Benchwarmers Restaurant and Delivery

105 Allen St, Tiffin
(567) 268-9268

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mike Jarnac

Great food and great service

pamela morrison

It's a small pub and not a lot of tables . I didn't expect it to be so crowded during the middle of the week for lunch but after getting our food I understand why. For the prices it was pretty cheap the kids meals were just enough and they ate it all and said it was good. The wings were yummy and they said the hamburgers and chicken chunks were good. The wait time was long but it was worth it. The waitress deserves a raise for her effort on waiting and serving all the tables by herself. Probably the cook also. Go try it out the menu was a lot of stuff and if I didn't live 1 hour and 40 minutes away I would go there often. The fries are like fair Fry's so yummy the bowl was a large we shared between 4 of us . Bone in wings price varies ours was 8.99 for 6 . They also had larger portions. What was great is you can order single burgers double and triple. Just go and try it . It was Worth it 😃😊

Todd Huebner

Great place for burgers. They are delicious. Variety of French fry options and soft pretzels better than any other I've had.

Cameren Smith

Very poor service, especially when they get your order wrong not once, but twice in the same day. I understand mistakes are made, but they did nothing to resolve the issue. I waited over two hours for a replacement pepperoni melt (which has 3 ingredients) and they decided ham and onion would be a good addition. But hey, at least I got a $10 certificate to a restaurant I will never be ordering from ever again! I am very disappointed as I order from here once a month and our store orders from here at least 2-3 times a month. Overall, very disappointed and I will never be ordering from Benchwarmers again. Guess I’ll have to find another local business to support! Any recommendations?

Joy Flechtner

customer service is not the special of the day at benchwarmers.
we ordered take out, on a friday. i know the wait was to be expected but getting the wrong order after an hour and waiting another two and a half for another wrong order was enough to ensure i won’t be visiting here again

justin kersh

Love this place. VERY good food.

L J

Zach was very friendly and his service was on point! The chili burger and pickle fries were amazing.

Stephen Smith

Came in for lunch had great food and the waitress was awesome!! The lunch rush came and she still had everyone served!!

Natasha Lynch

Food was fantastic

donnie smith

I get a smaller Bdubs vibe from here. But their portions here at Benchwarmers is definitely bigger. The food is always good when we go. Service was great as well.

Andy Felter

Tori at Benchwarmers is great, friendly, and very accommodating!! 10 / 10 on service!! The food was phenomenal and the overall atmosphere was great!!

-TTV_Haymaker- 50

Tried calling to order take-out and they hung up on me based on their atmosphere being loud.

Kimberly Hughes

Just not impressed.

Lindsay Hicks

Girl that answers the phone isn't very pleasant. Takes away from the great food they have at this place. Love the piggy burgers and fries!

R R

Friend ordered a Han n Cheese sub There was literally 1 THIN slice of ham on the sub. It was all bun I cannot get the photo attached but did take one

Loading...

Benchwarmers Restaurant and Delivery

105 Allen St, Tiffin, OH 44883
(567) 268-9268