Papa’s Bakery Cafe

196 McCartney Rd, Youngstown
(330) 953-2255

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Tripleta Triple Meat Half 6''
Dozen 12 Sugar Glazed Donuts
Triple Chocolate Cake Slice
Ham Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Cakes Pastries Sandwiches
Maduros Sweet Plantains
Shrimp Butter Garlic
Pastelillos De Guava
Pastelillo De Guava
Budin Bread Pudding

Menu

Salads
Grilled Chicken Salad
Crisp lettuce, tomato, onion, fries, mozzarella cheese, chicken breast.
Steak Salad
Crisp lettuce, tomato, onion, fries, mozzarella cheese with Spanish seasoned steak.
Signature Salad
Crisp lettuce, onion, tomato and avocado topped with your favorite dressing.

Puerto Rican Signature Dishes
Mofongo
Green plantains mixed with garlic, olive oil, broth, chicharron mashed by hand in a wooden pilon.
Pollo
Breaded fried chicken or sauteed chicken topped with chimichurri.
Carne Frita
Delicious pork chunks seasoned and marinated in Spanish rice then fried to perfection.
Pernil Asado
Slow-roasted pork.
Pork Chops
2 pork chops Spanish seasoned with herbs and spices.
Bistec Encebollado
Thinly sliced steak sauteed in Puerto Rican spices and onions.

Pizza, Wings, Rolls, Calzones
Wing Dings
Comes with choice of sauce.
Pepperoni Papa's Roll
Made with mozzarella and served with sauce.
Sausage Papa's Roll
Made with mozzarella and served with sauce.
Veggie Papa's Roll
Made with mozzarella and served with sauce.
Create Your Own Papa's Roll
Made with mozzarella and choice of 2 toppings. Served with sauce.
Meat Lovers Calzone
Made with seasoned ricotta and mozzarella, served with sauce.
Sausage Calzone
Made with seasoned ricotta and mozzarella, served with sauce.
Pepperoni Calzone
Made with seasoned ricotta and mozzarella, served with sauce.
Chicken Calzone
Made with seasoned ricotta and mozzarella, served with sauce.
Veggie Calzone
Made with seasoned ricotta and mozzarella, served with sauce.
Meatballs Calzone
Made with seasoned ricotta and mozzarella, served with sauce.
Create Your Own Calzone
Made with seasoned ricotta and mozzarella, served with sauce. Choice of 2 toppings.
Papa's Golden Fries
Hot and crispy golden french fries.
NY Style Thin Crust Pizza
Add toppings for an additional charge.

Puerto Rican Side Dishes
Arroz con Gandules
Yellow rice. Puerto Rican rice and pigeon peas made with all-natural homemade sofrito.
Arroz Blanco
Puerto Rican short grain white rice.
Habichuelas
Stewed beans. Flavorful pink beans simmered in safrito base broth with potatoes and olives.
Maduros Relleno
2 pieces. Mashed yellow plantains stuffed with Spanish seasoned ground beef.
Relleno de Papa
2 pieces. Spanish seasoned mashed potatoes, ground beef breaded with special panko seasoning, deep-fried.
Bacalaitos
Spanish seasoned cod fish fritters.
Alcapurria
Fritter made of green bananas and yautia (Taro Root) and stuffed with Spanish seasoned ground beef.
Pasteles
Seasoned taro root and plantain masa filled with meat. Wrapped in banana leaves and boiled.
Tostones
Crispy green plantains, fried twice and served with mojito, mayo, ketchup or chimichurri sauce.
Maduros
Sweet yellow plantains, fried to a crisp with soft and tender core.
Pastellilos
Chicken or beef. Made from scratch dough, deep-fried with Spanish seasoning. Add cheese for an additional charge.
Chimichurri Sauce
Cilantro dressing.
Mojito Sauce
Made with raw natural ingredients (spiced garlic sauce).

Desserts
Flan Cake
Buttery crisp cake edges with soft flan flavor inside. Add ice cream for an additional charge.
Vanilla Flan
Made of baked custard and coated with caramel.
Brownie and Ice Cream
Chewy chocolate brownie served with vanilla bean ice cream.
Vanilla Tres Leches
White butter cake, soaked in 3 kinds of milk topped with whipped cream frosting.

Drinks
Goya Product
Tropicola
Cola Champagne.
Soda Can
Bottled Water
Orange Juice
Apple Juice
Pina Colada
Non-alcohol.
Strawberry Daquiri
Non-alcohol.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+42 photos
Photo credit: google
+41 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Ordered for delivery. Food arrived hot. Presentation was good. Everything was amazing. Very tasty and seasoned well. My first time trying and was not disappointed. Highly recommend!!
September 2025
¡Comida increíble, servicio increíble! Sin duda volveré. Una joya escondida en la zona este.

Incredible food, incredible service! Definitely will be back. Hidden GEM on the East side ❤️
September 2025
First impressions matter and they knocked it out of the park. From the greeting at the counter like we were old friends and the ease of ordering and speedy preparation, just amazing. My food was amazing, totally will order again. The only negative thing my wife said, was that the Yuca fries maybe needed a pinch of salt. Overall we were floored with the flavor every bite packed. Just wow!!
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

A Taste Of Seafood And More - 1992 McCartney Rd
Seafood
Nicky's Pizzeria - 1916 McCartney Rd
Pizza
HeckYA! - 1680 McCartney Rd
Fast Food, Hot Dogs, Comfort Food

Papa’s Bakery Cafe

196 McCartney Rd, Youngstown, OH 44505
(330) 953-2255