BayLobsters Café & Fish Market

Lobster rolls were small and overcooked and rubbery. Lobster mac and cheese was watery and not much cheese Lobster was overcooked and rubbery. Lobster bisque was overcooked and rubbery.

The food is absolutely amazing and yummy.

Our first visit, the food was delicious

We just had a wonderful dinner experience at Bay Lobster’s in Wooster, Ohio. Our seafood sampler, fried oysters, Fresh Lake Erie perch and all the sides were excellent! The owner, John, even came out to visit with us after our meal and he made us feel very welcome. This is now our “go to” spot whenever we are nearby in the future!! Highly recommend this to anyone who loves fresh perfectly prepared seafood. The choices of fish and shellfish is unbelievable!

All good.

I’ve never eaten in the cafe, however I’ve purchased seafood numerous times here to prepare at home. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly and their fish never disappoints. Don’t take a chance at a grocer- buy your fish here, it’s fresh, well handled, and if you ask you’ll learn how to make an amazing meal…… this is the only place I buy seafood

The cod was fresh and tender. Will be back!

Stopped in for a late lunch and was not disappointed ! We both had the fish and chips and the fish was very mild , good crunchy coating and delicious. Hush puppies were good as well. Staff were all friendly and explained everything well and answered questions. Don't hesitate to stop and try it , we will definitely be back !

Always wonderful tasting seafood! Very friendly service!

All was good, if I could change anything it would be to reduce the breading on the oysters. To me they were so fresh (very light delicate taste) that the breading slightly covered thier taste. Even that being said. I will definitely be going back here again.

Amazing food and service. Wooster's hidden gem. Fresh, delicious seafood they'll prepare it for you or take it home.

Amazing food and service! We enjoyed the fried oysters, lobster roll, fish sandwich, onion rings, and crab cake blt sandwich. All food & service exceeded our expectations! Can't wait to go back for more crab cakes and try some other fish! There is nice small dining area and lots of cool decor... I highly recommend you stop here if you're looking for quality seafood & service from friendly people!!

Best fish I have ever had. 😋

Had lobster roll wasn't what I was expecting. Not that much lobster and ALOT of celery. Tiny peaces parts. I was expecting big chunks of lobster. Coleslaw was the bagged stuff you get and brown. I'm glad we tried this place but marking this one off our list.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Friendly ppl, affordable prices. The only place I could find Land O Lakes Garlic and Herb butter.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Oysters on the Half-Shell, Lobster, Fried Shrimp, Crab Legs