The Cardinal Scoop

4282 E Lake Rd, Sheffield Lake
(440) 242-0423

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Charles Olm

Love coming here when I can!!

Leena D.

Pricey for the small amount of ice cream you receive I asked for a medium sundae and received a small I believe cones for kids should at least have two scoops for the amount of money we are paying.

Roy Froebe

Chili dogs and sloppy Joe's are delicious.

kira b

This was our first time in, just searching the area for good ice cream and stumbled upon this AMAZING TREASURE.
Don’t let the outside fool you. While it may not look like much, there’s gold on the inside.
There’s no stairs to get in, just a small step up. And there is a small ramp for those who need it. Completely flat surface once inside. A few tables and chairs both inside and outside.
We were greeted with a smile from a very nice lady. I didn’t get her name but she very much could have been the manager. This is their 4th year in business.
They serve hard scoop Hershey’s Ice Cream, soft serve vanilla, chocolate or a twist, “incredible ice” and hot food.
I grabbed a sample of Sour Apple “incredible ice”, which is their name for Italian ice and oh my goodness…. I see why they can’t keep it in stock when they have it!! It was delicious!! I ordered a medium and it DEFINITELY exceeded that generously. I still have half left in my freezer. My boyfriend ordered a triple scoop of Salted Caramel Brownie, (Decadent brownie batter ice cream with a sweet and salty caramel swirl and baked brownie bites.) He was pleased and happy.
I couldn’t stop thinking about this place, we went 2 days later. This time greeted by a very nice young lady. Ordering a small Orange Blossom (vanilla) incredible ice, and a double scoop of Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup. Both times he got a waffle cone and said it’s the best one he’s ever had. It was fresh and not stale. Priced very well considering the “extra” they give. We will try hot food one day. But in the mean time, this will be our new ice cream spot. If you are ever in the area, or willing to make the drive you will not be disappointed. Put this on your summer 2025 bucket list.

Heather Trevis

Everyone on staff is always extremely nice! The bathrooms are always clean and the ice cream is absolutely fantastic!!

Papii

Awesome experience that I had today. Cotton candy and blackberry cherry. Thanks 😊

Jennifer Martin

Always a good experience! The staff is always so kind.

Chris Kambouris

Great food very clean also a good variety of ice cream also there is a very nice Trail right next to it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tammy Kennedy

Last minute stop, but the kids and I enjoyed the ice cream flavors, and the service was exceptional. Hopefully, the owner realizes the jewels he has working for him.

Vegetarian options: They serve a non dairy option

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salty Caramel Truffle, Strawberry Cheesecake, Cotton Candy

Tiffany Osborne

It so cute and updated inside , it looks tiny but when you walk in it's very large and refreshing! Will hopefully be back soon !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Heather Holland

I’m visiting from Florida and this ice cream shop is fantastic! It’s m a huge fan of local businesses and this place is a gem. The young man working was extremely polite & friendly. Highly recommend!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kristy Mulholland

Came across this place by accident while sight seeing along route 6.

It was amazing, clean and service was fantastic.

The Italian Ices were really good and the ice cream selection had a decent amount of choices.

Prices were awesome, will definitely be back to Cardinal Scoops for sure.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maria Malick Gray

Very nice owner and the ice cream was fantastic. Very clean and staff very friendly. I highly recommend.

Crystal Johnson

Very nice little place. Clean, open, tons of variety. Really good ice cream. Love having it so close to home. Will definitely be returning. The staff was very friendly and the prices were fair. Give it a shot next time you're driving up lake road, you'll like it. They've got drinks and other food too, if you're not in a sweet tooth mood but still want to visit.

Don't tell Fenik's I cheated. Fenik's if you read this it's a figment of your imagination. I would never eat ice cream elsewhere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony Lane

Great local ice cream shop that serves Hershey ice cream and has some good finger foods. Definitely recommend the hot pepper cheese bites!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Loading...