Great pizza, some of the best. The only thing was that I only ordered on large and has to wait over an hour, so pizza ended up being almost room temp by the time it got to me. But he was so sweet, apologized, and explained that part of it was because he got lost. I understand that mistakes happen and everywhere is having trouble keeping up right now. Even with the wait, worth it! Just wish it could have been warmer ❤️ will order again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Jared Conley
Order online it was a little weird wouldn't let me pick my sauce for the wings I called they fixed it for me. Picking up was a great experience such a nice staff and the food was even better probably the best pizza in town. Wings were great and that cheesy bread was out of this world.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dane Jones
10-28-2023 - Knocked it down a star today as they updated the site to no longer offer delivery to my area.10-25-2023 - TL;DR: The online ordering "Slice" system has terrible support staff. NOT Danny Rays fault. If you have an issue call them directly DON'T use the Slice support. Danny will make it right. "Slice", Doesn't care.Full story: I had placed an order online and one of the delivered items was not made as requested (extra and missing toppings and missing sauce cup) I tried to get the issue corrected but was stone walled by the "Slice" online support people as they claimed that Danny's refused to refund or redeliver the issue items.Then I got a call from the owner the day after.He seen the initial review on google and wanted to rectify the issue. The owner took responsibility and had personally offered to deliver the corrected items (We already ate today so I requested it be deferred for the next day).If you have an issue CALL the restaurant and do not use the online "Slice" support chat as they will lie to you to get you.Continue to use the online ordering as it works fine.. just don't trust there support.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Stacey C
Try the Cheez Bread… you won’t regret it!
Paul Giangrande
Great Pizza, at a great price. We had the peperoni, and I do have to say it was a great pie. thanks Danny.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Allen
It's great pizza. Only problem we had was having to wait an hour and fifteen minutes for it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Big Dill Chicken Pizza
Tony Amato
Sub was good, Pizza could use some work , disappointed the cheese was in the middle on four pieces, hopefully next time it will be different .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Travis Mullins
Wow!! Just got the Philly fold over and cheese curds. Just moved to Willard and was my 1st time ordering. Will definitely do it again.!! Thank you.. ??
Nathan S
Good subs, decent
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Dana Record
I ordered a philly cheese steak sub, an italian sub and a large deluxe pizza today, so I'd have pizza for dinner tonight. I cannot even begin to describe how disappointed I am in what I got.1st- The philly cheese steak had maybe 15 small black square pieces that I think may have been the steak. There were no onions or mushrooms as described in the description.The italian.....well, let's just say I could have gotten more meat on a sub from Circle K. The pizza- I should have known something was off when I couldn't even smell it through the box and the box was warm, at best. The amount of toppings, again more on a frozen pizza and it is not completely cooked. I will try to finish cooking it before my husband gets home. I was really hopeful for something new close to home, but this isn't it.I did call and speak to the manager after typing this as I thought that was only fair. He did apologize and offered to come get my order and make another one or take my name and number and the next time is on him. I did give him my name and number. Everyone deserves a second chance. Fingers crossed.
First time trying the shop out. I'm very particular when it comes to pizza. I was so pleased that this establishment did not serve just a run of the mill pizza like most. The pizza crust was absolutely amazing! It is very unique with an indescribable taste unlike any. The toppings were fresh and the pizza was cooked perfectly! We purchased a sub for our son and brought it home to Columbus. He was also impressed and asked us where we got it so he could stop in sometime.The staff was family oriented and loved what they do. I would highly recommend trying the shop out. You will be glad you did.
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Pizza
Jeri
The chicken bacon ranch sub was delicious. The deluxe pizza was good, but after eating the sub first it couldn't compete.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Martha Palmison
A bit disappointing:Ordered : 2 samplers for separate couples.Tasted as if the deep fryer needed cleaned ....unpleasant aftertaste.Also, no sauces were offered nor given for the fried assortment.We thankfully had homemade marinara, honey mustard, and ranch at home.We all concurred not to order that again.We also ordered Small Veggie Speciallty, Hamburger Speciallty and Cheese bread (thin pizza crust/not bread).Crust on all three had great flavor, however unexpectedly thin. At least not too crispy.A thicker crust would have been more manageable and satisfying.Toppings on both pizzas were scarce.Veggie Pizza included canned black olives, green olives from a jar, and banana peppers only.The onions were perfect tiny squares. (Obviously pre frozen).( in conclusion, for 17.00 bucks you get two pickled frozen wet veg. (Olives however cheap are not a veg).Slight cheese on Veggie Pizza.No cheese at all on Hamburger Pizza.We Spent 68.00.Price per quality: We conclude 2 ? ? stars.Someone made the comment."We should have gone across the street to Rita's".Likelihood of reccomendation or returning.....No
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Jenny Arntz
The food was good. We prefer a thinner crust and the square cut pizzas. Service was friendly and quick. The eating area was clean and quaint. A nice little find.
Great pizza, some of the best. The only thing was that I only ordered on large and has to wait over an hour, so pizza ended up being almost room temp by the time it got to me. But he was so sweet, apologized, and explained that part of it was because he got lost. I understand that mistakes happen and everywhere is having trouble keeping up right now. Even with the wait, worth it! Just wish it could have been warmer ❤️ will order again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Order online it was a little weird wouldn't let me pick my sauce for the wings I called they fixed it for me. Picking up was a great experience such a nice staff and the food was even better probably the best pizza in town. Wings were great and that cheesy bread was out of this world.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
10-28-2023 - Knocked it down a star today as they updated the site to no longer offer delivery to my area.10-25-2023 - TL;DR: The online ordering "Slice" system has terrible support staff. NOT Danny Rays fault. If you have an issue call them directly DON'T use the Slice support. Danny will make it right. "Slice", Doesn't care.Full story: I had placed an order online and one of the delivered items was not made as requested (extra and missing toppings and missing sauce cup) I tried to get the issue corrected but was stone walled by the "Slice" online support people as they claimed that Danny's refused to refund or redeliver the issue items.Then I got a call from the owner the day after.He seen the initial review on google and wanted to rectify the issue. The owner took responsibility and had personally offered to deliver the corrected items (We already ate today so I requested it be deferred for the next day).If you have an issue CALL the restaurant and do not use the online "Slice" support chat as they will lie to you to get you.Continue to use the online ordering as it works fine.. just don't trust there support.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Try the Cheez Bread… you won’t regret it!
Great Pizza, at a great price. We had the peperoni, and I do have to say it was a great pie. thanks Danny.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's great pizza. Only problem we had was having to wait an hour and fifteen minutes for it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Big Dill Chicken Pizza
Sub was good, Pizza could use some work , disappointed the cheese was in the middle on four pieces, hopefully next time it will be different .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Wow!! Just got the Philly fold over and cheese curds. Just moved to Willard and was my 1st time ordering. Will definitely do it again.!! Thank you.. ??
Good subs, decent
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
I ordered a philly cheese steak sub, an italian sub and a large deluxe pizza today, so I'd have pizza for dinner tonight. I cannot even begin to describe how disappointed I am in what I got.1st- The philly cheese steak had maybe 15 small black square pieces that I think may have been the steak. There were no onions or mushrooms as described in the description.The italian.....well, let's just say I could have gotten more meat on a sub from Circle K. The pizza- I should have known something was off when I couldn't even smell it through the box and the box was warm, at best. The amount of toppings, again more on a frozen pizza and it is not completely cooked. I will try to finish cooking it before my husband gets home. I was really hopeful for something new close to home, but this isn't it.I did call and speak to the manager after typing this as I thought that was only fair. He did apologize and offered to come get my order and make another one or take my name and number and the next time is on him. I did give him my name and number. Everyone deserves a second chance. Fingers crossed.
Restaurantji Recommends
First time trying the shop out. I'm very particular when it comes to pizza. I was so pleased that this establishment did not serve just a run of the mill pizza like most. The pizza crust was absolutely amazing! It is very unique with an indescribable taste unlike any. The toppings were fresh and the pizza was cooked perfectly! We purchased a sub for our son and brought it home to Columbus. He was also impressed and asked us where we got it so he could stop in sometime.The staff was family oriented and loved what they do. I would highly recommend trying the shop out. You will be glad you did.
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Pizza
The chicken bacon ranch sub was delicious. The deluxe pizza was good, but after eating the sub first it couldn't compete.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A bit disappointing:Ordered : 2 samplers for separate couples.Tasted as if the deep fryer needed cleaned ....unpleasant aftertaste.Also, no sauces were offered nor given for the fried assortment.We thankfully had homemade marinara, honey mustard, and ranch at home.We all concurred not to order that again.We also ordered Small Veggie Speciallty, Hamburger Speciallty and Cheese bread (thin pizza crust/not bread).Crust on all three had great flavor, however unexpectedly thin. At least not too crispy.A thicker crust would have been more manageable and satisfying.Toppings on both pizzas were scarce.Veggie Pizza included canned black olives, green olives from a jar, and banana peppers only.The onions were perfect tiny squares. (Obviously pre frozen).( in conclusion, for 17.00 bucks you get two pickled frozen wet veg. (Olives however cheap are not a veg).Slight cheese on Veggie Pizza.No cheese at all on Hamburger Pizza.We Spent 68.00.Price per quality: We conclude 2 ? ? stars.Someone made the comment."We should have gone across the street to Rita's".Likelihood of reccomendation or returning.....No
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
The food was good. We prefer a thinner crust and the square cut pizzas. Service was friendly and quick. The eating area was clean and quaint. A nice little find.
Very good pizza!! ?