Jimmy John's

2161 W Market St, Tiffin
(567) 220-6539

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Michael McCurdy

I went here recently and there was a kind gentleman that was working the window wearing a beanie. He was kind and patient with my order! I definitely recommend going back to this store cause of his great customer service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cassi Traunero

Says they are open. Definitely visible employees inside. All doors are locked. No one answered the drive theough even though visible employee was standing there. Tried calling and no answer. Haven't been here in years and this is what happens. Won't be coming back.

Gregory Garth

Randomly closed. No staff or they keep the door locked so they don't have to work. Subways not as good but it's not as difficult to get a damn sandwich either !!!!

Shawn Brown

I ordered a sandwich through door dash but the sandwich never got delivered. I called the store and the teenager who answered said they don't use door dash and have another's contactor and couldn't deliver my sandwich. She was very rude. I questioned her about the situation and she hung up on me. Called back and spoke with manager. He wasn't quite as rude but was rude and never explained anything to me about how I should order so I gave up.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

jams yeah

Randomly closed. No staff or they keep the door locked so they don't have to work. Subways not as good but it's not as difficult to get a damn sandwich either !!!!

Hunter Opp

Literally didn’t even try to deliver my order. Waited an hour and a half for one sub so I called, they claimed they were at the warehouse and called me. I got no call, they didn’t walk up to any doors and knock or drop it off. Just voided and didn’t say a word. Money still came off the card though of course.Ridiculous.

Tina Woetko

Amazing food. Fresh ingredients

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Double Ham & Provolone

JD K

It's 7pm on April 20th and I am unable to place an order through the app or calling the store. I am unable to even get through calling to the store and I am less than 2 miles away.

OG D3THST4R

It's 7pm on April 20th and I am unable to place an order through the app or calling the store. I am unable to even get through calling to the store and I am less than 2 miles away.

Tanette (Tyger)

Delicious quality sandwiches made to order and served very quickly. I do wish their delivery area was 5 miles. I would eat their food more often. We are, alas, 2.1 miles away ...so 1 minute past their zone. Its a good simple meal when we are out and about. The Jimmy chips and pickles are really good!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lauren Pressley

I had gotten a sandwich from here 3 days ago and forgot about it. Around 1 am I was hungry and besides the veggies it saved good. The bread wasn’t soggy at all. This is a very durable and tasty sandwich place. I mean if you can’t eat a sandwich late at night hunched over it like a gremlin, as your cat gives you side eyes because you’re inhaling it then what’s the point of having a sandwich place? Right?10/10 would recommend. It was still so delicious and held up so great. I love Jimmy John’s I never have a bad experience ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Heavy duty Reviews

I'm on a low fat diet and these guys have several items I can order! The sun's are delicious with superb fresh bread, meat, and veggies! I always get it freaky fast!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah Palumbo

This location is consistently short-staffed and often does not have delivery drivers available, and the lobby has been closed for dining for months. The food is usually good and the folks who do show up are usually courteous, but I can't give full marks when they advertise services they can't provide consistently. Owner needs to figure out their issue keeping staff. Also the parking lot (which I understand is the building owners issue) is terribly maintained and has potholes that could fit a toddler in them.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 2

Tanette Wildman Arana

Delicious quality sandwiches made to order and served very quickly. I do wish their delivery area was 5 miles. I would eat their food more often. We are, alas, 2.1 miles away ...so 1 minute past their zone. Its a good simple meal when we are out and about. The Jimmy chips and pickles are really good!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brandi

I love jimmys, always fast and friendly. I work next door and they never let me down when I’m looking for a fast tasty lunch

Loading...