Selah is one of the most charming restaurants in the Youngstown area. Definitely worth visiting!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
C
Every single thing we had was delicious and totally different from your typical Youngstown Italian dishes. The food was fresh and the sauce had a depth that I can't even describe. I'm genuinely shocked by the bad reviews!
Mindy Marckel
Our waitress seemed intoxicated and my steak was awful! I usually don't leave reviews but ruined my valentines day! Hostess and bus boys were wonderful
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 2
Sharon Chisholm
Not a great experience. I came with a large group. My crab cake was frozen halfway through, and that was my main meal. I wasn't offered anything else or even remake it. Another person in our group had undercooked meatballs. She even knew when I was going to tell her it was frozen. She barely apologized and acted like it was a favor for her to take the meal off my check. The cake was bland. The best part of the meal was the honey feta and the atmosphere. This was my first experience, and I will not be returning.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mary Palumbo
I just went to Selah and had the Mozzarella Bacon Burger for lunch...best burger I ever had and the sweet potato fries that come with it were fantastic!! Don't even get me started on the cakes in that place!! 5 Star Restaurant for sure!! Beautiful atmosphere and beautiful people that work there...I highly recommend this place!!
dwayne muszik
Everyone was friendly, the food and desserts were out of this world, and the atmosphere is amazing. Will be back very soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica Rogers
Love this place. Such a great atmosphere, especially for a date. The food is delicious with a lot of unique options, and the staff is extremely friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jim Stefanak
Awesome restaurant inside old Bank Food is excellent as well the service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Allison Esposito
Outstanding server. She does a great job . Good was great. Will come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elaine Soos
We had our daughter’s baby shower here and everything was perfect! Brian and Theresa went out of their way to ensure that our food was delicious and ready exactly when we were! Our guests who had not been here before were impressed with the ambience provided by the renovated old bank building, including its original teller windows, wall and ceiling effects and vault room, where we stored the gifts, but which can be also be used for a creative small-group dining experience. We have brought several guests here for lunch or dinner on more “ordinary” days, and Selah has always come through with its tasty food (especially its one-of-a-kind cakes), dependable service and unique atmosphere. Classic jazz and swing playing quietly in the background enhances the experience. The restaurant also has dinner theater and distinctive summer alley parties featuring local talent. We highly recommend making the drive slightly off the beaten path to Selah!
Service and place were awesome but we went for the gnocchi and they were out. Definitely going back to try them hear they are the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Taylor
Terrible experience from start to finish. The restaurant smelled awful the moment we walked in, like something had gone bad. The service was incredibly slow and the staff seemed uninterested — no one checked on our table, and when we did get our food, it was cold, bland, and honestly inedible. The place felt dirty and poorly managed. Definitely not worth the money or time. I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sterling Whitfield
I went here about a week ago while visiting the state and even after returning home it still bothers me. I did not enjoy the service, I couldn't even properly give a 15% tip in good conscience. The server didn't come to check on us more than once through the meal and wasn't even the one to run us our food. I ran out of my drink and had to wait until after our meal was finished to even get a refill. The food wasn't even that great to be worth this level of service. Sure the place looked nice, but everything about my visit was just subpar.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Boomikins
Worst dinner service I've ever had. Server referred to me as a snow beaner because they heard my Canadian accent. Asked if I wanted a cup of maple syrup with my dinner. But wouldn't call me his 'buddy'. Told me to go back to my igloo when I complained.
2/10, never again, eh.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pharo Pictures
Poor service, horrible wait times, and my server brought up my bald spot which hurt my insecurities. I don't remember what her name was but it started with an S. My food was under cooked and my beer was WARM. If I could leave a 0 star review I would.
Selah is one of the most charming restaurants in the Youngstown area. Definitely worth visiting!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Every single thing we had was delicious and totally different from your typical Youngstown Italian dishes. The food was fresh and the sauce had a depth that I can't even describe. I'm genuinely shocked by the bad reviews!
Our waitress seemed intoxicated and my steak was awful! I usually don't leave reviews but ruined my valentines day! Hostess and bus boys were wonderful
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 2
Not a great experience. I came with a large group. My crab cake was frozen halfway through, and that was my main meal. I wasn't offered anything else or even remake it. Another person in our group had undercooked meatballs. She even knew when I was going to tell her it was frozen. She barely apologized and acted like it was a favor for her to take the meal off my check. The cake was bland. The best part of the meal was the honey feta and the atmosphere. This was my first experience, and I will not be returning.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
I just went to Selah and had the Mozzarella Bacon Burger for lunch...best burger I ever had and the sweet potato fries that come with it were fantastic!! Don't even get me started on the cakes in that place!! 5 Star Restaurant for sure!! Beautiful atmosphere and beautiful people that work there...I highly recommend this place!!
Everyone was friendly, the food and desserts were out of this world, and the atmosphere is amazing. Will be back very soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place. Such a great atmosphere, especially for a date. The food is delicious with a lot of unique options, and the staff is extremely friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome restaurant inside old Bank Food is excellent as well the service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Outstanding server. She does a great job . Good was great. Will come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had our daughter’s baby shower here and everything was perfect! Brian and Theresa went out of their way to ensure that our food was delicious and ready exactly when we were! Our guests who had not been here before were impressed with the ambience provided by the renovated old bank building, including its original teller windows, wall and ceiling effects and vault room, where we stored the gifts, but which can be also be used for a creative small-group dining experience. We have brought several guests here for lunch or dinner on more “ordinary” days, and Selah has always come through with its tasty food (especially its one-of-a-kind cakes), dependable service and unique atmosphere. Classic jazz and swing playing quietly in the background enhances the experience. The restaurant also has dinner theater and distinctive summer alley parties featuring local talent. We highly recommend making the drive slightly off the beaten path to Selah!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Service and place were awesome but we went for the gnocchi and they were out. Definitely going back to try them hear they are the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Terrible experience from start to finish. The restaurant smelled awful the moment we walked in, like something had gone bad. The service was incredibly slow and the staff seemed uninterested — no one checked on our table, and when we did get our food, it was cold, bland, and honestly inedible. The place felt dirty and poorly managed. Definitely not worth the money or time. I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I went here about a week ago while visiting the state and even after returning home it still bothers me. I did not enjoy the service, I couldn't even properly give a 15% tip in good conscience. The server didn't come to check on us more than once through the meal and wasn't even the one to run us our food. I ran out of my drink and had to wait until after our meal was finished to even get a refill. The food wasn't even that great to be worth this level of service. Sure the place looked nice, but everything about my visit was just subpar.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Worst dinner service I've ever had. Server referred to me as a snow beaner because they heard my Canadian accent. Asked if I wanted a cup of maple syrup with my dinner. But wouldn't call me his 'buddy'. Told me to go back to my igloo when I complained.
2/10, never again, eh.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Poor service, horrible wait times, and my server brought up my bald spot which hurt my insecurities. I don't remember what her name was but it started with an S. My food was under cooked and my beer was WARM. If I could leave a 0 star review I would.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...