The pepperoni rolls are terrible! They taste pre-made no flavor they taste like garbage I will never give my business to them again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Brad Sciullo
So this is the biggest and baddest of the DBP locations and i agree its the best but i think its more cause it has more of that great defelice crust smell then other smaller locations but the pizza across all locations is great and consistent so they are all winners. Thing with this one is its got all the bells and whistles so give it a try along with your local shop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
SN Jayk
I love the pizza but the service at St. Clairsville is the worst. Rude employees and very unprofessional. Will never order from here again. Ordered a Pizza for carry out. Over 1 hour waiting and the staff doesn’t care. Doesn’t even come to the pick up window. Drove over to pick up order 3 times. Now almost 1 and 1/2 hour wait. They make you pay when you place the order…. is this why? Once they get the money -they don’t care!
miranda carman
Great pizza and their buffet is always the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Pretzel Sticks, Breadsticks, Diavola Detroit
Rhonda Mayhugh
Got delivery! Everything was just fine. No complaints! Friendly answering phone and taking order and so was the delivery
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Antipasto Salad, Breadsticks
Brad Rossano
I was taught if u got nothing nice to say ,don't say anything at all.
Lee Donnell
Spent over $80 and waited close to an hour and the order wasn't right, at all. Didn't know it until we got home. My fault for not checking. The pizza and bread sticks were undercooked. Ordered 3 heart pizzas but was given 1 heart and the rest regular. Was very overcrowded inside with a very long line. The parking lot is extremely cramped. Almost got rear ended try to pull out.The workers there are not professional at all. If you ask them a question they will tell you that they don't know, then won't follow up. And don't bother trying to call them. It rang for 12 minutes before I hung up. All in all this establishment isn't very good.Parking: It's horrible
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Addie S
Loved DeFelice for many years, excited to be living back in the delivery area always lived the calzones and are as excellent as they were over 10 years ago, tried the Diavolo today first time, it's now a favorite also! And the delivery driver I've had the last few times is great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Olan Teague
Atmosphere is just a 3 star for me saying I don't know everytime I come in its about 30 minutes befote close. So I have no referenceService as mentioned a lot of high school people it seems at the counter knowledge on the low side but they are always friendly good folks.Food comment below my Texas run-on below,Me- work up here occasionally from Texas. In Texas some local places but the market is dominated really by the big 3-4 matinal chains then of course several other national but small foot print chains. Mom and pops style places kinda rare besides major cities, or local small town places usually offering wings and bread with spaghetti sauce on it. Up here though many local small regional chains. With a wide variety of pizza styles and offerings.In st Clairsville I have had 3-4 different places. These guys are my go to. Diverse menu without of good items. Never had a bad " new food" experience here. Not gonna say it's some gourmet experience but the food is ways working man good solid stuff. This is a small local chain. I have expeeienced in other towns around the are they have all been solid choices as well.Just keep in mind, back home we have lots of BBQ chicken and Taco places, up here sandwiches and Italian food tend to regin Supreme.The foodI get now default to, the " Supreme" everything pizza, as others mentioned it is sorta ( Crust pizza hut like), price $20 ish for the large but it is good... the toppings the toppings these guys do not skimp the pizza is loaded with meat or veggies --both- flavors very good stuff. In fact I usualy scarpe the toppings of two slices, save it and mix Into a can of tomato soup, and air fry the crust for a great meal later in the week, I gradients taste crunch feel fresh and not cheep. Sauce not bad,Sandwiches I have had about 4 different ones all top notch. Good meat great prices.Wings are wings to me but these are good.The appetizers the sausage and peppers In sauce nearly a meal on its own. That and a sandwich you have supper for two days easy.Iove the food here, and it's value I promise you will not eat this well and feel your dollars are respected anywhere else In town. Between the food and price your stealing and " getting away with it" .
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Carol Brunner
Ordered a thin crust pizza tonight. The crust was perfect, the sauce authentic and it had generous quality toppings. Reasonably priced. Will definitely order the next time we pass through St.
Pizza is awesome! High schoolers running the register was not so good. They had issues with taking the order. We ended up ordering something we didn't necessarily want, however to get an order placed we just did it. Where was the manager... Sitting in a booth!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Wes Cornett
Good pizza. Really really good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Breadsticks
Rick Murray
We was looking for a pizza eat in restaurant, we aren't from the area. Of course I googled and looked at many places to eat and just happened to see DeFelice.We parked, went inside and found they had a pizza buffet and salad bar. We asked how long was the Buffet open. We were told it was open for about 30 minutes more. We hurried up and all of us enjoyed the salad bar and buffet.The waitress was nice and said she was going to get a few more pizzas made for us to enjoy. Very nice of them.The pizza buffet and salad bar were both really good, the waitress was very nice and attentive to what we needed like drinks and such.The pizza crust to me seemed similar to a pizza hut crust which I like and the pizza sauce was a nice rich pizza sauce which I also like.Thank you,The Murray's
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spaghetti and Meatballs, Chef Salad, Greek Salad, Pepperoni Roll, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Make Ur Own Salad, Medium Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Jacqueline Lindow
The service is a bit hectic! The kids working here are not real knowledgeable of the menu . Therefore if you are asking questions about the menu..... They have to look at menu or ask someone who then has to ask someone else and so on. Delivery orders take a long time. Way longer then how long they say it will be. They rarely bring napkins or silverware and 3 out of 5 times the good was not hot. The food is excellent though! It's nice that they hire young kids but they need to have an experienced adult on all shifts as well!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Porterstoybarn Chris
Changed ingredients on pepperoni rolls, it’s bad when I couldn’t force myself to eat one they used to be the best.
The pepperoni rolls are terrible! They taste pre-made no flavor they taste like garbage I will never give my business to them again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
So this is the biggest and baddest of the DBP locations and i agree its the best but i think its more cause it has more of that great defelice crust smell then other smaller locations but the pizza across all locations is great and consistent so they are all winners. Thing with this one is its got all the bells and whistles so give it a try along with your local shop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love the pizza but the service at St. Clairsville is the worst. Rude employees and very unprofessional. Will never order from here again. Ordered a Pizza for carry out. Over 1 hour waiting and the staff doesn’t care. Doesn’t even come to the pick up window. Drove over to pick up order 3 times. Now almost 1 and 1/2 hour wait. They make you pay when you place the order…. is this why? Once they get the money -they don’t care!
Great pizza and their buffet is always the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Pretzel Sticks, Breadsticks, Diavola Detroit
Got delivery! Everything was just fine. No complaints! Friendly answering phone and taking order and so was the delivery
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Antipasto Salad, Breadsticks
I was taught if u got nothing nice to say ,don't say anything at all.
Spent over $80 and waited close to an hour and the order wasn't right, at all. Didn't know it until we got home. My fault for not checking. The pizza and bread sticks were undercooked. Ordered 3 heart pizzas but was given 1 heart and the rest regular. Was very overcrowded inside with a very long line. The parking lot is extremely cramped. Almost got rear ended try to pull out.The workers there are not professional at all. If you ask them a question they will tell you that they don't know, then won't follow up. And don't bother trying to call them. It rang for 12 minutes before I hung up. All in all this establishment isn't very good.Parking: It's horrible
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loved DeFelice for many years, excited to be living back in the delivery area always lived the calzones and are as excellent as they were over 10 years ago, tried the Diavolo today first time, it's now a favorite also! And the delivery driver I've had the last few times is great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere is just a 3 star for me saying I don't know everytime I come in its about 30 minutes befote close. So I have no referenceService as mentioned a lot of high school people it seems at the counter knowledge on the low side but they are always friendly good folks.Food comment below my Texas run-on below,Me- work up here occasionally from Texas. In Texas some local places but the market is dominated really by the big 3-4 matinal chains then of course several other national but small foot print chains. Mom and pops style places kinda rare besides major cities, or local small town places usually offering wings and bread with spaghetti sauce on it. Up here though many local small regional chains. With a wide variety of pizza styles and offerings.In st Clairsville I have had 3-4 different places. These guys are my go to. Diverse menu without of good items. Never had a bad " new food" experience here. Not gonna say it's some gourmet experience but the food is ways working man good solid stuff. This is a small local chain. I have expeeienced in other towns around the are they have all been solid choices as well.Just keep in mind, back home we have lots of BBQ chicken and Taco places, up here sandwiches and Italian food tend to regin Supreme.The foodI get now default to, the " Supreme" everything pizza, as others mentioned it is sorta ( Crust pizza hut like), price $20 ish for the large but it is good... the toppings the toppings these guys do not skimp the pizza is loaded with meat or veggies --both- flavors very good stuff. In fact I usualy scarpe the toppings of two slices, save it and mix Into a can of tomato soup, and air fry the crust for a great meal later in the week, I gradients taste crunch feel fresh and not cheep. Sauce not bad,Sandwiches I have had about 4 different ones all top notch. Good meat great prices.Wings are wings to me but these are good.The appetizers the sausage and peppers In sauce nearly a meal on its own. That and a sandwich you have supper for two days easy.Iove the food here, and it's value I promise you will not eat this well and feel your dollars are respected anywhere else In town. Between the food and price your stealing and " getting away with it" .
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Ordered a thin crust pizza tonight. The crust was perfect, the sauce authentic and it had generous quality toppings. Reasonably priced. Will definitely order the next time we pass through St.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza is awesome! High schoolers running the register was not so good. They had issues with taking the order. We ended up ordering something we didn't necessarily want, however to get an order placed we just did it. Where was the manager... Sitting in a booth!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Good pizza. Really really good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Breadsticks
We was looking for a pizza eat in restaurant, we aren't from the area. Of course I googled and looked at many places to eat and just happened to see DeFelice.We parked, went inside and found they had a pizza buffet and salad bar. We asked how long was the Buffet open. We were told it was open for about 30 minutes more. We hurried up and all of us enjoyed the salad bar and buffet.The waitress was nice and said she was going to get a few more pizzas made for us to enjoy. Very nice of them.The pizza buffet and salad bar were both really good, the waitress was very nice and attentive to what we needed like drinks and such.The pizza crust to me seemed similar to a pizza hut crust which I like and the pizza sauce was a nice rich pizza sauce which I also like.Thank you,The Murray's
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spaghetti and Meatballs, Chef Salad, Greek Salad, Pepperoni Roll, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Make Ur Own Salad, Medium Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
The service is a bit hectic! The kids working here are not real knowledgeable of the menu . Therefore if you are asking questions about the menu..... They have to look at menu or ask someone who then has to ask someone else and so on. Delivery orders take a long time. Way longer then how long they say it will be. They rarely bring napkins or silverware and 3 out of 5 times the good was not hot. The food is excellent though! It's nice that they hire young kids but they need to have an experienced adult on all shifts as well!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Changed ingredients on pepperoni rolls, it’s bad when I couldn’t force myself to eat one they used to be the best.