Steph and she was friendly, diligent, and did everything very well. I loved the ambiance of the place!! I’ve always heard of people going to this place, super happy I got to try it out!
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Reunion Asian Kitchen - 805 Hill Rd N
Asian, Chinese, Soup, Thai, Vegetarian
Pizzeria New York - 833 Hill Rd N
Pizza, Italian
Finnegan's Wake - 841 Hill Rd N
Bar, Irish Pub, Music Venues

The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Pickerington

797 Hill Rd N, Pickerington, OH 43147
(614) 834-3927