Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery

$20 for a small pizza. really??. good but overpriced

This was absolutely delicious 😋. Will return, we're regulars now.

The best! They make their own sourdough crust and sauce. Perfect every time. Personal favorite is the Autumn Swoon.

It was early in the evening and I was told they were sold out of small pizzas and had to order a large. Aren't you an artisan pizza shop? Why do I have to pay for a large when I only want a small? This will be my last time going to your pizza shop.

This is excellent fired pizza. It is not your hum drum pizza but rather unique and delicious!!! And they have creative, delicious bakery treats for sale, either for dessert or breakfast next day.

Tyler's Pizza: A Flavorful Feast!
I recently had the pleasure of trying Tyler's Pizza, and I must say, it was an absolute delight! From the first bite to the last, every element was bursting with flavor. The pizza itself was perfectly cooked, with a delicious crust that struck the ideal balance between chewy and crispy. The toppings were fresh and plentiful, and the sauce was clearly made with high-quality ingredients.
But the real star of the show, surprisingly, was the brownie. Forget your standard dense, fudgy brownie; Tyler's offered a cake-like brownie that was truly melt-in-your-mouth. It was light, airy, and incredibly rich, with a perfect balance of sweetness. It was a wonderful and unexpected treat, and I highly recommend saving room for dessert!
Overall, Tyler's Pizza delivered a fantastic culinary experience. The combination of flavorful pizza and the heavenly brownie makes this a must-try for any pizza lover. I will definitely be ordering from them again soon!

Seriously! What is this! I ordered 2 calzones and had my husband pick them up. When I opened the box I was shocked 😲 Totally inedible and burnt! I will never order from them again!

Great pizza, great pizza!! Eat here! We really do love it and the people who work here…

My husband and I ordered the Sunny Side Up Pizza and it was delicious! Who doesn’t love pizza for breakfast? Delicious chewy crust and great combination of toppings. The staff was friendly and the pizza was ready in about 30 minutes on a busy Friday evening! We will most assuredly order again soon!

My 2nd time here, and still not too big a fan of the pizza. Friendly staff and good desserts. Can't remember the specifics from my first visit just wasn't feeling it 6 months ago. This time around I got a large pep and cheesy bread, there was less cheese on the bread then previous, and both the bread and pizza taste sour. Doesnt appeal to my pallet much at all. Was hoping for more new york east coast style. The crust is very flimsy and soft. Not sure if its a sour dough but its sour. Small burned spots all around the crust on top and underneath but thats common for this type of pizza and didn't impact the flavor.

That is some good pizza... The crust is top notch
Tony

First pizza at our new house in Reynoldsburg, and what a find! Wood fired pizza served fresh and delicious. The 3-Cheeses BeGeezus with added fresh mushrooms was awesome, and our son raved about the Sunny-Side Up. Both pizzas were fantastic for breakfast as well. Also, don't forget to ask about their fresh baked treats.

Crust was phenomenal, and the toppings were delicious as well.

Pizza is excellent and so are baked goods for Breakfast and desserts

Their blueberry muffins are awesome!