What happened to this place? We came specifically for the Mothers Day menu that was listed on Facebook, and the items posted weren’t even there. The chicken was over cooked, dry and hard. Service was slow. Three of us got the buffet and had a plate of salad and a plate of hot food finished before my daughter in law even got what she ordered , and was not even that busy. Beverage refills were not offered. Just overall has declined in my eyes. Except the decorating. Really nice redo.
Candy Engle
We went today and we will not be back. We were seated and waited almost 15 minutes before any server acknowledged us. We ordered the buffet. Started with the salad bar and the lettuce mixture was awful. It was visibly old with red/brown tinged lettuce throughout the entire pan. Other salad bar items were ok, although the macaroni salad was very al dente which is not how you should serve macaroni salad. We went next to the hot buffet and almost every pan on the buffet was empty. I mentioned it and others came up and went back to their seats as they were not filling food in a timely manner. I took a small scoop of mashed potatoes, which were clearly NOT homemade. The gravy was either out of a jar or a packet because it was awful and noticeably also not home made.
In a venue where you expect most folks are getting the buffet, you need to Lee on top of it and keep it fresh, hot, and full to accommodate your customers. It was not a good experience at all.
Local restaurant critic Dereck Malone was there at the same time we were. I can’t imagine he would give it a favorable review unless he truly is being paid to do so.
Joann Rodock
Hell No !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Lana Kelly
Wonderful meal, had the buffet, soooo good, met with our Model T club, we all enjoyed ourselves, staff was so friendly ❤️
Nina McIntire Burns
I have never had a bad meal at the Amish Door restaurant. We love the Buffet with all the fixings. The bakery items are delicious. Prices have gone up all over since Covid. For me it is worth my money to get all you can eat buffet.
Tamara Benson
Friendly staff and wonderful selection of baked goods. Always worth a stop when you are heading to Amish Country!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Hanna
They have the biggest best fritters I've had my wife loves the cheese and meat selection and said the prices were really good, the cheese is creamy smooth and very tasty ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Renner
Lied about business hours. Went there 12/20/23 at 2:30 pm and was closed. Hours say open until 6pm.
Betty E
Do not ever order the fish & chips. I had that and it was the worst meal I have ever had. The fish was so tough down the center I could not cut it with a knife. I had to pick at the sides in order to get a few bites of cod. Also, the fries were soggy and not crispy at all.
This was our first place we went to for a meal when we got to Amish Country. I got the roast beef, gravy, mashed potatoes, and corn. Delish!! My husband, Mark, got the meatloaf , mashed potatoes, and corn. They served dinner rolls with the meal and I wanted to eat all of them ...delish!! We split a piece of pecan pie. It was good and not as sweet as some I have had. We would definitely recommend the place!!
peggygV5452IC
Neither one of us was all that hungry so we decided not to get the buffet. We had the chicken dinner and hot roast beef sandwich combo which were both wonderful! The dinner rolls were awesome (and they sell them in their bakery to take home with you which we did) Service was top notch, we didn't have room for dessert but I'm sure that pie was great too.
B350m
We have dined at the Amish Door for probably 10 years. I was disappointed with them today. They have significantly raised their prices and I don’t feel the quality was the same as in the past. A three piece chicken dinner 2 sides costs between $15-$16.00. Add a beverage for another$ 3.00 and lunch is now$19.00. If you prefer to substitute a healthy salad for a side there’s an additional charge of $5.49, bringing your lunch up to $24.49. Amish Door has followed the trend of businesses adding a3% charge for credit card purchases. A stop to the bakery in the past was a happy visit. The chocolate brownies were reasonably priced and buying 6 was a price breaking point. Today I found a piece of brownie was $2.99 or 12 for $22.99. That exceeds my budget for sweets. The gift shop upstairs was now closed. The once bustling restaurant , where I had to wait in line to get a table , was noticeably empty.Sadly, I doubt that we will be returning.
TroyGuy50
Best peanut butter cream pie. Very flavorful and satisfying. We even brought a whole peanut butter cream pie home. Don’t skip dessert here.
What happened to this place? We came specifically for the Mothers Day menu that was listed on Facebook, and the items posted weren’t even there. The chicken was over cooked, dry and hard. Service was slow. Three of us got the buffet and had a plate of salad and a plate of hot food finished before my daughter in law even got what she ordered , and was not even that busy. Beverage refills were not offered. Just overall has declined in my eyes. Except the decorating. Really nice redo.
We went today and we will not be back. We were seated and waited almost 15 minutes before any server acknowledged us. We ordered the buffet. Started with the salad bar and the lettuce mixture was awful. It was visibly old with red/brown tinged lettuce throughout the entire pan. Other salad bar items were ok, although the macaroni salad was very al dente which is not how you should serve macaroni salad. We went next to the hot buffet and almost every pan on the buffet was empty. I mentioned it and others came up and went back to their seats as they were not filling food in a timely manner. I took a small scoop of mashed potatoes, which were clearly NOT homemade. The gravy was either out of a jar or a packet because it was awful and noticeably also not home made. In a venue where you expect most folks are getting the buffet, you need to Lee on top of it and keep it fresh, hot, and full to accommodate your customers. It was not a good experience at all. Local restaurant critic Dereck Malone was there at the same time we were. I can’t imagine he would give it a favorable review unless he truly is being paid to do so.
Hell No !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Wonderful meal, had the buffet, soooo good, met with our Model T club, we all enjoyed ourselves, staff was so friendly ❤️
I have never had a bad meal at the Amish Door restaurant. We love the Buffet with all the fixings. The bakery items are delicious. Prices have gone up all over since Covid. For me it is worth my money to get all you can eat buffet.
Friendly staff and wonderful selection of baked goods. Always worth a stop when you are heading to Amish Country!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They have the biggest best fritters I've had my wife loves the cheese and meat selection and said the prices were really good, the cheese is creamy smooth and very tasty ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lied about business hours. Went there 12/20/23 at 2:30 pm and was closed. Hours say open until 6pm.
Do not ever order the fish & chips. I had that and it was the worst meal I have ever had. The fish was so tough down the center I could not cut it with a knife. I had to pick at the sides in order to get a few bites of cod. Also, the fries were soggy and not crispy at all.
Sour dough bread was delicious! Very fresh!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great Blueberry Cake Donuts.
This was our first place we went to for a meal when we got to Amish Country. I got the roast beef, gravy, mashed potatoes, and corn. Delish!! My husband, Mark, got the meatloaf , mashed potatoes, and corn. They served dinner rolls with the meal and I wanted to eat all of them ...delish!! We split a piece of pecan pie. It was good and not as sweet as some I have had. We would definitely recommend the place!!
Neither one of us was all that hungry so we decided not to get the buffet. We had the chicken dinner and hot roast beef sandwich combo which were both wonderful! The dinner rolls were awesome (and they sell them in their bakery to take home with you which we did) Service was top notch, we didn't have room for dessert but I'm sure that pie was great too.
We have dined at the Amish Door for probably 10 years. I was disappointed with them today. They have significantly raised their prices and I don’t feel the quality was the same as in the past. A three piece chicken dinner 2 sides costs between $15-$16.00. Add a beverage for another$ 3.00 and lunch is now$19.00. If you prefer to substitute a healthy salad for a side there’s an additional charge of $5.49, bringing your lunch up to $24.49. Amish Door has followed the trend of businesses adding a3% charge for credit card purchases. A stop to the bakery in the past was a happy visit. The chocolate brownies were reasonably priced and buying 6 was a price breaking point. Today I found a piece of brownie was $2.99 or 12 for $22.99. That exceeds my budget for sweets. The gift shop upstairs was now closed. The once bustling restaurant , where I had to wait in line to get a table , was noticeably empty.Sadly, I doubt that we will be returning.
Best peanut butter cream pie. Very flavorful and satisfying. We even brought a whole peanut butter cream pie home. Don’t skip dessert here.
Loading...