We absolutely love Papa GeGe’s! We are so thankful they came to New Middletown, we’ve already eaten there 3 times and cannot wait to go back. Takeout twice, and dining inside once with our littles (which can sometimes be a challenge) but everyone and everything was great. Food is incredible. Highly recommend!
Quinn Beitzel
The manager was fantastic! There was an issue with the credit card reader and she did a great job rectifying the situation the food is amazing as well! This was at the new Middletown one. Will recommend to everyone
rhonda wilhelm
My Father absolutely loves your chicken parmigiana and after being married to my mother for 59 years loved her Italian foodParking: I can park right in front to pick up for my father who loves to receive a meal
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
laura kraft
Always 5 star food and service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly K
Amazing food and service tonight at the boardman location! I usually order a NY style pizza, cause it’s my favorite pizza around, but today i got Alfredo and red sauce for the kids and the sauce didn’t disappoint! Even the salad was fresh and had lots of veggies. We love this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
TaNia Simms
So I’m being generous giving 2 stars. I went in to order a total of FOUR pepperoni rolls… I ordered ONE with fries. I included this photo so everyone can see the prices of those items… I was charged $25.45 for an order that should have only totaled $14.77. I was given $4.55 back with NO receipt. Not to mention there was about 10 fries in the box. Never again.
John
Pizza is so good! I wanna see this business succeed! It’s right down the street my house. They seem like they haven’t got it quiet together yet with employees they need help for sure but the recipe is spot on. Great pizza!
Maddison Miller
Turned us away at 7:30? Web says they’re open til 9, we walked in to give them a try and we were excited. And they turned us away and said they aren’t taking orders, and there were people sitting down for dinner at the time. I don’t know if there’s like. More to the story as they didn’t explain at all they just turned us away?
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 1
Omar Barr
Food was delicious. Service was pleasant. .Parking: Lots of parking
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veal Parmesan, New York Style Pizza
Peter Palma
Excellent food at a reasonable price. Large portions. Very friendly people. Limited seating.
I’ve been here a few times before and only gotten pizza. I tried a dinner this evening for the first time and it led to a teachable moment….The dinner was excellent but I unfortunately didn’t get to finish it all. I substituted my salad with a bowl of wedding soup. I expected a small cup (coffee mug size), but instead got a giant bowl (dinner plate next to it for reference)Much larger portions than expected on everything. Unless you’re a competitive eater, anticipate to take about half of it home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana
Louise Cohen
The food was authentic Italian, using fresh ingredients, and skillfully prepared. Service was attentive with a kitchen capable of bringing out each course in a timely but unrushed manner. Portions were generous so you have a great dinner and additional enjoyment at home. Overall, a very satisfying dining experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paul Bair
Need a bigger restaurant..lol..it was packed, people standing at the door, so you couldn't get in, the check out counter is right at the door, so you have to wait till people are done paying to get in, not a fan of crowded places, they are a great place to eat at, so can't fault them for that, it's just that the restaurant isn't big enough to hold as many people as they serve, demand for good Italian food is on the rise..lol..but their food is delicious.Wheelchair accessibility: I would imagine there is no wheelchair access, the place is so small, I could barely get in, so a wheelchair would be even harder, if they had a second door, it might be possible, but one way in and one way out, if a fire broke out, I wouldn't want to be there.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Steak Calzone, Pepperoni Pizza, Greek Salad, New York Style Pizza
Sheila Hill
I have had the most delicious meals at Papa G’sYou can tell he only uses the best ingredients… delicious ?
We absolutely love Papa GeGe’s! We are so thankful they came to New Middletown, we’ve already eaten there 3 times and cannot wait to go back. Takeout twice, and dining inside once with our littles (which can sometimes be a challenge) but everyone and everything was great. Food is incredible. Highly recommend!
The manager was fantastic! There was an issue with the credit card reader and she did a great job rectifying the situation the food is amazing as well! This was at the new Middletown one. Will recommend to everyone
My Father absolutely loves your chicken parmigiana and after being married to my mother for 59 years loved her Italian foodParking: I can park right in front to pick up for my father who loves to receive a meal
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always 5 star food and service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food and service tonight at the boardman location! I usually order a NY style pizza, cause it’s my favorite pizza around, but today i got Alfredo and red sauce for the kids and the sauce didn’t disappoint! Even the salad was fresh and had lots of veggies. We love this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So I’m being generous giving 2 stars. I went in to order a total of FOUR pepperoni rolls… I ordered ONE with fries. I included this photo so everyone can see the prices of those items… I was charged $25.45 for an order that should have only totaled $14.77. I was given $4.55 back with NO receipt. Not to mention there was about 10 fries in the box. Never again.
Pizza is so good! I wanna see this business succeed! It’s right down the street my house. They seem like they haven’t got it quiet together yet with employees they need help for sure but the recipe is spot on. Great pizza!
Turned us away at 7:30? Web says they’re open til 9, we walked in to give them a try and we were excited. And they turned us away and said they aren’t taking orders, and there were people sitting down for dinner at the time. I don’t know if there’s like. More to the story as they didn’t explain at all they just turned us away?
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 1
Food was delicious. Service was pleasant. .Parking: Lots of parking
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veal Parmesan, New York Style Pizza
Excellent food at a reasonable price. Large portions. Very friendly people. Limited seating.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Roll
Restaurantji Recommends
I’ve been here a few times before and only gotten pizza. I tried a dinner this evening for the first time and it led to a teachable moment….The dinner was excellent but I unfortunately didn’t get to finish it all. I substituted my salad with a bowl of wedding soup. I expected a small cup (coffee mug size), but instead got a giant bowl (dinner plate next to it for reference)Much larger portions than expected on everything. Unless you’re a competitive eater, anticipate to take about half of it home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana
The food was authentic Italian, using fresh ingredients, and skillfully prepared. Service was attentive with a kitchen capable of bringing out each course in a timely but unrushed manner. Portions were generous so you have a great dinner and additional enjoyment at home. Overall, a very satisfying dining experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Need a bigger restaurant..lol..it was packed, people standing at the door, so you couldn't get in, the check out counter is right at the door, so you have to wait till people are done paying to get in, not a fan of crowded places, they are a great place to eat at, so can't fault them for that, it's just that the restaurant isn't big enough to hold as many people as they serve, demand for good Italian food is on the rise..lol..but their food is delicious.Wheelchair accessibility: I would imagine there is no wheelchair access, the place is so small, I could barely get in, so a wheelchair would be even harder, if they had a second door, it might be possible, but one way in and one way out, if a fire broke out, I wouldn't want to be there.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Steak Calzone, Pepperoni Pizza, Greek Salad, New York Style Pizza
I have had the most delicious meals at Papa G’sYou can tell he only uses the best ingredients… delicious ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball, Chicken Parmigiana, Gnocchi Bolognese
Old Italian Cafe layout & atmosphere. Large menu, great food, and very reasonable prices. I'm a regular customer and love the sauces and garlic knots.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Roll, Meatball, Pepperoni Pizza, Cannoli, Alfredo Pasta with Chicken, Greek Salad, Veal Parmesan, New York Style Pizza, Pepperoni-Sausage Rolls