I really enjoy this place because it's pretty authentic to New York pizza. The service was quick and staff were friendly. The diningroom is small but have a few seats outside. Recommended.
Andrea Montero
The best NY style pizza!
Geoff Schmidt
I just tried to pay for a big order over the phone with my credit card and was refused that option. My daughter is picking up the 100 dollar plus order and I did want her to have to pay for it. I was in the restaurant business for 60 years and know my request was not abnormal for other establishments. They have great pizzas but going out of their way to satisfy a customer was beyond their reach.
Donnie Conn
The only place I can think of that sells a single slice. The pizza is ready good. I just got a Stromboli and it was unbelievably good. Every time I’ve gone there they have been extremely friendly.
Devin Durbin
First time visitors. Literally came on a Reddit recommendation as we try and branch out from the normal places. Dang! They crushed it. I love a New York style pie and this was a legit offering! We ate a whole large pizza and we had no business eating that much. I forgot to even document it until it was gone. 10/10
Steve Croyle
It's a carryout shop but possibly the best pizza in Columbus.
Never disappointed except in the early closing hours.
Clear Water Prowash
Awesome pizza. My eyes were bigger than my stomach. Pizza by the slice but each piece is like 2. Great value for your pocket and your taste buds!
Richard Boggs (Rich)
Not an eat in place but the best New York style pizza in Columbus. Always friendly staff. Our go to pizza place with an ABSOLUTELY outstanding white pizza.
Kaylan Lewin
This was some of the worst pizza imaginable. We got one with sausage and banana peppers and one with just cheese. Both were trash. Were they made a couple days ago and just sitting on a counter the whole time? Maybe. Absolutely awful. And the calzone was terrible too. Such a waste of money. Total disappointment
Pizza is good, multiple fees that no one was able to explain what they were for.
Cam Stover
Walked in, and the guy was unimaginably rude—zero understanding of what it means to serve the customer, it’s apparent customer service is not a priority here. Hands down the worst experience I’ve ever had at a pizza place. I will never be back, nor will my family. We’ll be praying for that very angry man. God bless.
Kerah Murphy
Thought I would stop and try and I will say it's really good
Best pizza in Ohio, hands down!
I really enjoy this place because it's pretty authentic to New York pizza. The service was quick and staff were friendly. The diningroom is small but have a few seats outside. Recommended.
The best NY style pizza!
I just tried to pay for a big order over the phone with my credit card and was refused that option. My daughter is picking up the 100 dollar plus order and I did want her to have to pay for it. I was in the restaurant business for 60 years and know my request was not abnormal for other establishments. They have great pizzas but going out of their way to satisfy a customer was beyond their reach.
The only place I can think of that sells a single slice. The pizza is ready good. I just got a Stromboli and it was unbelievably good.
Every time I’ve gone there they have been extremely friendly.
First time visitors. Literally came on a Reddit recommendation as we try and branch out from the normal places. Dang! They crushed it. I love a New York style pie and this was a legit offering! We ate a whole large pizza and we had no business eating that much. I forgot to even document it until it was gone. 10/10
It's a carryout shop but possibly the best pizza in Columbus.
Never disappointed except in the early closing hours.
Awesome pizza. My eyes were bigger than my stomach. Pizza by the slice but each piece is like 2. Great value for your pocket and your taste buds!
Not an eat in place but the best New York style pizza in Columbus. Always friendly staff. Our go to pizza place with an ABSOLUTELY outstanding white pizza.
This was some of the worst pizza imaginable. We got one with sausage and banana peppers and one with just cheese. Both were trash. Were they made a couple days ago and just sitting on a counter the whole time? Maybe. Absolutely awful. And the calzone was terrible too. Such a waste of money. Total disappointment
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza is good, multiple fees that no one was able to explain what they were for.
Walked in, and the guy was unimaginably rude—zero understanding of what it means to serve the customer, it’s apparent customer service is not a priority here. Hands down the worst experience I’ve ever had at a pizza place. I will never be back, nor will my family. We’ll be praying for that very angry man. God bless.
Thought I would stop and try and I will say it's really good
Amazing pizza and calzones. High quality.
Owners from ny so you know they good people's
Loading...