Amazing crust on the deep dish pizza! Crispy on the bottom, soft texture in the middle.The sauce is tangy yet sweet, an impossible combination to pull off in a pizza sauce!We ordered our medium 8-slice deep dish pizza topped with pepperoni, bacon, onion, and pineapple. It was superb! After devouring my first slice, I asked my wife if she thought it was too late to order a large!This pizza is so good that we're considering a two-hour road trip to come back again!
Robert Hatfield
What can I say. Had a personal pan, and it was incredible. Smiles and so friendly. First 5 star for me I
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristen Fletcher
Got take out and the ends of the subs where burnt and un able to eat have changed alot in a bad way.also asked for onions barely any couldn't taste them .
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Dylan Parks
Call to order food said the card machine was working when I get there said it wasn’t working had to drive to the bank pull money out drive back and all they said was my
Service: 1
Scott Eddington
Great pizza and friendly staff
Harry Matheny
Their crust is sooooo very delicious! Crispy, buttery and decadent. Great spot, nice people.Well worth it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Duane Gerstenberger
The best pizza we have had from any Upper Sandusky restaurant. Employee on the phone was extremely nice. Delivery person was super friendly. Keep up the good work store number 23!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Melinda Monroe
Don't waste your time the manager is rude and refuses to replace a half cooked pizza made us both sick. Your loss we order once a week atleast your establishment has lost our business for life. Also trying to contact corporate I don't believe they will appreciate this.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Matthew Allison
Best pizza ? buffet around. Lots of choices well stocked for lunch. Poppers are amazing ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar
Tobey Basinger
Love east of Chicago Pizza best of all during lunch buffet. I do wish they had more than just 2 topping pizzas on the buffet maybe a good all meat. Normally you'll find a pepperoni, a sausage, or a bacon sometimes a sausage/bacon or something. But still an amazing buffet.Dietary restrictions: Their crust is dairy free. You just have to order no cheese like we do for our daughter, who is allergic. They don't have a gluten free option like some other pizza places do now. My wife just eats the salad bar since she can't eat the pizza anymore.
Chicken bacon ranch sub is soooooo delicious I love it and that says a lot cuz I hate ranch
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laura Haseley-Wilson
I gave one star because giving zero was not an option. My family and I decided to try the buffet. The salad bar (a phrase I'm using loosely) was just iceberg lettuce, shredded carrots, olives, shredded cheese, pepperoni and maybe pickles or banana peppers.The pizza looked as though it was sitting out as it looked dried and burnt. With the exception of the thin crust cheese, everything had meat on it. I tried a slice of pepperoni that seemed to escape getting any meat. Had it not been for the grease, it would have had no taste. An employee said she eod puy out a mushroom and a cheese. Evidently, "mushroom" meant pepperoni with mushroom crumbs. Fortunately, my money was refunded. I will not return and stick with grocery store frozen pizzas. The few that I get (including store brands) are better and cheaper than restaurants.Vegetarian options: They might have vegetarian options on the menu, as most pizza restaurants tend to have. However, I was disgusted and not interested.Wheelchair accessibility: The main entrance has a step and no sign directing one to an accessible entrance.
Steven Raymond
I'm new in town, I have had nothing but awesome food from here. The people are great and I always get hot fast delivery..... keep up what you doing.Ps. The wings are huge ?. The would make three of Buffalo wild wings.. wing
Amanda Forman
Cheri and Connie always treat you like family when you are in there. Love the buffet. They always have a great variety of pizza, salad bar and other buffet options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Audrey Ferrier
the foods decent when they actually put there phone on the hook and stop closing early.
Amazing crust on the deep dish pizza! Crispy on the bottom, soft texture in the middle.The sauce is tangy yet sweet, an impossible combination to pull off in a pizza sauce!We ordered our medium 8-slice deep dish pizza topped with pepperoni, bacon, onion, and pineapple. It was superb! After devouring my first slice, I asked my wife if she thought it was too late to order a large!This pizza is so good that we're considering a two-hour road trip to come back again!
What can I say. Had a personal pan, and it was incredible. Smiles and so friendly. First 5 star for me I
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got take out and the ends of the subs where burnt and un able to eat have changed alot in a bad way.also asked for onions barely any couldn't taste them .
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Call to order food said the card machine was working when I get there said it wasn’t working had to drive to the bank pull money out drive back and all they said was my
Service: 1
Great pizza and friendly staff
Their crust is sooooo very delicious! Crispy, buttery and decadent. Great spot, nice people.Well worth it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best pizza we have had from any Upper Sandusky restaurant. Employee on the phone was extremely nice. Delivery person was super friendly. Keep up the good work store number 23!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Don't waste your time the manager is rude and refuses to replace a half cooked pizza made us both sick. Your loss we order once a week atleast your establishment has lost our business for life. Also trying to contact corporate I don't believe they will appreciate this.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Best pizza ? buffet around. Lots of choices well stocked for lunch. Poppers are amazing ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar
Love east of Chicago Pizza best of all during lunch buffet. I do wish they had more than just 2 topping pizzas on the buffet maybe a good all meat. Normally you'll find a pepperoni, a sausage, or a bacon sometimes a sausage/bacon or something. But still an amazing buffet.Dietary restrictions: Their crust is dairy free. You just have to order no cheese like we do for our daughter, who is allergic. They don't have a gluten free option like some other pizza places do now. My wife just eats the salad bar since she can't eat the pizza anymore.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Chicken bacon ranch sub is soooooo delicious I love it and that says a lot cuz I hate ranch
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I gave one star because giving zero was not an option. My family and I decided to try the buffet. The salad bar (a phrase I'm using loosely) was just iceberg lettuce, shredded carrots, olives, shredded cheese, pepperoni and maybe pickles or banana peppers.The pizza looked as though it was sitting out as it looked dried and burnt. With the exception of the thin crust cheese, everything had meat on it. I tried a slice of pepperoni that seemed to escape getting any meat. Had it not been for the grease, it would have had no taste. An employee said she eod puy out a mushroom and a cheese. Evidently, "mushroom" meant pepperoni with mushroom crumbs. Fortunately, my money was refunded. I will not return and stick with grocery store frozen pizzas. The few that I get (including store brands) are better and cheaper than restaurants.Vegetarian options: They might have vegetarian options on the menu, as most pizza restaurants tend to have. However, I was disgusted and not interested.Wheelchair accessibility: The main entrance has a step and no sign directing one to an accessible entrance.
I'm new in town, I have had nothing but awesome food from here. The people are great and I always get hot fast delivery..... keep up what you doing.Ps. The wings are huge ?. The would make three of Buffalo wild wings.. wing
Cheri and Connie always treat you like family when you are in there. Love the buffet. They always have a great variety of pizza, salad bar and other buffet options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
the foods decent when they actually put there phone on the hook and stop closing early.