Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Wedding Cake, Pizza & Roll Tray, Rolls, Chicken Parmesan with Cavatelli, Spinach Brick, Traditional Cannoli, Tiramisu, Portabello Brick, Sausage Sub, Baklava, Pepperoni Roll, Bakery, The Brick, Italian Sub, Reuben Brick, Cheese Cake, Cupcake, Breaded Eggplant Deli, Homemade Wedding Soup
Eric Edwards
As long as I am working in this area, I will never go to another sub shop again. You can’t beat the service, quality of food or prices. I would give it six stars if I could.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Sub
Amy Fierst
We had no idea what this place was like, I googled a place with good Tiramisu and Jimmy's showed up. They were incredibly friendly on the phone when i ordered. When we arrived to pick it up, my husband and i stopped in our tracks. This place is huge, with display cases FULL of every Italian dessert, cookie, pastry, biscotti, i could go on and on. Then you arrive at the displays of meat, cheese, pasta, etc. All the staff was so welcoming and friendly especially the young lady who waited on us.In the car we immediately tried a bite of one of the 6 extra desserts we purchased! Magical. Delicious. Period.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Tiramisu
John Fierst
What a great place! We went in to pick up a cake and almost bought everything in the place. We will definitely be back.
The food is always good here. It's one of the few places I can eat lunch for under 10 bucks and still be filled up.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pam Harasyn
Everything is sooo good. Every time I’m home I get lunch and 4 or 5 jars of sauce to take home ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
bill chludzinski
Hot sausage sandwich and pasta Primavera were excellentThere is nothing better than the itialian deluxe with homemade
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
m bia
Have been coming for years. Upon ordering my sub I was informed that every topping would be 1.00$ extra. Refuse to double the cost of my sub just to have lettuce, onion, and tomato put on. That's an extraordinary up charge. Worker was rude when informing me of this unrupt and unexpected change to boot.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
bo marchionte
Love walking through the door and love it even more when I walk out because all the goodies I purchase are delicious.
pcampbell74
If you love traditional Italian food & deli, this place is for you!! Homemade pasta, meatballs, spaghetti sauce awaits you. A amazing deli & hot foods counter that will knock your socks off!!! A cookie & dessert counter that is nothing short of stunning!!!I always stop in on my lunch hour and grab a bite to eat. The entire staff is awesome, friendly & treat you like family!I love going to Jimmy’s to shop. A quick bite or picking up a cookie tray for the holidays.
Everything has slightly changed for the worst. From less fillings in all the food items (i.e.: sandwiches and also ricotta stuffed shells), to doctored-up or watered-down fillings. The meatballs are lower meat quality the past year. Also the turkey meat in the Dino subs has been replaced with another brand or supplier. Everything was so perfect a couple years ago though.:’-(
Keith Mallory
Love this place. The Sandwiches and pastas are amazing. I'm going to go here more often
Jailynne Cronin
Jimmy'sbaker made a beautiful birthday cake for a 2 year old's Peter Rabbit party. It was delicious, creative, and beyond beautiful! Thanks Jimmys!!
Jason Nelson
I stopped by on my way to New Castle to pick up some food and the selection is incredible! Everything from hot foods, sandwiches, amazing looking desserts and all things Italian. I picked up a few spinach rolls with hot peppers, a Reuben brick, an Italian sub and a container of their hot peppers. Everything was so fresh and delicious! Don’t sleep on this place! I true gem in Youngstown. I’m bummed that I didn’t pick up some of their desserts. Thank you so much!
Joseph Zajac
Great Italian food!!! Meatball sub is the bomb... Pizza of all variety.. they have fresh and frozen specialties. Great go to place for lunch... What are you waiting for, just go...
Absolute diamond!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Wedding Cake, Pizza & Roll Tray, Rolls, Chicken Parmesan with Cavatelli, Spinach Brick, Traditional Cannoli, Tiramisu, Portabello Brick, Sausage Sub, Baklava, Pepperoni Roll, Bakery, The Brick, Italian Sub, Reuben Brick, Cheese Cake, Cupcake, Breaded Eggplant Deli, Homemade Wedding Soup
As long as I am working in this area, I will never go to another sub shop again. You can’t beat the service, quality of food or prices. I would give it six stars if I could.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Sub
We had no idea what this place was like, I googled a place with good Tiramisu and Jimmy's showed up. They were incredibly friendly on the phone when i ordered. When we arrived to pick it up, my husband and i stopped in our tracks. This place is huge, with display cases FULL of every Italian dessert, cookie, pastry, biscotti, i could go on and on. Then you arrive at the displays of meat, cheese, pasta, etc. All the staff was so welcoming and friendly especially the young lady who waited on us.In the car we immediately tried a bite of one of the 6 extra desserts we purchased! Magical. Delicious. Period.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Tiramisu
What a great place! We went in to pick up a cake and almost bought everything in the place. We will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Tiramisu, Bakery
The food is always good here. It's one of the few places I can eat lunch for under 10 bucks and still be filled up.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything is sooo good. Every time I’m home I get lunch and 4 or 5 jars of sauce to take home ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hot sausage sandwich and pasta Primavera were excellentThere is nothing better than the itialian deluxe with homemade
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Have been coming for years. Upon ordering my sub I was informed that every topping would be 1.00$ extra. Refuse to double the cost of my sub just to have lettuce, onion, and tomato put on. That's an extraordinary up charge. Worker was rude when informing me of this unrupt and unexpected change to boot.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Love walking through the door and love it even more when I walk out because all the goodies I purchase are delicious.
If you love traditional Italian food & deli, this place is for you!! Homemade pasta, meatballs, spaghetti sauce awaits you. A amazing deli & hot foods counter that will knock your socks off!!! A cookie & dessert counter that is nothing short of stunning!!!I always stop in on my lunch hour and grab a bite to eat. The entire staff is awesome, friendly & treat you like family!I love going to Jimmy’s to shop. A quick bite or picking up a cookie tray for the holidays.
Restaurantji Recommends
Everything has slightly changed for the worst. From less fillings in all the food items (i.e.: sandwiches and also ricotta stuffed shells), to doctored-up or watered-down fillings. The meatballs are lower meat quality the past year. Also the turkey meat in the Dino subs has been replaced with another brand or supplier. Everything was so perfect a couple years ago though.:’-(
Love this place. The Sandwiches and pastas are amazing. I'm going to go here more often
Jimmy'sbaker made a beautiful birthday cake for a 2 year old's Peter Rabbit party. It was delicious, creative, and beyond beautiful! Thanks Jimmys!!
I stopped by on my way to New Castle to pick up some food and the selection is incredible! Everything from hot foods, sandwiches, amazing looking desserts and all things Italian. I picked up a few spinach rolls with hot peppers, a Reuben brick, an Italian sub and a container of their hot peppers. Everything was so fresh and delicious! Don’t sleep on this place! I true gem in Youngstown. I’m bummed that I didn’t pick up some of their desserts. Thank you so much!
Great Italian food!!! Meatball sub is the bomb... Pizza of all variety.. they have fresh and frozen specialties. Great go to place for lunch... What are you waiting for, just go...