PaPa GeGe's Italian Villa

440 Boardman Poland Rd, Youngstown
(330) 758-0000

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tricia Hiltgen

The way Italian food should taste! We have passed Papa Gege's multiple times when going to Boardman. Finally, we tried it & we were not disappointed. The salad had quality greens, tomatoes, olives, bell peppers, & croutons with their homemade dressing. My husband got blue cheese & I got ranch. We both enjoyed them. In addition to our pasta meal we also got 3 garlic knots. These are not the tiny garlic knots that you're used to getting. They were very good sized. Our son ordered a mini pepperoni roll which was filled with plenty of pepperoni & a slice of thin crust pepperoni pizza. The chef cooked them a little too long & were a little dark but he sent them out for our son to munch on. The pepperoni roll was still delicious & they gave a good size of marinara sauce for dipping. Shortly after, my son received a perfectly cooked pepperoni roll & slice of pepperoni pizza. Later, the chef came out & apologized to us about the overdone pizza & pepperoni roll. We were impressed he took the time to humble himself and acknowledge his mistake. My husband ordered beef ravioli & I ordered the spaghetti with bolegnase sauce & a meatball. All the food were good serving sizes & we took a few containers home. The servers of the restaurant were helpful & great! They were on top of getting food to us & clearing away plates and utensils. The soft drinks are serve yourself. We are continuously on the lookout for real cooked food, this is the place to go. Forget the chain restaurants-when you want great Italian food-go to Papa Gege's instead!

Jamison Fennel

Great tasting food at a decent price.

Darlene Woodberry

Thank you Papa Gege for the best pizza in boardman from the Board of elections ate the holiday Inn.

reddginger10

A heartfelt thanks to PaPa GeGe for his kindness giving us pizza for our election poll workers at the Holiday Inn. Much appreciated!

g Ramsey

Thank you Papa Ge Ge for blessing the election workers with your generous heart and your phenomenal pizza! Amore from all of us!

Mark Asher

Was that a function and had their pizza it was outstanding from margarita, sausage, pepperoni, and others highly recommend

Anthony Maciukiewicz

First time trying, been on our radar for a while now. Tried the fried zucchini and cheese wedge appetizer. I had meatball splash and she had chicken parmigiana sandwich. Food was fantastic and sandwiches were huge we took half our meals home. Have a fun slice shop vibe realy nice people working there.

Rosemarie Recca

We Are From NY Where They Make The Best Pizza We Moved To Ohio In Oct.& We Been Looking For A Good Pizzeria Well Papa GeGe's Tasted Just Like NY Pizza. The Pizza Was Delicious & The Garlic Knots Were One Of The Best I Ever Had The Service Was Wonderful & The Pizza Guy Was Very Nice. We Will Definitely Be Going Back There Very Soon Great Atmosphere I Definitely Give Them A 👍

Thomas and Tammy

Delicious. Staff very attentive and helpful. Owner personable. Food absolutely delicious. Salad fresh. Pizza perfect. Panini is very well loaded with meat.

Marshall Winkler

Gotten food here several times, and pleased to say this is one of the better Italian restaurants in the area. Their various sauces are excellent, as are their calzones (which are huge!).

Greg Ekoniak

Absolutely delicious, large portions…great service

Dakota States

They have the best pizza in town.

Timothy Lankes

Delicious as usual, but...bring back the cheese fries, please?!?!

Devastated.

Sue Perelman

Love the pizza, pasta and soups. Everything is always amazing and the staff is friendly and helpful

Emmett Underwood IV

Great food and Great people

Loading...