Guarnieri Pizzeria

220 E Spring St, St Marys
(419) 394-2244

Recent Reviews

Megan McLeish

This place is amazing! I usually get pasta, but they have lots of other types of food. All very good! Family friendly too. Can't say enough great things about this place.Vegetarian options: They could make things vegetarian for you if requested. I think they had vegetarian dishes on the menu too.Kid-friendliness: Our daughter loves this place! They have a shuffleboard that keeps her entertained while we wait for food, and the food is all stuff she loves.Parking: Plenty of parking spaces on the street, usually right in front.Wheelchair accessibility: Everything seems wheelchair accessible from the parking to the door to the seating.Dietary restrictions: As long as you disclose it, they're willing to modify anything or let you know if it's not possible, depending what your restriction is.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Antipasto

Kristina Parke

Fettuccine Alfredo was AMAZING!Side salad was large.Pizza and Wings were good.Drinks were so good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Krissy Seger

amazing pasta!! Alfredo sauce is so good!

Steven Olberding

Patio was open. nice quiet clean and good food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maria Wiseman

Very delicious pizza! Staff is friendly and helpful. First time we came here I got a Moscow Mule which was also delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Harlett

The online menu says $11.95 for a large order of bone-in wings. I was charged $25.00. Isn't that considered false advertising?

jedidiah herzog

Always friendly service and great food.

Ethan Westgerdes

The food is always good, service excellent. It has an old building vibe that's very welcoming.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Peter Clark

Atmosphere is cool… pizza is over priced and mediocre at best….

Beth R.

Matty & Garret provided excellent service and the pizza was delicious! It was my friend's first time there and she said she can't wait to bring her husband and family back.

Marc Roidt

Our Pizza wàs excellent, wish they would rotate there taps more. Truth is everywhere ? try something else.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cindy Gaerke

8 inch grilledChicken sub had about 12-16 1/2 in cubes on it...mostly bread ...very disappointedMenu said it was a grilled chicken sub...not pieces and parts...not worth the price...not coming back

Matt P.

Great little place with great pizza and pasta dishes. Staff are friendly and very helpful.

Melissa Sidenbender

great pizza decent craft beer choices on tap ya need to bring in Thyird Eye Brewing Co beer ? the patio is the perfect spot to enjoy great food, beer and company!!

Paula A.

Amazing! Pizza was great, sauce must be homemade! Great value! Very nice clean restaurant.

Load More