I wish it was possible to give a rating beyond 5 stars for my catering experience with Cosentino’s this past weekend! The food was delicious, presentation and packaging we perfect, communication during the ordering process so very helpful, and the price is very fair considering the high quality! We will definitely be ordering from them again…. Especially the Stromboli 😋. Thank you Cosentino’s!
Tom Lingo
This is the highest quality pizza shop in Rootstown. Their food is top notch. Unfortunately, due to being a family business, they have selective hours.
Seth Powers
Food is always good and owners are great. We eat here often. And homemade bread.
Stephen Phillips
High quality food and people!
Kathryn Ice
Absolutely love this restaurant. Food is amazing every time. The owner is very nice and friendly. My go to for excellent spaghetti & meatballs, salads are fresh every time. Garlic parm fries are an awesome add on. Very generous portions.
sandra sicinski
First time ordering pizza from here. Had a pepperoni and sausage. That was the best pizza l had years.
Ayla Powers
Probably the best sub ever had, think they put crack in them and they’re cheaper than subway
JUSTIN NALLEY
Spaghetti and meatballs was great. Pizza was super greasy and doughy in the middle.
Josh Leas
Great food. Just so hard to get hold of to place an order
Jerod Husvar
Cosentino's consistently over-delivers. We've been customers for a long time and try to get a pie at least once a month, sometimes more. Every single time we receive a quality product that far exceeds what you'd expect at the reasonable prices! Every ingredient is fresh, combined eloquently without being overdone or pretentious. They pay exceptional attention to detail while still producing a product you feel great about eating on a weeknight OR for a special occasion. On top of the amazing pizza we've sampled several dinner options including the chicken parmesan, Stromboli and calzones, as well as the mind-blowing deserts. I cannot emphasize enough how things are "just right." You're gonna think Nona is in the back cooking. :) It's also so soul-warming to be recognized and called by name on the phone when you order, and genuinely treated as a friend when you visit.
Parking: Plenty of close parking lot spaces, including handicapped spots.
Nice place. Nice people. Tried pizza here for the first time. Not going to become my favorite, but I will have it again. They have lots of other items on their menu that I plan on trying eventually.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
theresa babbo
Best Italian take out, hands down. Everything in prepared by 5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ chef David. Nothing is frozen or processed. Everything is prepared fresh daily, from the sub buns, to the pizza crust. Everything is freshly cut and prepared as you would do it in your own homes. You walk into Cosentino's Pizzeria as a customer, and walk out feeling like family. Would recommend this place for all your catering needs. From the first bite to the last bite, you can taste the care that went into preparing your food. So much great italian food, for an unbelievable price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sherrie Maronen
Yummy ? Food. Everything there is homemade.Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Edward Gaines
Good pizza with sweet sauce, flavorful Italian salad dressing, but the clerk gave me the wrong dessert. Granted we were both yapping, but GOD BLESS IT I WANT MY CANNOLI! ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Christy Esler
We can not recommend this place enough. The food is fresh, high quality and homemade. We love the Stromboli, pizza, salad, subs, soups, desserts, oh heck, we love everything. Great small town family business.
I wish it was possible to give a rating beyond 5 stars for my catering experience with Cosentino’s this past weekend! The food was delicious, presentation and packaging we perfect, communication during the ordering process so very helpful, and the price is very fair considering the high quality! We will definitely be ordering from them again…. Especially the Stromboli 😋. Thank you Cosentino’s!
This is the highest quality pizza shop in Rootstown. Their food is top notch. Unfortunately, due to being a family business, they have selective hours.
Food is always good and owners are great. We eat here often. And homemade bread.
High quality food and people!
Absolutely love this restaurant. Food is amazing every time. The owner is very nice and friendly. My go to for excellent spaghetti & meatballs, salads are fresh every time. Garlic parm fries are an awesome add on. Very generous portions.
First time ordering pizza from here. Had a pepperoni and sausage. That was the best pizza l had years.
Probably the best sub ever had, think they put crack in them and they’re cheaper than subway
Spaghetti and meatballs was great. Pizza was super greasy and doughy in the middle.
Great food. Just so hard to get hold of to place an order
Cosentino's consistently over-delivers. We've been customers for a long time and try to get a pie at least once a month, sometimes more. Every single time we receive a quality product that far exceeds what you'd expect at the reasonable prices! Every ingredient is fresh, combined eloquently without being overdone or pretentious. They pay exceptional attention to detail while still producing a product you feel great about eating on a weeknight OR for a special occasion. On top of the amazing pizza we've sampled several dinner options including the chicken parmesan, Stromboli and calzones, as well as the mind-blowing deserts. I cannot emphasize enough how things are "just right." You're gonna think Nona is in the back cooking. :) It's also so soul-warming to be recognized and called by name on the phone when you order, and genuinely treated as a friend when you visit.
Parking: Plenty of close parking lot spaces, including handicapped spots.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza, Large Pepperoni & Cheese Pizza, Chicken Parmigiana, Sausage Pizza, Tiramisu
Restaurantji Recommends
Nice place. Nice people. Tried pizza here for the first time. Not going to become my favorite, but I will have it again. They have lots of other items on their menu that I plan on trying eventually.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Best Italian take out, hands down. Everything in prepared by 5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ chef David. Nothing is frozen or processed. Everything is prepared fresh daily, from the sub buns, to the pizza crust. Everything is freshly cut and prepared as you would do it in your own homes. You walk into Cosentino's Pizzeria as a customer, and walk out feeling like family. Would recommend this place for all your catering needs. From the first bite to the last bite, you can taste the care that went into preparing your food. So much great italian food, for an unbelievable price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yummy ? Food. Everything there is homemade.Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza with sweet sauce, flavorful Italian salad dressing, but the clerk gave me the wrong dessert. Granted we were both yapping, but GOD BLESS IT I WANT MY CANNOLI! ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
We can not recommend this place enough. The food is fresh, high quality and homemade. We love the Stromboli, pizza, salad, subs, soups, desserts, oh heck, we love everything. Great small town family business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...