Pizza Joe's

3506 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown
(330) 270-0116

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kelly Birch

Placed an order went to go pick it up and the store is completely closed. So their website processed my payment and everything. Google says they close at 830. I placed it at 7pm. Can't contact anyone. Absolutely ridiculous. I want my money back and the food I ordered !

Xavier Ogwin

Online and says they close at 8:30pm and on good it says they close at 9:00pm. So my fiance placed a order at 7:09pm when they should clearly be open and it took her money off her card and everything! 27 dollars and some change taking off and when I went up there to get our dinner for the night they was close, they've been closed for how ever long but this needs fixed some people need fired and we need our money back plus the food because this is ridiculous!!!

Robert Harris

The absolute best calzones in

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tim McCabe

I guess when you ask for extra banana peppers on your sub.You get none at all!!!

Nick Miller

Great food and great service! Still the best veggie pizza in the area! Staff is courteous and food has never been better. 🙌🏼

Thomas Probst

This is the second time in a row that I paid in cash, and did not receive my change like it was not required. Today i purchased a large pepperoni pizza. I was told i owed $15.75. I gave them $16.00. I received no change. Second time in a row. My daughter was with me so I did not make a scene. Otherwise it would have been different. Cash is now king again, to avoid the additional 3% fee. I will not return. It's a shame because I love the pizza. What kind of crackhead establishment does not issue change due. Try it yourself. Better yet. Don't.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Austin

Didn't answer phone

Shawnte Gibbs

Chicken bacon ranch pizza was extremely dry over cooked and not enough cheese. This pizza absolutely did not have enough white sauce and it was overcooked and dried out. I’ve had better at this location. It has definitely changed. They use to have the best chicken bacon ranch pizza.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Doug Poole

I'm not from the area and ordered a large pepperoni and cheese while on a job site near here. I was really impressed with a really short wait for pick up, the price was very reasonable and the pizza was amazing. Shame I live almost 2 hours away because I'd get from here more often. Thanks for a great lunch.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tracy Steele

Their veggie pizza is the best! I am a travel nurse, so every time I am in town, I have to get it! Even my granddaughter's love it!! ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Veggie Pizza

Leaayzia Crockett

Worst pizza of my life it was horrible too much sauce and the dough wasn’t fully cooked

Food: 1

Kent Tucker

Twice now I've ordered from there . Splitting it with a co-worker . Order no peppers and they keep putting peppers on the order. Co-worker start eating his half . Ii take lunch find the order has peppers. Call back they want me to return it . Then they will make a new one . Most people only get a 30 minute lunch . So not worth going back . It wasn't my mistake to begin with. Plus keeps happening and stuck with the bill .I will not order from there ever again.

Food: 4

Service: 1

Carmen MottaGuedes

I called Pizza Joe's to get a price check on some Pizza, I personally love pizza from everywhere but who ever is open during a certain hour is a good key of importance gotta feed on my pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marian Thomas

This was the first time I ever had a bad experience with Pizza Joe's West...crust was under done and I asked for my wings to be crispy..that didn't happen.. disappointed ?

Food: 2

Sierra Marenkovic

Sad when the food is so good but the people on the phone or whoever is making the orders doesn't listen. I'm pretty specific so stuff doesn't get misunderstood but somehow it still does. Asked for a half sheet with pepperoni on the WHOLE thing, and mushrooms only on half TOO. Those are the exact words I used and somehow my order still isn't right. Not the first time either, constantly not getting what I'm asking. I really don't think I'm making things confusing just people moving too quick. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Loading...