Firstly, it's adorable and tiny. You walk in and it smells of fresh pastries and pizza, there's beautiful loaves of bread on display, dough getting loved on and pizzas being slung in the brick ovens. Everybody was very nice and there were samples to try and let me tell you...one nibble of the chocolate croissant and it was love at first bite; flakey, warm and decadent so naturally I bought two. Just when I thought I found my one and only I tasted the cream cheese danish....boom my pastry soul mate was right before my eyes. No debate the best pastry I have ever eaten; creamy, light, rich and voluptuous so naturally I bought two. Now for the calzone and pizza I can lump them together since they are similar by design. The dough is absolutely spectacular! Charred, crisp and chewy, really reminded me of my trip to New Haven. Undercarriage is to die for; leaves a little black char on your fingers. Cartoon esq. cheese pull, peps were crispy, sauce was fresh and vibrant. Tighten up the middle a bit and it's a 9+. This is a drive an hour to try it spot easy. From a guy who's eaten pizza in Chicago, New Haven, New York and about 75% of places in central Ohio. Chocolate croissant-8.9, Cream cheese danish-9.4, calzone-8.6, pizza-8.8
Terry Finklea
Very friendly and welcoming. Ordered Calzones and Strombolis. Love at first bite. The dough was cooked perfectly. Unbelievable. Fresh mozzarella, mushrooms were fresh cut nice size. Pepperoni was perfect. I can't wait to get back over there. I wish they offered delivery or Doordash. Fresh bread would be ordered frequently. This place is amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Darryll Wolnik
Best calzone ever. Breads are so good, and everyone is so nice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Larry Wolfe
Tyler's pizzas and baked goods are always first rate. This weekend Brian baked Irish soda bread for St Patty's Day....absolutely delicious!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Croissants, Garlic Cheddar Bread, Pepperoni and Extra Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza, Pumpkin and Cinnamon Scones, Blueberry Chocolate Chip Bars, White Pizza with Spinach and Garlic, Margherita Pizza, Half 3 Cheezus Begeezus Half Pauper's Pie, Cheese Danish and Chocolate Croissant, Meat Pizza
Cathy R.
I truly loved Tyler's Pizzeria. I used to go in on Saturdays for fresh bread and the best cinnamon croissants! I loved having a bakery nearby. However they stopped being open on Saturday mornings. So I no longer go there.
Hannah J.
The employees were great and such a cute little take out place! I was extremely excited to try the pizza since I love wood fire. But... the pizza was SOAKED with grease. I understand pepperoni has a grease that releases but the whole pizza as you see was soaked. Just a few taps on the paper towel shows you how much. The pizza had a great flavor but I couldn't even hold it up since it was so wet with grease. I would like to give it another try but... nervous to spend the money again. They were kind enough to give me a refund. I felt bad but I just was very disappointed after searching yelp and looking at others pizza.
Madhu Sharma
Pizza is not good and cheese is bad test it’s test is expired cheeseVegetarian options: Not good pizza
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Croissants
Michele D.
Excellent service, pizza was delicious and the calzone was amazing. Even leftovers were great
Garic W.
Everyone is SUPER polite! The pizza and desserts are amazing!! Hidden gem in Reynoldsburg!
Jon Bauer
Great Pizza - Great Baked Items - Great Service.If your looking for a local owned/non-chain place, this is it. Rarely leave reviews but had to give this place 5 stars! 100% would recommend anyone local to here.
Fantastic pizza and great desserts. Cheese danish especially.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Lisa Weisner
Tyler's Pizza is a Reynoldsburg staple! You are missing out if you don't stop in.You are always greeted by Tyler and he will answer and suggest the best. This time we only stopped in for pastries, his chocolate croissant is great warmed with coffee! We ended up placing an order for the autumn swoon pizza. Please don't take it off the menu. It has quickly grown to my favorite specialty pizza.Try it out! Great wood fired pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Croissants, Cheese Danish and Chocolate Croissant
Madeline Pfister
Never had a bad pizza there and their bakery items are excellent. Everything is high quality and delicious. Plus, they are just really nice people.
Woooohooooo! Dayyyaaammnnnn! Nooooiice! Pizza in the car!Tyler's pizzeria and bakery7516 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068LG 14" pepperoni DBL sausage $18.50Carry out onlyLegit wood fired pizza!Good tasting crust with great leoparding on the undercarriage and a fantastic crumb and crunch on the handle. Got more floppy toward the centerGood quality toppings. Cup-n-partially charred pepperoni. Uniquely flavorful herbaceous sausage. Rich, savory sauce, and a good amount of in-house shredded mozz.This looks like a hippie pizza joint, and at the risk of sounding a bit weird, the pizza tasted like a hippie pizza. Hard to describe, but if you're into wood fired pizza with flavors that are proprietarial, I'd definitely give them a try. I doubt you'll be disappointed.Super nice folks!Also, I got a bonus loaf of rustic bread and a couple of chocolate chip blueberry bars.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ms. Freeman
Wow!!! Customer service was stellar from ordering over the phone, carried over in-person. The pizza smelled so delicious, I almost started in in it while driving. My family said it was the best pizza they've ever had. We should have ordered more. Now we have to wait until Wednesday to order again. Really good food!
Firstly, it's adorable and tiny. You walk in and it smells of fresh pastries and pizza, there's beautiful loaves of bread on display, dough getting loved on and pizzas being slung in the brick ovens. Everybody was very nice and there were samples to try and let me tell you...one nibble of the chocolate croissant and it was love at first bite; flakey, warm and decadent so naturally I bought two. Just when I thought I found my one and only I tasted the cream cheese danish....boom my pastry soul mate was right before my eyes. No debate the best pastry I have ever eaten; creamy, light, rich and voluptuous so naturally I bought two. Now for the calzone and pizza I can lump them together since they are similar by design. The dough is absolutely spectacular! Charred, crisp and chewy, really reminded me of my trip to New Haven. Undercarriage is to die for; leaves a little black char on your fingers. Cartoon esq. cheese pull, peps were crispy, sauce was fresh and vibrant. Tighten up the middle a bit and it's a 9+. This is a drive an hour to try it spot easy. From a guy who's eaten pizza in Chicago, New Haven, New York and about 75% of places in central Ohio. Chocolate croissant-8.9, Cream cheese danish-9.4, calzone-8.6, pizza-8.8
Very friendly and welcoming. Ordered Calzones and Strombolis. Love at first bite. The dough was cooked perfectly. Unbelievable. Fresh mozzarella, mushrooms were fresh cut nice size. Pepperoni was perfect. I can't wait to get back over there. I wish they offered delivery or Doordash. Fresh bread would be ordered frequently. This place is amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best calzone ever. Breads are so good, and everyone is so nice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tyler's pizzas and baked goods are always first rate. This weekend Brian baked Irish soda bread for St Patty's Day....absolutely delicious!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Croissants, Garlic Cheddar Bread, Pepperoni and Extra Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza, Pumpkin and Cinnamon Scones, Blueberry Chocolate Chip Bars, White Pizza with Spinach and Garlic, Margherita Pizza, Half 3 Cheezus Begeezus Half Pauper's Pie, Cheese Danish and Chocolate Croissant, Meat Pizza
I truly loved Tyler's Pizzeria. I used to go in on Saturdays for fresh bread and the best cinnamon croissants! I loved having a bakery nearby. However they stopped being open on Saturday mornings. So I no longer go there.
The employees were great and such a cute little take out place! I was extremely excited to try the pizza since I love wood fire. But... the pizza was SOAKED with grease. I understand pepperoni has a grease that releases but the whole pizza as you see was soaked. Just a few taps on the paper towel shows you how much. The pizza had a great flavor but I couldn't even hold it up since it was so wet with grease. I would like to give it another try but... nervous to spend the money again. They were kind enough to give me a refund. I felt bad but I just was very disappointed after searching yelp and looking at others pizza.
Pizza is not good and cheese is bad test it’s test is expired cheeseVegetarian options: Not good pizza
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Croissants
Excellent service, pizza was delicious and the calzone was amazing. Even leftovers were great
Everyone is SUPER polite! The pizza and desserts are amazing!! Hidden gem in Reynoldsburg!
Great Pizza - Great Baked Items - Great Service.If your looking for a local owned/non-chain place, this is it. Rarely leave reviews but had to give this place 5 stars! 100% would recommend anyone local to here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Fantastic pizza and great desserts. Cheese danish especially.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Tyler's Pizza is a Reynoldsburg staple! You are missing out if you don't stop in.You are always greeted by Tyler and he will answer and suggest the best. This time we only stopped in for pastries, his chocolate croissant is great warmed with coffee! We ended up placing an order for the autumn swoon pizza. Please don't take it off the menu. It has quickly grown to my favorite specialty pizza.Try it out! Great wood fired pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Croissants, Cheese Danish and Chocolate Croissant
Never had a bad pizza there and their bakery items are excellent. Everything is high quality and delicious. Plus, they are just really nice people.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza, Blueberry Chocolate Chip Bars
Woooohooooo! Dayyyaaammnnnn! Nooooiice! Pizza in the car!Tyler's pizzeria and bakery7516 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068LG 14" pepperoni DBL sausage $18.50Carry out onlyLegit wood fired pizza!Good tasting crust with great leoparding on the undercarriage and a fantastic crumb and crunch on the handle. Got more floppy toward the centerGood quality toppings. Cup-n-partially charred pepperoni. Uniquely flavorful herbaceous sausage. Rich, savory sauce, and a good amount of in-house shredded mozz.This looks like a hippie pizza joint, and at the risk of sounding a bit weird, the pizza tasted like a hippie pizza. Hard to describe, but if you're into wood fired pizza with flavors that are proprietarial, I'd definitely give them a try. I doubt you'll be disappointed.Super nice folks!Also, I got a bonus loaf of rustic bread and a couple of chocolate chip blueberry bars.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Wow!!! Customer service was stellar from ordering over the phone, carried over in-person. The pizza smelled so delicious, I almost started in in it while driving. My family said it was the best pizza they've ever had. We should have ordered more. Now we have to wait until Wednesday to order again. Really good food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Refrigerator Pizza, Fresh Garlic