Bazemore Pizza Company

So Bazemore Pizza Co. Is located inside Pointe Tavern in Upper Arlington Ohio.

Italian Sub - This was thee best take on a classic sub I have ever had. I’m still trying to figure out how something so simple and yet it tastes so complex? Like the taste of Bazemore’s Italian sub was absolutely F’n phenomenal! The bun had a crispy crust and the inside was warm and delight, everything inside was straight magic!

The Margarita Pizza - 1st off, full disclosure I should note that I came here mainly because the place was featured on One Bite and the fact Dave Portnoy gave it an amazing review. So yeah, I had to come and it’s worth the drive from Westerville to Upper Arlington. Just look at the picture! If that doesn’t tell you what it tastes like, then nothing will!

Chicken Wings - Classic Buffalo, Dank Dust Dry Rub (🔥 my favorite), Juli-Q (2nd fav)

Italian Meat Balls - These MF’ers melt in your mouth, just get them!

So I actually got to meet Billy & Todd, great guys. I just need them to move closer to my side of town.

One of the best Italian subs I’ve ever had. Toasty bun a flavors in sub were delicious. Staff was friendly too. I’ll be back for sure!

Sports atmosphere, great hospitality, amazing food, first time visiting Bazemore Pizza, I’ll definitely be a repeat customer. Thanks!!!

The pizza here is fantastic! Consistently one of the best pies in Columbus and the owner always comes out to check on us. Would highly recommend this place.

The meatballs were out of this world. Wings fantastic, dry rub. The pizza was classic. Can’t wait to go back.

Delicious from start to finish. Bazemore Pizza serves up a pie that is absolute heaven. The Italian Sub is without a doubt the best Italian sub in the city. You can rest the fork on top of the meatballs and they glide right through. You can tell when a owner cares about their food, Bazemore cares.

We got meatballs, wings, the house salad and a cheese pizza. All were fresh and tasted amazing. The meatballs were so moist and not at all dense. Some of the best the four of us have had. Salad had fried up pepperonis on it, such a fun add. Plus the homemade dressing was really tasty. Wings with just the dry rub were large and hit the spot. Pizza though, fantastic. Not floppy and really like how the sauce is on top of the cheese and not swimming in it under the cheese. Over all we loved everything. Will be back again soon!!

I ordered a deluxe pizza and asked the bartender if I could sub the banana peppers for mushrooms little did we know he charged us for a custom and charged us 3.50 per topping i saw the bill and he said afterwards no substitutions.. there's no place on the menu that says that! 32$ for this awful pizza. It has zero flavor and the young bartenders are rude. They're deceiving! They only took off our 2 drinks. We will never give them business again.

Bazemore Pizza is DELICIOUS!! We ordered the mushroom and the deluxe - their mushroom pizza is now officially my favorite in town! Also, the dry rub wings are phenomenal, I highly recommend giving them a try.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mushroom Pizza, The Deluxe, Chicken Wings

Might be some of the best pizza in Columbus!! Todd and Billy aren’t messing around with this pizza! Their dry rub on their wings are on another level, and the meatball pizza with sauce dolloped on top was such a unique and delicious addition to their pizza! Everyone NEEDS to run and try this pizza!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings, The Meatball

Saw this spot in a Facebook post and gave them a try. The meatball pizza stood out a bit with all ingredients tasting very fresh and the meatball slices being as tender as meatloaf. Also picked up two classic pies (one pep, one cheese) that were solid. Good service, mom and pop atmosphere, worth a try.

Food: 5

Service: 4

HOLY COW!! I honestly can't say anything else! The meatball pizza is amazing.. The chicken cutlet sandwich is even better. We also had some amazing Buffalo and Dry Rub wings with a salad and fried pickles! Great price even better flavor. Don't sleep on it JUST GO!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meatball and Pepperoni Pizza

We tried 4 different item menus and every single thing was amazing!!! You cannot go wrong by ordering Bazemore Pizza!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings, Checking the Pizza

Everything was absolutely delicious! I could eat the Italian sub everyday of my life. Perfect pizza, and tender flavorful meatballs. Food was on point! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Got custom pizza with3 toppings mushrooms pepperoni and banana peppers 614 said this was east coast pizza blend it is not one of the most greasy salty pizza I have ever had crust was burnt and hard.way overpriced.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1