I love peirogies and Colemans fish market. I grew up in Wheeling but moved to Texas. We looked for pierogies everywhere here and I always talk about them. My husband surprised shipped them here. I was over the moon when I received them! They didn't disappoint there!!! They were delicious!
Matt
We enjoyed walking through the shops. Parking was free on Saturday. Everything closes and 5:30 and Sunday it's completely closed. Valley Cheese was my favorite
Michael Sargent
If you love kielbasa and pierogi you will live this place. The kielbasa sandwich is a dream come true. Served with some of the best cabbage I ever had. Get number 1 you will not be disappointed.
Joshua Clemons
Love the entire market but this little booth within has some phenomenal food. My kielbasa sandwich with saurkraut and red pepper cheese sauce was sooooo good. Very nice people. Also have a lot of take home to cook options.
John M
Went in to see what they had. Bought fresh homemade pasta and desert. Wonderful person that was worker wrote a sauce recipe down for me and talked me thru it. Had some small talk. Looking forward to a return to try something else. Dinner than night was awesome.
Lindsay Doyle
Did everyone have the same pierogis we did? We were super disappointed. Lovely staff, but the pierogis? Frozen, mass produced and almost zero flavor to them. We tried a couple of flavors and they all tasted exactly the same. And don’t get me started on the teeny tiny diced onions. Not what you would expect from a place that is supposed to love pierogis. Meats were good. Bakery items looked great. Suggest passing this one up and picking up freshly homemade pierogis from the Ukrainian Church on Thursdays instead when you have a pierogi craving.
Layla Williamson
The pierogis were amazing and the sauerkraut was excellent!!! (Even the pickle that came with our meal was delicious)
Brandee Youngclaus
Kielbasa sandwiches from the heavens, huge homemade perogies, and dessert? 100% yes. For the Love of Perogies is a local favorite made with love. It exceeded my expectations and I can not wait to have a chance to go back! The portions are HUGE and the price is fair, if you have the chance, TRY IT! ❤️
Katie Puterbaugh
Finally got to try this place and the food was amazing!!
Marissa Clark Folmar
Some of the worst pierogis I’ve ever eaten. Bland and chewy. Mrs T frozen are better, my homemade ones are far better. Service was great though and the lady that took our order was very friendly and polite and always smiled.
The food is out of this world!! Very friendly staff!! It’s a real treat.
Michelle Jadrić
They have nice meal options and an impressive dessert case! The pierogies are great.
Jerald Solomon
I was randomly driving through St Clairsville on Thursday afternoon just looking for a new place to eat. I found this restaurant on Google and said why not. I was blown away by the flavor of the food! I ordered the special #1 and I was not disappointed! Honestly some of the best pierogies I've ever had and ill definitely be back! Also an amazing warm, welcoming, clean, and overall enjoyable environment to be in! Cannot wait for my next visit
Glenda Dornon
Has a fantastic tasting fettuccine Alfredo at a great price. Friendly waitresses/waiters and fast service.
Jessica Morgan
Brought my pierogie loving son here for his birthday, he said they were the best! Food was delicious, service was super kind, and the cannoli cake was amazing!
I love peirogies and Colemans fish market. I grew up in Wheeling but moved to Texas. We looked for pierogies everywhere here and I always talk about them. My husband surprised shipped them here. I was over the moon when I received them! They didn't disappoint there!!! They were delicious!
We enjoyed walking through the shops. Parking was free on Saturday. Everything closes and 5:30 and Sunday it's completely closed. Valley Cheese was my favorite
If you love kielbasa and pierogi you will live this place. The kielbasa sandwich is a dream come true. Served with some of the best cabbage I ever had. Get number 1 you will not be disappointed.
Love the entire market but this little booth within has some phenomenal food. My kielbasa sandwich with saurkraut and red pepper cheese sauce was sooooo good. Very nice people. Also have a lot of take home to cook options.
Went in to see what they had. Bought fresh homemade pasta and desert. Wonderful person that was worker wrote a sauce recipe down for me and talked me thru it. Had some small talk. Looking forward to a return to try something else. Dinner than night was awesome.
Did everyone have the same pierogis we did? We were super disappointed. Lovely staff, but the pierogis? Frozen, mass produced and almost zero flavor to them. We tried a couple of flavors and they all tasted exactly the same. And don’t get me started on the teeny tiny diced onions. Not what you would expect from a place that is supposed to love pierogis. Meats were good. Bakery items looked great. Suggest passing this one up and picking up freshly homemade pierogis from the Ukrainian Church on Thursdays instead when you have a pierogi craving.
The pierogis were amazing and the sauerkraut was excellent!!! (Even the pickle that came with our meal was delicious)
Kielbasa sandwiches from the heavens, huge homemade perogies, and dessert? 100% yes. For the Love of Perogies is a local favorite made with love. It exceeded my expectations and I can not wait to have a chance to go back! The portions are HUGE and the price is fair, if you have the chance, TRY IT! ❤️
Finally got to try this place and the food was amazing!!
Some of the worst pierogis I’ve ever eaten. Bland and chewy. Mrs T frozen are better, my homemade ones are far better. Service was great though and the lady that took our order was very friendly and polite and always smiled.
Restaurantji Recommends
The food is out of this world!! Very friendly staff!! It’s a real treat.
They have nice meal options and an impressive dessert case! The pierogies are great.
I was randomly driving through St Clairsville on Thursday afternoon just looking for a new place to eat. I found this restaurant on Google and said why not. I was blown away by the flavor of the food! I ordered the special #1 and I was not disappointed! Honestly some of the best pierogies I've ever had and ill definitely be back! Also an amazing warm, welcoming, clean, and overall enjoyable environment to be in! Cannot wait for my next visit
Has a fantastic tasting fettuccine Alfredo at a great price. Friendly waitresses/waiters and fast service.
Brought my pierogie loving son here for his birthday, he said they were the best! Food was delicious, service was super kind, and the cannoli cake was amazing!