Your Pizza Shop

503 E Liberty St, Wooster
(330) 804-0404

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jamie Blake

Old-school neighborhood pizza shop with a super sweet staff. Family friendly, and exactly what you’d expect in terms of food: hot, relatively quick, reasonably priced, tastes good. This is your regular folks pizzeria, not a fancy overpriced bistro. It’s pretty unassuming from the outside but it hits the spot, and the great people make the place. We’ll definitely come back again!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Theodore Jones

They got a new cook the cook is good at making the chicken I will be back again food was very good 👍👍👍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Jojo's

Alicia Conr

Absolutely amazing food. The hit wings are amazing an so was the pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Traditional Wings

Adam Conr

excellent pizza, affordable and friendly staff. I love the hot wings as well as they were amazing. if your in Wooster ohio. Come get your pizza here. On training vacation and definitely worth coming for

Bill Elliott

Good food. Descent prices. Nice people that work there.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Jason Lindbom

Not a local. Driving through area. Heard good pizza and fried chicken. Gave it a try.
Placed order. Took over an hour to get food. In the meantime, several other customers had issues with orders as well. Looks like owners need to get managers in line to manage the rest of staff.
Everyone there was nice, just took forever and seen alot of mad local customers.
Food was great!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Cyndi Czibor

I like some sauce on a pizza, Ours was extra dry… not impressed whatsoever. Doubtful I will get another…. I don’t recommend it ..

Jason Henry

Yours Pizza was one of my favorite places to get chicken. A simple mistake was made that could have easily been correct. I oreder the 4 leg dinner to be delivered. What I received was 4 wings. Unfortunately I went to the hospital that evening and was unable to report the mistake. I was in.the hospital a week. Once discharged I call to see if things could be corrected. I was call a thief. I was insulted. i.will never order from them again. so disappointing.

Mike Parsittie

Great pizza staff was friendly and professional

Mike Franks

Ordered the deep dish pizza. It was ready for pickup at the given time. We opened the box at home. It was just a regular pizza with high rim. Not what I expected. The crust bland. Pizza was barely warm. We tossed the leftovers.

Matt Allen

We ordered delivery. Price was reasonable and delivery time was not bad (about 40 minutes). I was disappointed that they did not make the pizza correctly. Was supposed to be half cheese, half pepperoni and mushroom. Receipt confirmed they had the info correct, but they made the whole pizza with toppings so my daughter did not get any pizza. I was equally disappointed when I took a bite and found that the pizza had no flavor at all. Dipping it in the marinara sauce that came with the garlic bread helped a little, but not much. The garlic bread was ok, and the giant chocolate chip cookie was ok, so not a total loss but I threw away most of the pizza as I can't imagine it would improve overnight. Won't be ordering from here again.

Anthony Poling

My wife ordered a large gourmet pizza, potato wedges, chicken wings and jalapeño poppers. I was with her as she waited 5 minutes after being put on hold to order, told it would be 40 minutes. Stop to pick up our order and was told they had no such order and no orders for the name she gave. All 3 employees looked and acted like they had no idea what was going on. So left with no food and no excuse. As we were arriving home, 20 minutes away, my wife called back to ask how the order was never received when she was given a price and time to pick up. At that point the employee said they DID have the order after all and we could come and pick it up!! No apologies or even a discount to drive back to pick up our now cold order! That didn't happen.

Justin Michael

Great food, great customer service! definitely recommend!

Tiffany Frelix

The best pizza ever even my husband loves it, it's to die for, wings are fantastic and the pizza is made just right

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Your Wings - Boneless, Traditional Wings, Brownie, Jalapeño Poppers, Mozzarella Sticks

Wilma begly

Customer service on the phone was the most disrespectful I have ever experienced. Due to a disagreement over a chicken sub that was the most awful thing I've ever tried to eat. I called the store 3xs and was hung up on, even waited to call the next day to talk to the manager and was hung up on even from him. (Bob Hope) if that's even his name. What a shame.

Loading...