Thank you so much for making the Dutch Apple pie for me on this past Saturday! It was DELICIOUS! My entire family loved it! It was a huge hit! 🍏🍎
Gerald Cercone
Crust was too thick, needed more filling, below average experience for the price.
Food: 2
Edward Johnston (Todd)
During a cross country road trip the hankering for pie struck. A quick search along our route yielded Pie, Oh My and man am I happy it did. The pie we bought was one of the best pies I have ever had (Cranberry Crumble) and the scones we got as well were amazing! Jen was extremely friendly, charming, and just all around amazing. If I am ever in the area again I will definitely go out of my way to acquire more pie from here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marcelle Raphtis
Highly recommended! Amazing pies❤️
Dan Abramson
Ordered a key lime pie ,a banana cream pie , and a small cherry pie for birthdays , they were all delicious ,made fresh the morning of our dinner , would gladly order form them again, and intend to do just that 5 big stars ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Caprie Klacik
My mom had the little pies at my bridal shower and they are my number one favorite pies I have literally ever had! They were even nice enough to lend her pretty display trays. 10/10 recommend! We had cake bites and cookies too but those went so fast I didn’t even get to try. They were all a hit :)
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kaylen Baringer
I will forever go here for any pies! Usually I am a big mocha house or white horse fruit farms person but neither of them can compete with Pie Oh My! Personable service! Amazing response times! Delicious pies! Never been disappointed with anything I have ever got and I've been getting her pies for about two years now. Definitely a must try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie M. Scott
Ohh my goodness!! Her pies are amazing, the owner is super sweet and extremely accommodating. My cousin ordered a pie 4 years ago and just came in from Arizona this week, the first thing she said was “we have to get a pie from Pie oh My. If you’re looking for a great pie, this is the place to order from!!
Roy Johnson
Really sweet and kind lady who loves baking. There are so many different things she can bake.If you don't know about her or her location, chances are you'll drive right by. There's no significant advertising outside. In my opinion, she should set a sign out front for cars to see with pictures of her baking items and possibly a special of the season. Most people drive by, and there's really nothing outside to attract attention.The location is across the street from Lake Newport and several historical mansions that set along the lake. Mill Creek Park is across the street.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cherry Pie
Judi Lesnansky
I love their pies. They are delicious. The little ones are a great way to try new things and are the perfect size for 2!
OMG! Just tried Pie Oh My for the first time! We tried the strawberry rhubarb pie and it was delicious! The crust was so flaky and perfect! The owner even baked it special for me and let me pick it up when she was closed! Super friendly and I will be back again! Thank you!
Katie Markielowski
We needed pies for our daughters 1st birthday party as she was born on pi day (3.14). We ordered a dozen mini pies, a few medium, and 2 large pies. Not only was every single pie fantastic but she made sure to work with me to make a special pie for my infant daughter. Everything was perfect and I could not reccomend pie oh my more.
Ian Beniston
Delicious sweets and an awesome shop. Check it out sometime soon and try a pie or a cinnamon scone. You won't be disappointed!
Angela Davis
I’m a cake person; however, I do eat certain pies. I tried her Strawberry Pretzel Cream pie and it was excellent! I liked everything about it.
Thank you so much for making the Dutch Apple pie for me on this past Saturday! It was DELICIOUS! My entire family loved it! It was a huge hit! 🍏🍎
Crust was too thick, needed more filling, below average experience for the price.
Food: 2
During a cross country road trip the hankering for pie struck. A quick search along our route yielded Pie, Oh My and man am I happy it did. The pie we bought was one of the best pies I have ever had (Cranberry Crumble) and the scones we got as well were amazing! Jen was extremely friendly, charming, and just all around amazing. If I am ever in the area again I will definitely go out of my way to acquire more pie from here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Highly recommended! Amazing pies❤️
Ordered a key lime pie ,a banana cream pie , and a small cherry pie for birthdays , they were all delicious ,made fresh the morning of our dinner , would gladly order form them again, and intend to do just that 5 big stars ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My mom had the little pies at my bridal shower and they are my number one favorite pies I have literally ever had! They were even nice enough to lend her pretty display trays. 10/10 recommend! We had cake bites and cookies too but those went so fast I didn’t even get to try. They were all a hit :)
Food: 5
Service: 5
I will forever go here for any pies! Usually I am a big mocha house or white horse fruit farms person but neither of them can compete with Pie Oh My! Personable service! Amazing response times! Delicious pies! Never been disappointed with anything I have ever got and I've been getting her pies for about two years now. Definitely a must try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ohh my goodness!! Her pies are amazing, the owner is super sweet and extremely accommodating. My cousin ordered a pie 4 years ago and just came in from Arizona this week, the first thing she said was “we have to get a pie from Pie oh My. If you’re looking for a great pie, this is the place to order from!!
Really sweet and kind lady who loves baking. There are so many different things she can bake.If you don't know about her or her location, chances are you'll drive right by. There's no significant advertising outside. In my opinion, she should set a sign out front for cars to see with pictures of her baking items and possibly a special of the season. Most people drive by, and there's really nothing outside to attract attention.The location is across the street from Lake Newport and several historical mansions that set along the lake. Mill Creek Park is across the street.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cherry Pie
I love their pies. They are delicious. The little ones are a great way to try new things and are the perfect size for 2!
Restaurantji Recommends
OMG! Just tried Pie Oh My for the first time! We tried the strawberry rhubarb pie and it was delicious! The crust was so flaky and perfect! The owner even baked it special for me and let me pick it up when she was closed! Super friendly and I will be back again! Thank you!
We needed pies for our daughters 1st birthday party as she was born on pi day (3.14). We ordered a dozen mini pies, a few medium, and 2 large pies. Not only was every single pie fantastic but she made sure to work with me to make a special pie for my infant daughter. Everything was perfect and I could not reccomend pie oh my more.
Delicious sweets and an awesome shop. Check it out sometime soon and try a pie or a cinnamon scone. You won't be disappointed!
I’m a cake person; however, I do eat certain pies. I tried her Strawberry Pretzel Cream pie and it was excellent! I liked everything about it.
Best Butter Pecan Pie I ever had. Delicious!
Loading...