Massey's Pizza - Whitehall

4464 E Main St, Whitehall
(614) 559-2222

Recent Reviews

Sort by
adam frontuto

45 minutes here(12:30pm-1:15pm). From the point we got here there was 4 pizzas all half gone or less. Not one new pizza brought out, the old one were orange and burnt. Salad was half flag missing most Ingedients and only two dressings ( so lettuce cheese banana peppers and dressing(yum). Nothing made or restocked the entire time. Chicken was good (not the usual frozen chicken wings) and for $32 for two people. I won't be back!

Cheryl Gwynn

Mary (the manager) was very rude. I would like to speak to corporate. She moved my pizza with her dirty hands (after touching cash) when I asked for pizza to be re-cut. She continued to argue after I ask for pizza to be re-made. Another manager (black lady) asked her to stop going back and forth. 5/19/2025 12:29 pm order order 5
Brandon Howard
12 inch pizza
2 fountain

Debra Anderson

The food was outstanding 😁 and fulfilling!!!
The customer service was top notch πŸ‘; very respectful ☺️!!!
And I would definitely recommend it to any and everyone πŸ™‚πŸ™‚!!!!!

Rena Hagley

They put a lot of pepperoni on my pizza, just the way I like it πŸ˜‹
I have to drive 4 hours to get good pizza. Currently live in Michigan, and there are no good pizza places like Massey's

Imbeautifulnaturally A

Called & recording said if ordered online u get $5 off 1st order but wouldn't allow to order for delivery online. Spoke to someone who had NO knowledge about anything smh yelled for someone named Mary who I assume was mgr. She was worse. No accountability just blamed delivery app & didn't offer to honor offer even though it was offered on recording when u call. I still ordered & food was cold & nasty. DEFINITELY not worth what I paid. Wouldn't even have been worth it with the $5 off

John Page

I have got really good wings and Pizza here before, but today I got the worst pizza ever. It was a bare bones supreme and it was cooked until it was like wood. I had to wait double the amount of time for the pizza. I will not be back.

Kidd Kato

Best lasagna for price

Edwin Ayers

I ordered one topping pepperoni from Whitehall. I had been a faithful patron of Donatos (family friends) since they opened but their quality and service became disappointing. Lukewarm pizza was the high point of every order. Massey's was a hit and it's right around the corner from my home. Even good cold the next day. You have a new faithful customer.

Sally Foster

Two pizzas cooked to perfection!

James Blevins

This is the funniest shit ever I mean a side salad that cost 4 bucks should be something it looks like a softball size with 5 pieces of lettuce goddamn never again

Chad β€œC-Bo” Bennett Sr.

Always great food and service!

charlie fabb

Food delicious, but waiting 15 minutes for subs, um..no

Jackie Parker

I'm from Ohio east side my friend sent me pizzas πŸ• one year for Christmas πŸŽ„ brought my memories back I'm fixing to order some and have shipped to Jacksonville NC

Annie1984

disappointed ordered a large pizza today and it was burnt.

Dimitrios Tsirlis

I ordered a pizza for delivery after I had waited for 50 minutes they called me back in a rude manner to tell me I wasn't in the zone and that they were slammed without offering any solutions or credit for wasting my time and having me wait hungry for this long.

Loading...