My official Facebook review is below..this is after my first visit. Needless to say I'll be back: Finally decided to take a break from meal prep to indulge on pizza this weekend. So here's my honest and sober review of Sexton's in Reynoldsburg. I ordered a 16" hand tossed "Dairy Air" which has Ezzo Cup N Char pepperoni, cream cheese and a hot honey drizzle. Yes..CREAM. CHEESE. Before you frown let me just say that I took the first bite before I turned my car on and proceeded to violate the rest of the piece before I could drive home. It's so damn good. I'm a slut for cream cheese so I ate a cream cheese ball solo too lol. It's not super saucy but it worked for this pizza. The cheese was nice and melty and the pepperoni did not disappoint. I was nervous because I've seen people complain that the crust is "burnt" but honestly the crust was good! I could see myself dipping it in hot honey lol. The ratio of crust to toppings was *chefs kiss*. This was my first time at Sexton's and upon the first bite I knew it wouldn't be my last. One slice is about all I can handle in one sitting and that's depending on the size of the slice. I tried to pick the smallest slice lol.
Tiffany Dalton
We have finally found our favorite pizza! The Kevin Bacon pizza is unbelievable. We tried it for the first AND second time this weekend!You can't go wrong with whichever type of pizza you choose but the New York style is my absolute favorite!
Wes Anders
Best Pizza in Columbus. Hands down. Owners are great people. Staff is always friendly and kind. Never disappoints.
Steve Kauffman
This is some of the best pizza I've had in awhile. I went in for pickup, but looks like a decent place to dine in. The staff was friendly, got our order perfect, was an all around good experience. Oh yeah, also: Their thick crust pie is on point. ?
Kevin Cross
Our family has been on the search for the best pizza within 20 min from Hilliard, making Friday nights family pizza night. Well I think we just found it with Sexton’s Pizza. Brovo!!!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
tina staton
I am telling everyone my family has lived in the Reynoldsburg area for 30 years we go everywhere for pizza. We've gone to Chicago, just all over but I'm here to tell you Sexton's Pizza is the best pizza we have ever eaten no joke. We love it and their hoagie (sub) is phenomenal I don't even need toppings but you can get them. You can't pay with cash right now because some people thought they deserved this family's hard earned cash more than they did and broke in and stole their cash register. So let's support this small delicious business you won't regret it. Promise.
Rachel Streck
We used to love this place. The 614 pizza was the best! But lately they’ve limited their menu, they removed their best pizza from it, they only offer one size and just the overall service had gone way down. We ordered two pizzas last night, one was supposed to be half cheese for my toddler. My husband went in to pick it up and waited 8 minutes for someone to even acknowledge he was there. Then they handed him his pizzas and disappeared. Knowing the type of service we’ve seen from them over the past few months, my husband checked the pizza and they didn’t make a half cheese pizza. He waited for another few minutes for someone to come back out (he was also saying “hello” to get someone’s attention) no one ever came. So we had to make my toddler a frozen pizza. I’m not sure we’ll be back. Disappointing. This place used to be amazing!
Kyle Wier
I was so excited to try this place. I got it home and it was the incorrect order and it was awful ? the service wasn’t the best. Sucks, I wanted to support but don’t rush and be friendly!
Adam Fausnaugh
Our family had this yesterday for the first time at the Gahanna location. This is some of the best local pizza we have had. Crust was crisp, sauce was sweet, and pepperoni was fantastic. Highly recommended
Rachel S.
Excellent pizza, especially for the price. My favorite is the Dairy Air, my boyfriend likes the Kevin Bacon. I've been to the Reynoldsburg location several times and I've always received good service. Glad you guys came to town!
Had no idea what to expect about this new pizza joint. Had great music, pretty quick food, and amazing pizza. I will be coming back. The Kevin bacon pizza is amazing.
Clayton Kohut
I’m from Youngstown and prefer a thicker crust. Their motown pizza is EXACTLY what I’ve been searching for. I wish they had a location closer to me in grand view but the drive was well worth it. That Thursday wing deal is amazing as well
Drew U
Never heard of the place and took a chance via DoorDash… Might be the best pizza in Columbus for NY style pie. Amazing crispy crust even after 30 min delivery. Will be making a special trip to try in person.
Dan Bush
I tried the Couliflower crust cheese pizza to see all the hype my friend said about the Couliflower crust. The crust had a nice crisp to it, but the pizza sauce taste like ravioli sauce from the can, it was enough cheese and my pizza didn’t have much taste. I give the pizza 2.5 out of 5 due to the crunch, but the pizza was like eating cheese from a cardboard box. I will stick with Donatos, Massey, Mods and Meister for Couliflower crust. However, this is just my opinion maybe someone else will have a better experience with the pizza.
Ya Y.
It was my first time trying Sexton's pizza. My friends and I got two speciality flavors (one was queso based with jalapeño, bacon and fried chicken, and the other one was pepperoni and bacon). We also got one of the most popular dishes - skillet knots. They were all very tasty. The queso one was quite spicy as we kept eating, but at the same time the candied bacon helped add some sweetness to the pizza. It was good! Also this pizza place sell the pizza by slices! It made quite easier if you want to try different flavors at once!
My official Facebook review is below..this is after my first visit. Needless to say I'll be back: Finally decided to take a break from meal prep to indulge on pizza this weekend. So here's my honest and sober review of Sexton's in Reynoldsburg. I ordered a 16" hand tossed "Dairy Air" which has Ezzo Cup N Char pepperoni, cream cheese and a hot honey drizzle. Yes..CREAM. CHEESE. Before you frown let me just say that I took the first bite before I turned my car on and proceeded to violate the rest of the piece before I could drive home. It's so damn good. I'm a slut for cream cheese so I ate a cream cheese ball solo too lol. It's not super saucy but it worked for this pizza. The cheese was nice and melty and the pepperoni did not disappoint. I was nervous because I've seen people complain that the crust is "burnt" but honestly the crust was good! I could see myself dipping it in hot honey lol. The ratio of crust to toppings was *chefs kiss*. This was my first time at Sexton's and upon the first bite I knew it wouldn't be my last. One slice is about all I can handle in one sitting and that's depending on the size of the slice. I tried to pick the smallest slice lol.
We have finally found our favorite pizza! The Kevin Bacon pizza is unbelievable. We tried it for the first AND second time this weekend!You can't go wrong with whichever type of pizza you choose but the New York style is my absolute favorite!
Best Pizza in Columbus. Hands down. Owners are great people. Staff is always friendly and kind. Never disappoints.
This is some of the best pizza I've had in awhile. I went in for pickup, but looks like a decent place to dine in. The staff was friendly, got our order perfect, was an all around good experience. Oh yeah, also: Their thick crust pie is on point. ?
Our family has been on the search for the best pizza within 20 min from Hilliard, making Friday nights family pizza night. Well I think we just found it with Sexton’s Pizza. Brovo!!!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I am telling everyone my family has lived in the Reynoldsburg area for 30 years we go everywhere for pizza. We've gone to Chicago, just all over but I'm here to tell you Sexton's Pizza is the best pizza we have ever eaten no joke. We love it and their hoagie (sub) is phenomenal I don't even need toppings but you can get them. You can't pay with cash right now because some people thought they deserved this family's hard earned cash more than they did and broke in and stole their cash register. So let's support this small delicious business you won't regret it. Promise.
We used to love this place. The 614 pizza was the best! But lately they’ve limited their menu, they removed their best pizza from it, they only offer one size and just the overall service had gone way down. We ordered two pizzas last night, one was supposed to be half cheese for my toddler. My husband went in to pick it up and waited 8 minutes for someone to even acknowledge he was there. Then they handed him his pizzas and disappeared. Knowing the type of service we’ve seen from them over the past few months, my husband checked the pizza and they didn’t make a half cheese pizza. He waited for another few minutes for someone to come back out (he was also saying “hello” to get someone’s attention) no one ever came. So we had to make my toddler a frozen pizza. I’m not sure we’ll be back. Disappointing. This place used to be amazing!
I was so excited to try this place. I got it home and it was the incorrect order and it was awful ? the service wasn’t the best. Sucks, I wanted to support but don’t rush and be friendly!
Our family had this yesterday for the first time at the Gahanna location. This is some of the best local pizza we have had. Crust was crisp, sauce was sweet, and pepperoni was fantastic. Highly recommended
Excellent pizza, especially for the price. My favorite is the Dairy Air, my boyfriend likes the Kevin Bacon. I've been to the Reynoldsburg location several times and I've always received good service. Glad you guys came to town!
Restaurantji Recommends
Had no idea what to expect about this new pizza joint. Had great music, pretty quick food, and amazing pizza. I will be coming back. The Kevin bacon pizza is amazing.
I’m from Youngstown and prefer a thicker crust. Their motown pizza is EXACTLY what I’ve been searching for. I wish they had a location closer to me in grand view but the drive was well worth it. That Thursday wing deal is amazing as well
Never heard of the place and took a chance via DoorDash… Might be the best pizza in Columbus for NY style pie. Amazing crispy crust even after 30 min delivery. Will be making a special trip to try in person.
I tried the Couliflower crust cheese pizza to see all the hype my friend said about the Couliflower crust. The crust had a nice crisp to it, but the pizza sauce taste like ravioli sauce from the can, it was enough cheese and my pizza didn’t have much taste. I give the pizza 2.5 out of 5 due to the crunch, but the pizza was like eating cheese from a cardboard box. I will stick with Donatos, Massey, Mods and Meister for Couliflower crust. However, this is just my opinion maybe someone else will have a better experience with the pizza.
It was my first time trying Sexton's pizza. My friends and I got two speciality flavors (one was queso based with jalapeño, bacon and fried chicken, and the other one was pepperoni and bacon). We also got one of the most popular dishes - skillet knots. They were all very tasty. The queso one was quite spicy as we kept eating, but at the same time the candied bacon helped add some sweetness to the pizza. It was good! Also this pizza place sell the pizza by slices! It made quite easier if you want to try different flavors at once!