Benchwarmers Restaurant and Delivery

105 Allen St, Tiffin
(567) 268-9268

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Build Your Own Grilled Cheese
Boneless Chicken Wings
Mushroom Swiss Burger
All American Burger
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Triple Cheeseburger
Steakhouse Burger
Chicken Sandwich
Alpine Sandwich
Boneless Wings

Menu

Pre-Game
Onion Petals
Served with bistro sauce.
Cheese Curds
Half pound of delicious white cheddar cheese curds served with either ranch or pizza sauce.
Pickle Fries
Served with ranch dressing.
Soft Pretzel Sticks
Served with beer cheese.
Breaded Mushrooms
Served with ranch dressing.
Sweet Potato Fries
Served with cinnamon honey butter.
Funnel Cake Fries
Served with chocolate sauce.

Premium Subs
Steak
Juicy sirloin steak sautéed with caramelized onions and roasted red peppers. Topped with house-sliced provolone cheese and house-made steakhouse aioli.
Flaming Chicken
Chicken breast, Hot Pepper cheese, jalapeños and house-made kickin' buffalo sauce.
Pepperoni Melt
Deli pepperoni layered generously with provolone cheese and house-made pizza sauce.
Turkey
Slow roasted turkey stacked with bacon, pepper jack cheese, and creamy ranch. Served on a sub roll.
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Slow roasted turkey stacked with bacon, pepper jack cheese, and creamy ranch. Served on a sub roll.
The Italian Stallion
Genoa salami, Capicola, and provolone cheese baked to perfection. Finished with our house Italian dressing, red onion, pepperoncinis, and tomato.
The Gobbler
Everyday is Thanksgiving with this sandwich! Roasted turkey breast stacked with stuffing and finished with our tangy cranberry aioli. Served on a sub bun.
Ham and Swiss
Smoked ham and Guggisberg Swiss cheese, topped with lettuce, tomato and mayo.
Chicken Parm
Chicken breast, house pizza sauce, provolone cheese and a garlic romano sprinkle.
BLT
Crispy Bacon loaded on our Artisan sub bun with lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Chicken Cordon Bleu
Grilled chicken, house-sliced ham, and guggisburg swiss cheese topped with honey Mustard.
Pulled Pork
Slow-cooked pork smothered in your choice of house-made BBQ or Carolina Mustard and topped with creamy coleslaw.
Chicken Philly
Try our famous steak sub with chicken instead.

Burgers
All American Burger
American cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickle, and white onion.
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Sautéed Mushroom and Guggisberg swiss cheese.
Cowboy Burger
Crispy onion petals, cheddar cheese, bacon and house BBQ sauce.
Greek Burger
Cucumber, red peppers, feta cheese and cilantro jalapeno hummus.
Pizza Burger
Deli style pepperoni, provolone cheese and house pizza sauce.
Steakhouse Burger
Caramelized onions, red peppers, sautéed mushrooms, provolone cheese and our steakhouse aioli.
Bacon Cheesy Burger
Bacon and American cheese piled high.
Southwest Burger
Cheddar cheese, corn salsa, lettuce, tomato and roasted jalapeno ranch sauce.
Chili Burger
Our house chili, hot pepper cheese and Carolina mustard sauce.
Buffalo Bleu Cheese Burger
Hot pepper cheese, red onion, jalapeno and house buffalo sauce. Served with bleu cheese dressing on the side.
Piggy Burger
Slow-cooked pork smothered in white cheddar cheese. Topped with creamy coleslaw and house-made BBQ or Carolina Mustard.

Slammin Sammies
Clubhouse
House-sliced Ham and turkey, bacon, white cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, and house-made Honey Mustard.
The Greek
Fresh sliced cucumber, tomato, red onion, black olive and, roasted red peppers on deli bread topped with feta cheese and cilantro jalapeno hummus.
The Alpine
The classic breaded cutlet sandwich, back by popular demand.
Cuban
Our take on a cuban sandwich. House pulled pork, sliced ham, Swiss, dill pickles, and Carolina mustard, served on sourdough.
Spicy Stallion
House-sliced provolone, hot pepper cheese, salami, roasted red peppers, and pepperoncinis served with a side of Italian dressing.
Wild Turkey
House-sliced hot pepper cheese and white cheddar cheese, house-sliced turkey, and a side of Hot Garlic Parmesan.

Chicken Wings
Bonless Wings
Juicy breaded boneless chicken wings perfectly fried and tossed in your sauce of choice.
Jumbo Bone-In Wings

Fresh Cut Fries
Philly Fries
Sirloin steak, caramelized onions, roasted red peppers, provolone cheese and topped with steakhouse aioli. Large size only

Wraps
Southwest Chicken Wrap
Grilled or crispy chicken, house made corn salsa, lettuce and cheddar cheese. All wrapped up in a jalapeno cheddar wrap with ranch or our chipotle ranch.
Buffalo Chicken
Grilled or crispy chicken tossed in our classic buffalo with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and ranch.
Greek
Lettuce, cucumber. red onion, tomatoes, pepperoncini's, and black olives topped with feta cheese and hummus.
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Grilled or crispy chicken, bacon, lettuce, shredded cheddar cheese, and ranch.
Clubhouse
House-sliced turkey and ham, bacon, tomatoes, and locally grown lettuce topped with shredded cheddar cheese, and honey mustard.
Chicken Ceaser Wrap
Grilled or crispy chicken, parmesan cheese, lettuce, tomato, croutons and Caesar dressing.

Greens
Zesty Chicken
Our Boneless chicken wings or grilled chicken tossed in the wing sauce of your choice. Cucumber, red onion, tomato and cheddar cheese. Served with ranch or bleu cheese.
Greek
Cucumber, black olive, red onion, pepperoncinis, tomato and feta. Red wine vinaigrette.
Chef Sald
Our house sliced ham and turkey with cucumber, tomato, hard boiled egg, cheddar cheese, and crotons.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
Grilled chicken, crispy bacon, cheddar cheese and red onion. Served with ranch dressing.
Antipasto
House-sliced Salami and ham, black olives, tomato, peppercinnis, and provolone cheese.

Little Sluggers Menu
Boneless Chicken Wings and Fries
Served with a side of dipping sauce.
Cheeseburger and Fries
Grilled Cheese and Fries
Pizza Sandwich and Fries

Drinks
House Made Lemonade
Soda Cans
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, mountain dew, dr. Pepper, mist twist, and mug root beer.
Soda (2 Liters)
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, mountain dew, dr. Pepper, mist twist, and mug root beer.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+28 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+27 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

Was super excited to find this location as we really were sad that the Bellevue location closed. The burgers are amazing. The fry portions are generous. Lots of options for the burgers!
August 2025
The place itself had such a relaxing atmosphere and the staff was friendly right off the bat....the food itself was AMAZING and sooooo filling. The Miller was nice and ice cold and the sports were going smooth. I recommend to ANYONE that loves a good family sports place 🤌🤌🤌
July 2025
My family and I were on road and decided to try out the benchwarmer’s restaurant! The service was amazing and they stayed on top of everything! The food was incredible as well. All around a very wonderful environment!
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Best Break - 604 Miami St
Clubs, Cafe
Big Dipper Ice Cream and more - 380 Wentz St
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream
Chipotle Mexican Grill - 596 W Market St
Mexican, Fast Food

Benchwarmers Restaurant and Delivery

105 Allen St, Tiffin, OH 44883
(567) 268-9268