The Sandwich Man

612 S Yearling Rd, Whitehall
(614) 230-2501

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ernest Mingo

Had the chopped cheese burger washed it down with the Kool-Aid OMG!!! Delicious!!!! Will be back again…

Alpine7907

I went with the Philly cheese steak (add lettuce, tomatoes and jalapeno) and it was one of the best cheese steaks I've had in awhile. There was plenty of steak on the sandwhich, and I could tell that all the veggies were fresh. I also went with a side of Mac and cheese, which was the real deal! Hats off to B for making such a strong 1st impression, where it's a no brainer that I'll have to come back to try more of the items on his menu

Elizabeth Frazier

Welcomed with warm hospitality, only have been a couple times and the food has been excellent everytime. Today I got the Philly cheese sub, lemon pepper wings and a slaw dog. Delicious!

Tim Westcott

Made a quick stop and am glad I did. Crystal and Kamala took great care of me and loved my food.

Anthony Grandison

Food was great! I had perch and catfish, both were fried perfect and delicious. Sides were good, cabbage and greens were good and potatoe salad tast like moms. Pound cake melts in your mouth. Service was great. Try it you will like it.

Mcmahan Girl

I door dash some food from here for the first time I was disappointed I ordered a coney dog it came with no coney sauce on it and a side of mustard my Italian sub was so soggy man never again will I order from here...

Elena K

Everything sounded and looked good right up until a cockroach crawled out from behind the counter and from under the bench I was sitting on.
Everything went in the garbage

Kelvin Jackson

Excellent Philly cheesesteak sandwich. Yams were very good as well.

Matte Black

Awesome little hidden gem right outside columbus
Had a burger that was insanely good

Nik Boyd

The gentlemen who made our food did a phenomenal job! My partner and I will definitely be back, especially to try the fish fry.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Fries

Camille Wade

I ordered from DoorDash. I ordered the 5 wings with fries and drink and also an extra onion ring. Everything came besides the fries. So I call them telling them I didn’t receive my fries and whoever answered the phone was not nice and down right rude. They suggested I come pick up the fries smh I ordered on DoorDash which means for whatever reason I needed it delivered! I will never order from this place again. I love to support local,family business but I also work hard for my money and I expect what I PAID for!!

Food: 2

Service: 1

Jonathan Tenorio

This was my first time coming here and it’s exactly what it appears to be. A small business with a big heart. I don’t know about everyone else but sometimes the city is just too big, too many restaurant chains, we need little spots like this one. Food was incredible, it’s one guy making all the food and he even brought it out to me while I sat in the car. (I’m a big foodie)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Jumbo Coney Dog

P Reviews

This place picked a good name because it caught my eye from my love for sandwiches. It is hidden away within Whitehall, so I can see it being a decent travel for many people. All of the items on the menu looked appealing to me, but the menu needs work. It has items on it without any description of the items. For example, my turkey sub had banana peppers on them. I like banana peppers, but I know a lot of people who don’t and can see that being an issue. I ordered online through the business DoorDash partnership, which created a cold interaction with the person working there. He kept telling me to show him that I accepted the order on DoorDash, and asked if it was my first day since I couldn’t find the button. I then told him that I ordered the food for myself and his demeanor changed completely and was extremely nice and gave me the order. I have heard of DoorDash people scamming businesses so I understand his caution, but it could have been handled better. It would probably be best if he just asked if it’s a carry-out or a DoorDash order. I ordered a turkey sub, coney, and a side of coleslaw. The order was completed in 9 minutes, so keep that in mind if you have a far drive. The food was very good. Probably one of the best conies I have had. It was all very warm and flavorful and had the right balance of everything. If I’m in the area I’d like to try more of their menu.

Parking: There are a few parking spaces out front.

Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly food.

Wheelchair accessibility: Accessible.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Turkey Sandwich, Beef Coney Dog, Sub

Rell_Funnyashell

This place is a hidden gem. I had the pleasure of meeting the owner and he was very courteous, and showed great professionalism. The prices were reasonable and they have a wide selection of items. They also have specials I believe on certain days. I ordered the Philly with the onion rings and it did not disappoint. The onion rings tasted homemade and the Philly was on point. I definitely will be going back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Philly Steak, Onion Rings

Z M

If you haven't been there, get there. Great food, better people.

It's a to-go spot, and it's best to order ahead.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheeseburger

Loading...