Cleveland Pizza Co

28910 Lakeshore Blvd, Willowick
(440) 944-2777

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Patrick Alunni

So i ordered pizza tonight for my and my girlfriend. We ordered one pizza cheesy bread and funnel cake fries.. they gave us a pizza instead of cheesy breadstick. I call to tell them they about it so they offered to make me some new ones but told me I had to pick them up don’t even offer to rub them too me when I am 5 mins down the road and uh the delivery range. And driver made the mistake. Atleast off to have someone run then out to me. So we pick them up and gave us the wring sauce for the bread. 2nd time I. A row they messed up my order you lost a customer there is so many pizza places around

Da’lonte Wright

I swear I have a hard time finding authentic pizza but hands-down this is one of the best pizzas you can get in the area. Recommend this to the king if he came from overseas thank you for the good pizza. Keep up the good work.

Kurt Snyder

This is my go to pizza spot. Always on point. Their spicy red sauce is so good. Love this place. It honestly surprised me when I saw the bad reviews about this place. I’ve ordered take out and delivery countless times and never had an issue. The workers are all cool and professional. The pizza o ordered last night was so good I had to order it again today.

chris ard

I've been eating here for years and never had an issue. During the winter my son ordered from here and ended up getting very sick. I just assumed it was a flu bug and it was just a coincidence that he had eaten here that weekend. A couple weeks later I ate here and ended up getting sick as well. It's been about a month or so since and today I decided to give it a try. I got sick almost immediately after I finished eating. I'll just assume that they're doing something differently because I've always ordered the same thing for the last several years. One thing I did notice is that the pizzas have been a lot more greasy. Or maybe it's the countless number of employees in such a cramped space walking and breathing on our food and also not wearing gloves, whether required or not. Especially seeing drivers coming and going walking right past food being prepared. Regardless, my days eating at this establishment are over.

*Edit*
Before I left my review I scanned through other reviews to see if anyone else has had a similar experience. Seems there are various other issues with this particular location. And all met with the same condescending replies from ownership/management. Also, I was unaware that this establishment specializes in health-care, judging by the expert medical diagnosis I was given. Which is a good thing thing because you may want to consider adding a colonoscopy to every order. But I did go ahead and remove the name of the other local pizza establishment that I also frequent so that it doesn't diminish the validity of my claim. But it also doesn't take away the fact that I have never gotten sick from their food. And I can assure you that if I were trying to promote their business I wouldn't stop with a Google review. So I'll end with this, when a restaurant cares more about arguing online with its customers rather than acknowledge an issue do you really want to take a chance with your health by eating there?

Jordan U

Food was amazing but weird I gave a tip after picked up the food from the restaurant and manager, tip culture is weird nowadays 🤔

Felicia Dickson

Love there pizza

brittany harper

They mess up my order everytime

Heidi McGlamery

The BBQ chicken pizza is delicious. Highly recommended.

Kimberly New

If you want an excellent salad and sub this is definitely the place. OMG both are fantastic

Scott Berry

I previously posted a review after having a bad experience. The manager called me soon after and apologized for my experience. Tonight I ordered the pizza he replaced for me and it was really good. Totally redeemed themselves and I will definitely order again!

Victoria Mcdivitt

Best Pizza ever. Get the sweet sauce! There is one in Mentor!

Shaze' Williams

If i could ZERO STARS I absolutely would. My pizza was undercooked and THE COOK MADE OUR PIZZA WOTH NO GLOVES. Then when confronted and asked to wear gloves we were told “the state doesn’t require us to wear gloves”. While this is true, i would expect them to care enough about the Health of customers to wear gloves when asked or IN GENERAL. This interaction is unacceptable and disgusting customer service. Do not eat here for your own health & safety.

Dan

NASTIEST PIZZA PLACE I EVER EXPERIENCED, THE PERSON WHO MAKES THE PIZZA DOESNT WEAR ANY GLOVES OR NOTHING THE PLACE IS FILTHY

Olivia Shoaf

If I could give zero stars, I would. Management is rude and quality control is lacking. Go somewhere else, save your money!

Latosha Lee

I ordered 10 wings & a large supreme pizza I placed the order at 4:53p.m and was told it’ll be about an hour for delivery. Almost 2 hours later I called and was told my order is out and he’s not sure why it’s taking so long now it’s 7:56p.m and still no pizza 🙄🤦🏽‍♀️ my fiancé called and asked for the manager and was told they’ll make it fresh and send it back out for delivery. This will be my last time ordering from this place because this is absolutely ridiculous it to mention I’m so hungry it’s 8:09p.m and i finally got the order at 8:00

Loading...