Pizzeria New York

7950 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg
(614) 868-3870

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

One Topping Cheese Pizza
Side of Mikes Hot Honey
Bone in Chicken Wings
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza New York
Garlic Knots
Breadsticks
Italian

Menu

Appetizers
Breadsticks (4 pcs)
Served with our homemade marinara sauce.
Cheezy Breadsticks
Eight pieces of breadsticks smothered in mozzarella cheese served with garlic butter or marinara sauce.
Mozzarella Sticks (6 pcs)
Served with our homemade marinara sauce.
Loaded Fries (Basket)
Smothered with Cheddar cheese and bacon.
French Fries (Basket)
Pinwheels (4 pcs)
Choose plain, cheese, or pepperoni. Served with our homemade marinara sauce.
Baked Meatballs (3 pcs)
Homemade meatballs smothered with mozzarella and marinara sauce.
Garlic Bread
Garlic Knots (5 pcs)
Onion Rings

Wings and Tenders
Chicken Wings (10 pcs)
Choose mild, hot, BBQ, teriyaki, cajun, Caribbean jerk, and garlic parm or blackened bourbon sauce.
Boneless Wings
Chicken Tenders
Five chicken breast tenders served with dipping sauce.

Salads
Tossed Salad
Iceberg lettuce, sliced red onion, tomatoes with shredded provolone, and croutons.
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce, croutons, imported romano cheese, and Caesar dressing.
Fried Chicken Salad
Served with chicken tenders (plain or tossed with our wing sauce) on a bed of mixed lettuce, topped with red onions, Cheddar cheese, and tomatoes.
Greek Salad
Mixed lettuce with feta and romano cheeses, red onions, Cheddar cheese, and tomatoes.

Oven-Baked Subs
Cajun Bourbon Chicken Sub
Fried chicken tenders smothered in bourbon sauce and mozzarella.
BBQ Chicken Sub
Fried chicken tenders smothered in mozzarella with BBQ sauce.
Veggie Sub
Grilled onions, mushrooms, green peppers, tomatoes, and provolone cheese.
Eggplant Parmigiano Sub
Seasoned eggplant, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
Meatball Parmigiano Sub
Hand-rolled meatballs, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
Philly Cheese Steak Sub
Sirloin tip steak, sauteed onions, green peppers, and provolone cheese.
Grilled Chicken Sub
Grilled chicken, provolone cheese with sauteed onions, and green peppers.

Specialty Pies
New York White Pizza Pie
Ricotta, garlic, sliced tomatoes, and mozzarella.
Veggie Primavera Pie
Onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and sliced tomatoes.
Eggplant Parm Pizza Pie
Eggplant smothered with mozzarella cheese and homemade sauce.
Taco Pizza Pie
Seasoned beef, crumbled tortilla chips, Cheddar and mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato with sour cream, and Jalapeno on the side.
Chicken Alfredo Pizza Pie
Seasoned chicken, mozzarella, green peppers, and homemade alfredo sauce.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Pie
Hot and spicy chicken and mozzarella with a side of blue cheese or ranch dressing.
Barbecue Chicken Pizza Pie
Grilled chicken covered in barbecue sauce and topped with mozzarella.
Philly Cheese Steak Pizza Pie
Shaved steak with sauteed green peppers and onions.
Greek Pizza Pie
Feta, red onions, sauteed spinach, and black olives.
Chicken Bourbon Pizza Pie
Seasoned chicken, bacon, sauteed red onions over bourbon sauce, and mozzarella.

Calzones, Strombolis, and Pinwheels
Calzone
A moon-like shaped dough baked to a flaky crust, stuffed with up to 3 regular pizza toppings, and our homemade marinara sauce on the side.
Stromboli
A roll-like shaped dough baked to a flaky crust, stuffed with up to 3 regular pizza toppings, and our homemade marinara sauce on the side.
Pinwheels (4 pcs)
Flaky bite-size crescents with your choice of cheese or pepperoni.

Entrees
Spaghetti Meatballs
Served with our homemade marinara sauce.
Eggplant Parmigiano
Baked breaded eggplant made with our homemade marinara sauce and served over a bed of spaghetti smothered in mozzarella cheese.
Stuffed Shells
Pasta filled with ricotta cheese, smothered in our homemade marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
Tortellini
Served with our homemade marinara sauce.
Fettuccine Alfredo
Served with our homemade alfredo sauce.
Chicken Parmesan
Breaded chicken breast topped with homemade marinara sauce and smothered with mozzarella. Served with garlic bread and a side salad.

Desserts
Cannoli
Sicilian fried pastry dough shell and filled.
New York Style Cheesecake
Chocolate Cake
Zeppoles Basket

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+25 photos
Photo credit: google
+24 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Very nice and respectful employees very helpful in finding what I wanted as I've never eaten here before the little black haired kid nick is a gem the italian subs are a 10/10 going to try again next week
January 2025
I just ordered a sub for 8.99 I bring it home and it's very small. I called to speak to someone and they said they don't make the prices. So I'm disappointed my feedback is to adjust the price this was too little for $9 with tax.

I edited my review from a 2 to a 3 because the sun does taste good.
October 2024
Read about this place in the 614 article, went to try it out at the Pickerington location. It's a modest but good sized restaurant, recently adding a bar and alcohol to their menu. The server was very nice, the pizza did not take long to get made. Pepsi products, for those like me who prefer Coca-Cola with red sauces. The crust was perfection, just heavenly with the perfect consistency to hold the piece together. The sauce and cheese definitely remind me of New York style...
July 2023

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Sakana Restaurant - 7952 E Broad St
Asian Fusion, Sushi Bar, Japanese, Vegetarian
Scramblers - 7970 E Broad St
Breakfast, American, Vegetarian
El Asadero bar and Mexican Grill - 8050 E Broad St
Mexican, Seafood, Cocktail Bar

Pizzeria New York

7950 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
(614) 868-3870