Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse

As usual dining at Hyde Park Upper Arlington was a memorable experience. Our server Colin was very professional and friendly. The food from the appetizer to the desert was excellent. We couldn't have had a better place to spend our anniversary .

Excellent food and service. Dining at Hyde Park Upper Arlington is always a memorable experience.

food excellent waitress was efficient but not that friendly vibe you usually get. also they should never clear the table when one peraon is still eating

Had a very enjoyable dinner with friends. Brandy was extremely efficient, never let our drinks run dry, and paced everything perfectly. Steaks were cooked perfectly and everything was delicious. Thank you for a fabulous evening!

Well after a less than stellar steak was served to us last month at a very prominent restaurant at Easton Town Center, which restaurant will remain unnamed, we were very impressed and delighted with the quality of the food at Hyde Park in Upper Arlington. Every single aspect of the experience was noteworthy. It was a little difficult to find a parking space when we arrived for our 7 pm reservation on a Friday night. But the staff directed us to a lot across the street we could use. We were seated immediately. Chris was our server. He was friendly and knowledgeable about the menu, although to tell you the truth, the four of us already knew what we wanted. This Hyde Park location is a little off of the beaten path. Last month when I went to visit a friend at a nearby rehab facility, it occurred to me...Hyde Park...that's the place we'll go when our friends come to town in April! And all four of us felt the same way. Hyde Park offers more options than steak, but based on the four of us, we'd say, if you are in the mood for steak...this is definitely the best place to go. My husband and I shared the chopped salad...superb! I had the escargot, and it was the best I'd had in a long while. At the table we had two of the Steak Kosar dishes, it is served Oscar style with half a lobster tail, bernaise and bordelaise sauces and asparagus. Another had the Steak Woody. (My husband and I shared a larger portion of the Steak Kosar.) We also had a side order of Lobster Mac & Cheese and each couple shared a wonderful Butter Cake Bananas Foster dish. The atmosphere was vibrant but certainly quiet enough to enjoy conversation at our own table and not bothered by hearing the diners at other tables. Hyde Park has just become our new favorite restaurant for steak. We won't forget it is tucked away there off of Old Henderson Road. Now if others read this...it will be harder to get a table. Tip: Make a reservation!

Unfortunately we had a bad server which diminished our experience. We have always loved Hyde Park UA and this is the first time I've had a bad steak that was overdone. Our server just was not very good and did not listen well, and wanted to rush us along. The last time we dined her was on my birthday, which was Valentine's Day, and our server that time took amazing care of us. This time, our salad was out before we were done with our appetizer and my steak arrived before I was done with my salad. And my steak was well done (ordered medium rare). The lamb appetizer was amazing which saved my experience but definitely need to request a different server and also make sure that our dishes are served with more time in between. We were celebrating my fiancé's birthday and would have spent more on beverages had we had the opportunity. So disappointed and so unlike any of our other experiences here.

One of the best meals we have ever had at a prime steakhouse. The service and the food were amazing and made us feel so welcome. Multiple people greeted and spoke with us throughout the meal and made sure we were enjoying every moment, which we definitely were. Way too many items on the menu to try, so a return visit is a must!! Such a great time to celebrate our 25th wedding anniversary. We will return soon and bring friends. Thank you for a fantastic experience.

My husband and I stopped in for our anniversary dinner. The vibe was nice. Staff were friendly and professional. Our server, CODY, did a phenomenal job and answered any questions we had. Food was absolutely excellent with an asthetic presentation. We shared a bottle of Cab, crab cakes and Rockefeller oysters. For entrée, Hubs had the tomahawk and I got the sea bass. We received the creme Brule as complementary dessert . Highly recommend. 10/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Prime Tomahawk Ribeye, Crab Cakes

Mouth watering

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Shrimp Cocktail, Prime Tomahawk Ribeye, Wedge Salad, The Bobby Rahal Steak

Wonderful atmosphere for a special relaxed evening. Kudos to the entire staff who are a unique blend of attentive & friendly, especially Jamal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup, The Bobby Rahal Steak, Greyare Gratin Potatoes

I server was amazing the supervisor came and checked in on the table that’s was amazing. Nobody do that anymore. The food was 10 out of 10 highly recommend. Had the best date night ever.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was ok. Shrimp cocktail was fresh and their cocktail sauce is really good. Tune app was over sauced and watery. Not very good. House salad was tasty and just the right size. Caesar salads were underwhelming and over priced. Steaks weren't cooked as well as they had been in our past experiences there. Although I love a fatty ribeye this one was too fatty. Ordered med rare and it was undercooked, almost rare in spots. Strips at table seemed better. Mushroom side was good. Creme brûlée dessert was a tad runny but really tasty. Can't say enough about the service. Impeccable as usual. Our server was Justin and he did a great job.

Hyde Park in UA is the place to go for a lovely dining experience with a celebration. My wife have gone there for years, and it's always incredible. The rustic ambiance, the waitstaff, the food - it's all nothing short of phenomenal. Our server the last two anniversaries has been Eddie, and wow does that guy hustle. He's friendly, fun, funny, and treats us like we're his only customers. I cannot recommend this experience enough.

One our favorite places to eat in the Columbus area. Steaks are always cooked perfectly and the shareable sides are delicious (and huge!) This particular location definitely has the old time steakhouse vibe and the bartender makes fantastic drinks.

You'll never be disappointed with Hyde Park.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Bobby Rahal Steak