If you've never tried the elmton,you're in for a treat. They're pizza is unique, in a good way. The chicken is fantastic. Do yourself favor and take the trip. You won't be sorry.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cake
Pizza is unbeatable. You can't go wrong with even plain cheese & wings. The wings are huge & moist & crispy. The value for your money is well worth it compared to other local shops and def smokes any pizza chain.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Louie Palumbo
Excellent food and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
bobpQ3935KD
Ordered a 16" pepperoni pizza for takeout 09/11/2025, and I must say it was well off Elmton's standards, sauce was bitter and the crust was hard to chew. The pizza consistency is hit or miss.
Jennifer Non
OH MY GOD!! I love their broasted chicken. Because i was confined to a wheelchair for over a year i missed their food so much. But im back on my feet and their food is just as good as i remember!
Kelly Williamson
Love the nostalgic atmosphere! The pizza was good.
Roberta Pannutti
my favorite place to get pizza and a beer. and you have to try the braised chicken 😋😋😋
Michael Williamson
Historic and legendary Youngstown pizza. Established 1945. The best
Shauna Cortez
So far, I've only picked up my food from Elmtons. The staff goes above and beyond for me. They are always welcoming and sweet, and they helped me bring my food to my car when I was pregnant. The food is always amazing 👏 🥰🤗
If you've never tried the elmton,you're in for a treat. They're pizza is unique, in a good way. The chicken is fantastic. Do yourself favor and take the trip. You won't be sorry.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is unbeatable. You can't go wrong with even plain cheese & wings. The wings are huge & moist & crispy. The value for your money is well worth it compared to other local shops and def smokes any pizza chain.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a 16" pepperoni pizza for takeout 09/11/2025, and I must say it was well off Elmton's standards, sauce was bitter and the crust was hard to chew. The pizza consistency is hit or miss.
OH MY GOD!! I love their broasted chicken. Because i was confined to a wheelchair for over a year i missed their food so much. But im back on my feet and their food is just as good as i remember!
Love the nostalgic atmosphere! The pizza was good.
my favorite place to get pizza and a beer. and you have to try the braised chicken 😋😋😋
Historic and legendary Youngstown pizza. Established 1945. The best
So far, I've only picked up my food from Elmtons. The staff goes above and beyond for me. They are always welcoming and sweet, and they helped me bring my food to my car when I was pregnant. The food is always amazing 👏 🥰🤗
Nice Atmosphere and Food.
Restaurantji Recommends
It’s our to go place. Everything is great.
I crave Elmton, s great food.. The daily specials are unbeatable in price and quality 😋
I have been going there since I was little. Love there pizza and broasted wings.
Pizza 🍕 is the best
We get it often...
Great fish dinners
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish, Broasted Chicken, 16 Inch Cheese Pizza, Sausage Pizza
Loading...