Pisanello's Pizza Waterville

Typically love this place. Yesterday I ordered two pizzas and instead got a pizza and sub delivered. They brought my second pizza and it still wasn’t the stuff crust I ordered…… hope it was just an off day.

best pizza in Waterville!!

20/10. These wonderful people have gone above and beyond for me, Every. Single. Order. I’ve literally never had a better relationship with a pizza place, and the food! The best of the best! On point, every single time! They care about customer satisfaction. Period! I Love Pisanello’s, Waterville! Thank you, I appreciate you so much!
- Paul T.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Family owned and operated. Great pizza, Subs and Salads. Support Local!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza! Once you try it, it will be your go to pizza place.

Ordered online and had delivered. Was great! Will be back!

Food: 5

Service: 5

The Best pizza and subs!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best Pizza in Waterville hands down!!! Love the owners and the small town feel. Only negative is too many teen workers when you walk in you feel bombarded with teen energy. But will still order on a monthly basis!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

WE HAVE BEEN ORDERING A PIZZA FROM PISANELLOS WATERVILLE OHIO WEEKLY FOR AT LEAST THE LAST 7 MONTHS. WE LIKE OUR PIZZA BROWNED ON TOP. THEY HAVE ALWAYS BEEN ACCOMODATING IN MY REQUEST. EXCELLENT PIZZA IN OUR AREA.
LAST SUNDAY I PLACED OUR USUAL ORDER...BROWNED ON TOP. UPON PICK UP I WAS TOLD BY THE LADY THAT ALWAYS BAKES THE PIZZA THAT SHE WILL NO LONGER HONOR MY REQUEST TO BROWN THE PIZZA AS REQUESTED...AS IT MESSES UP HER ASSEMBLY LINE BY HAVING TO PUT THE PIZZA BACK IN TO BROWN IT.
I LOOKED A THE PHOTOS OF PIZZAS ON THEIR WEBSITE...GUESS WHAT...IT SHOWS BROWNED PIZZAS.
SO MY QUESTION IS..IF YOU WENT TO PURCHASE A STEAK AT A STEAK HOUSE AND THE MANAGER TOLD YOU THAT THEY WILL NOT COOK THE STEAK TO ORDER...WHAT WOULD YOU DO ?????
TIME TO FIND A PIZZA STORE THAT WILL ACCOMODATE MY REQUEST..........

Good pizza. Seemed family owned. Tasty stuff 😋 👌 get ya some.

They are always so nice and my food is done quickly!

We were passing through from Wisconsin. Even though it is a carryout pizza place, the very friendly owner set us up with a table, plates, napkins and even bottled water. The pizza had REAL mozzarella cheese..hot and stringy. The sauce was great and the crust crispy. Wish there were one in Wisconsin.

If I could give 0 star then I would. Credit card machine was down and was not told that. I was a dollar short on cash and they wouldn't take it. Then after waiting 35 minutes I find out my pizzas still hadn't been put in the oven. Never again what a joke.

This place can't be beat for food and service! We live about 20 minutes away and it's worth the drive. We have tried something different every time, and the Mediterranean pizza and tomato bread are awesome! They even found some extra coupons for us in addition to the one we already had. Wonderful people, great food!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Pizza, Tomato Bread, Garlic Bread

Great food‼️? very friendly staff ????
The food is always perfected to order
Been comming here for years and there will be many years to come…. Great job ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5