Sugar Rush Columbus Bakery & Bar

I got my son's 16th birthday here. It was my first time buying a cake from here. I would definitely recommend them. I got two cakes one looked like a Oreo Cookie and the second a Oreo themed cake. They were both really good tasting and both very nice looking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I personally don't even like cake . I attended a graduation party in 2023 where they served a Sugar Rush cake ,I took a small slice home to be polite 🤦‍♀️one bite and I'm messaging the hostess asking where did you get that cake ...I've been hooked ever since .I've bought thier quick cakes and done custom orders neither have disappointed. I highly recommend !

I've tried this bakery twice through Uber. 1st order was a strawberry and a chocolate slice. The strawberry fell apart in crumbles. We received peanut butter instead of the chocolate. Didn't even try that one. Thinking maybe it was an off day we tried again today and ordered a mystery 6 pack. Requested no pb just in case. The stores had to be the most vile, disgusting, driest cupcake I've ever had. My kids wouldn't even eat it. I think another we tried was Creme Brule, it wasn't awful but it wasn't good either. Lastly we tried the maybe birthday cake one? It had the dye and vanilla frosting with sprinkles inside. It was pretty good. We were still so put off by the stores we gave up trying the others. I wish them well but my money has to go elsewhere.

I ordered a suprise bag from the app “Too good to go” and I was super excited to pick up my goodies. The window time to pick up my bag was 7-7:30 and I arrived at 7:26 just for them to tell me they were out of everything and they were going to shoot me a text. I guess I’m confused on why you guys would text me that my order could not be completed, 4 minutes before I was suppose to pick it up. I will not be returning to this unprofessional business again, do better. If I could give 0 stars, I would.

I LOVE Sugar Rush. I have two daughters that always want custom cakes for their birthdays. I made them for the first six years but now the cake wants are so difficult I had to find a bakery. We’ve gotten two birthday cakes here so far and they have been so beautiful and tasty. We’ve also grabbed sweets from here whenever I have a sweet tooth and absolutely everything has been amazing. The process is very simple for ordering a cake, everyone I spoke to was so nice, and the quality is amazing. I’m even thinking about splurging on my own birthday cake this year from here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered a custom engagement cake last week. The process was smooth and easy, and most importantly the cake was beautiful AND so moist and tasty. Several people asked me where it was from and even said it could be a contender for a wedding cake, which I agree. This rivals my favorite bakery in Dayton where I got married. We will use Sugar Rush in the future and especially once we have kids. Their designs are so fun!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I highly recommend this bakery. I ordered a Valentine’s Day cake and it did not disappoint. It was perfect!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I love Sugar Rush . Came in today to get some quick cupcakes for our 3rd graders valentines party. We got everything we need . They are so amsome and believe me the name says it all . Great treats. Best place to go.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We got six different flavors of cupcakes and the Dubai chocolate bar and enjoyed everything! Pick up was quick and staff were friendly! We will order from here again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bought 1 lemon drop cupcake 1 blueberry cupcake 2 pineapple upside down cupcakes and some cookies… the icing on both lemon cupcakes were completely dry and hard asa rock. The lemon cupcake itself barely had any flavor even with the blueberries. Completely disappointed in that. It’s very hard to find a good lemon cupcake anywhere it seems. The pineapple upside down cupcake was very good and moist. The cookies were ok. The employee was very nice and atmosphere was nothing special. That’s why gave 3 stars .

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Their monster cookies are fantastic! I love sweets and their cookies are always fresh and delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies

Excellent local small business in Blacklick, Ohio. Custom cakes, amazing sweet treats and some gluten free options as well! Oh, did I mention their amazing and creative shakes and adult beverages? Check them out! Check out the macarons! Yum! I had to snap a pic before they disappeared! ❤️

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options include macarons, buckeyes and buckeye bars. Of course the shakes and adult beverage selection has plenty of gf choices, too!

Parking: Large parking lot.

Kid-friendliness: Great shop with fun theme and kid friendly treats!

Wheelchair accessibility: Easy parking and store access

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies, Strawberry Milkshake, Cake Pops, Custom Birthday Cake

We have taken several cake and cookie decorating classes, stopped in and gotten treats on a random day and have NEVER had a bad experience.

Service is always prompt, kind, and offers great suggestions!

I will continue using Sugar Rush as our bakery destination and continuously recommend them to others!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cupcake, Cookies, Assorted Cupcakes

The gnash wasnt added to the cake. I got handed a pipping bag to add it myself, the fondant figure was not good looking AT ALL. on top of that it wasnt ready on time .$205 for all these inconveniences… overall not a good experience.

This is one of my favorite bakeries in town! We’ve ordered 3 custom cakes and today I went in to grab a ready made cake and it was AMAZING! Love these guys!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5