I have switched to Romeos pizza for my regular family pizza nights. Pizza sauce is untouchable if you like a sweet sauce. The deep dish satisfies my veggie pizza cravings and for me any pizza place that has broccoli on the menu is extra special. My kids love the bacon and pineapple toppings especially here not to mention their Capone sauce!!! This takes the experience over the top for my family! Delicious! Love the app with the rewards feature for savings in the future. There is always a coupon code to use also! AMAZING! 😋
Keaton Sweeney
Pizza was decent. They had a 2for20 deal and I tried it, and don’t have anything overly negative to say. The crust appears to be out of one of those textured mats and the garlic sauce I got for one base was not particularly good. Otherwise just a decent mid-range pie comparable to dominos or something.
Coco R
We had pizza delivered to us and it was great. The order arrived on time and they followed all requests we had for our food. The pizza was great and the delivery man was nice.
Craig Bartholomew
I'm very disappointed you've changed the makeup of the traditional crust. It's not nearly as good as the previous crust. I won't be returning because it's the main reason I was a regular customer and now it's not tasty at all. The service at this location wasn't nearly as efficient as usual even though they were fairly busy. Nobody gave me an indication of how much longer my online order might take.
Janet Bartholomew
These stars reflect the last few purchases. Romeo's Pizza has been our favorite pizza for a long time. Until recently. Our favorite crust has always been the TRADITIONAL. Now you have changed the traditional to a thin crust. Very unsatisfying. The toppings are still good. We are hoping you with switch back to the traditional Traditional crust. We don't really want to look for another favorite pizza.
Marti D.
We had a small pizza delivered and it was delicious! The sauce was so tasty. Our delivery drive was prompt and courteous. Will definitely order from Romeos again!
Amy Hartley
Hit it out of the ballpark yet again! Fast turnaround and delivery man was awesome, very friendly and polite. Everything tasted great and fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa Johnson
I ordered a half sheet Tuscan pepperoni with a lite bake and a cookie pie. It was extremely sparse on the pepperoni . On some of the slices there was one piece of pepperoni and Capone sauce was not included. For $35, plus $5 tip, I felt slighted.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Sherry Mcdonnell
Service Fast And Friendly, Calzone was Absolutely Delicious, Will Definitely Be ordering
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tyler Thomas
Courtney did a great job, customer service was stellar and had the patience to fix a mistake i made with no problem. Don’t get customer service like that anymore.
I have switched to Romeos pizza for my regular family pizza nights. Pizza sauce is untouchable if you like a sweet sauce. The deep dish satisfies my veggie pizza cravings and for me any pizza place that has broccoli on the menu is extra special. My kids love the bacon and pineapple toppings especially here not to mention their Capone sauce!!! This takes the experience over the top for my family! Delicious! Love the app with the rewards feature for savings in the future. There is always a coupon code to use also! AMAZING! 😋
Pizza was decent. They had a 2for20 deal and I tried it, and don’t have anything overly negative to say. The crust appears to be out of one of those textured mats and the garlic sauce I got for one base was not particularly good. Otherwise just a decent mid-range pie comparable to dominos or something.
We had pizza delivered to us and it was great. The order arrived on time and they followed all requests we had for our food. The pizza was great and the delivery man was nice.
I'm very disappointed you've changed the makeup of the traditional crust. It's not nearly as good as the previous crust. I won't be returning because it's the main reason I was a regular customer and now it's not tasty at all. The service at this location wasn't nearly as efficient as usual even though they were fairly busy. Nobody gave me an indication of how much longer my online order might take.
These stars reflect the last few purchases. Romeo's Pizza has been our favorite pizza for a long time. Until recently. Our favorite crust has always been the TRADITIONAL. Now you have changed the traditional to a thin crust. Very unsatisfying. The toppings are still good. We are hoping you with switch back to the traditional Traditional crust. We don't really want to look for another favorite pizza.
We had a small pizza delivered and it was delicious! The sauce was so tasty. Our delivery drive was prompt and courteous. Will definitely order from Romeos again!
Hit it out of the ballpark yet again! Fast turnaround and delivery man was awesome, very friendly and polite. Everything tasted great and fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a half sheet Tuscan pepperoni with a lite bake and a cookie pie.
It was extremely sparse on the pepperoni .
On some of the slices there was one piece of pepperoni and Capone sauce was not included.
For $35, plus $5 tip, I felt slighted.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Service Fast And Friendly, Calzone was Absolutely Delicious, Will Definitely Be ordering
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Courtney did a great job, customer service was stellar and had the patience to fix a mistake i made with no problem. Don’t get customer service like that anymore.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veggie Deluxe Specialty Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Awesome experience! Very customer service oriented employee. Cannot wait to taste the food...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veggie Deluxe Specialty Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Staff is very friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veggie Deluxe Specialty Pizza
Hey Kevin was super cool and friendly and very quick on service ! Food was fantastic best pizza in Reynoldsburg! 5 star rating!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Never had a bad pizza! Always delish!
Parking: Off street parking!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Cinnamon breadsticks homemade fresh out the oven?
It doesnt get any better than that, my friend.
Please remember to support your local pizzeria
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...