Pizza Pan

4218 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown
(330) 270-9988

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Pizza Pan Real Italian Veggie Pizza

Single Slab Baby Back Rib Dinner

1 Slab of BBQ Baby Back Ribs

Meatball Madness Stromboli

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

A Bit of Italy Stromboli

Hot and Spicy Stromboli

Half Sheet Pizza 16 sls

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Pizza 16 Large 12 sls

Picked for you

Half Sheet Pizza (16 sls)

All of our dough is hand made in our shop, every day. All of our pizzas feature our homemade pizza sauce with mozzarella and provolone cheese.

The Ultimeatum Pizza

This pizza is loaded with meats. Pepperoni, salami, ham, bacon, and sausage all of that on top of mozzarella and provolone cheese. All of our specialty pizzas are made exactly like our traditional pizzas just more specialized.

Pizza (16") (Large 12 sls)

All of our dough is hand made in our shop, every day. All of our pizzas feature our homemade pizza sauce with mozzarella and provolone cheese.

Wings (Bone-in) (20 pcs)

All wings come plain and you choose your sauce or just keep them plain. Crispy deep fried chicken wings deep fried when you order. Nothing in our kitchen is made to order so you receive the freshest food possible whether you order pick up, delivery, or door dash delivery. All wings come plain and you can choose a sauce for us to hand toss them in or just keep them plain.

1 Slab of BBQ Baby Back Ribs

1 slab of the rib by itself. All of our ribs are slow-cooked and made to order and feature our homemade bbq sauce. Our ribs are very tender and coke off the bone with ease. Try then and you won't be disappointed.

Pizza Pans Specialty Pizzas

The Ultimeatum Pizza

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Comes with our signature top-secret homemade buttermilk ranch sauce instead of the normal pizza sauce covered with mozzarella provolone and cheddar cheese, all topped with grilled chicken and bacon. All of our specialty pizzas are made exactly like our traditional pizzas just more specialized.

The Deluxe Pizza

All of our specialty pizzas are made exactly like our traditional pizzas just more specialized.

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Comes with our signature top secret bbq sauce instead of the normal pizza sauce covered with mozzarella and provolone cheese and topped with grilled chicken and bacon. All of our specialty pizzas are made exactly like our traditional pizzas just more specialized.

Pizza Pan Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

Our bacon cheeseburger pizza comes with our homemade pizza sauce loaded with mozzarella, provolone and cheddar cheese, all topped with ground beef and bacon. All of our specialty pizzas are made exactly like our traditional pizzas just more specialized.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Comes with our signature top-secret buffalo sauce instead of the normal pizza sauce covered with mozzarella and provolone cheese and topped with grilled chicken and bacon. All of our specialty pizzas are made exactly like our traditional pizzas just more specialized.

Pizza Pan Real Italian Veggie Pizza

Our real Italian veggie pizza comes topped with mozzarella and provolone cheese, mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olives and tomatoes. All of our specialty pizzas are made exactly like our traditional pizzas just more specialized.

Hawaiian Pizza

Our Hawaiian pizza comes with our homemade garlic butter sauce instead of the normal pizza sauce. Topped with mozzarella, provolone, ham, bacon, and dole pineapples. All of our specialty pizzas are made exactly like our traditional pizzas just more specialized.

The Pepperoni Supreme Pizza

All of our specialty pizzas are made exactly like our traditional pizzas just more specialized.

Pizza Pan Pizzas

Pizza (16") (Large 12 sls)

All of our dough is hand made in our shop, every day. All of our pizzas feature our homemade pizza sauce with mozzarella and provolone cheese.

Pizza (12") (Medium 8 sls)

All of our dough is hand made in our shop, every day. All of our pizzas feature our homemade pizza sauce with mozzarella and provolone cheese.

Pizza (9") (Small 6 sls)

All of our dough is hand made in our shop, every day. All of our pizzas feature our homemade pizza sauce with mozzarella and provolone cheese.

Half Sheet Pizza (16 sls)

All of our dough is hand made in our shop, every day. All of our pizzas feature our homemade pizza sauce with mozzarella and provolone cheese.

Pizza pan Strombolis

The Famous Original Stromboli

Our best-selling stromboli is the original which comes loaded with pepperoni, mozzarella, and provolone cheese. All of our strombolis are a foot long and use our homemade dough. They also come with a side of our homemade marina sauce. After baking we brush our signature garlic parmesan butter on.

Hot and Spicy Stromboli

Pepperoni, jalapeños, mozzarella, and provolone cheese. All of our strombolis are a foot long and use our homemade dough. They also come with a side of our homemade marina sauce. After baking we brush our signature garlic parmesan butter on.

Hawaiian Stromboli

Ham, bacon, pineapples, mozzarella cheese and provolone cheese. All of our strombolis are a foot long and use our homemade dough. They also come with a side of our homemade marina sauce. After baking we brush our signature garlic parmesan butter on.

Down on the Ranch Stromboli

Grilled chicken with bacon, mozzarella, and provolone cheese. All covered with our homemade buttermilk ranch inside a delicious roll. All of our strombolis are a foot long and use our homemade dough. They also come with a side of our homemade marina sauce. After baking we brush our signature garlic parmesan butter on.

Meatball Madness Stromboli

This stromboli comes filled with homemade Italian meatballs, onions, green peppers, mozzarella cheese and provolone cheese. All of our strombolis are a foot long and use our homemade dough. They also come with a side of our homemade marina sauce. After baking we brush our signature garlic parmesan butter on.

Buffalo Chicken Stromboli

Grilled buffalo chicken with mozzarella and provolone cheese. All of our strombolis are a foot long and use our homemade dough. They also come with a side of our homemade marina sauce. After baking we brush our signature garlic parmesan butter on.

A Bit of Italy Stromboli

This stromboli comes loaded with Italian sausage, green peppers, onions, mozzarella cheese and provolone cheese. All of our strombolis are a foot long and use our homemade dough. They also come with a side of our homemade marina sauce. After baking we brush our signature garlic parmesan butter on.

No Meat for Me Stromboli

This stromboli has sautéed vegetables including green peppers, onions, mushrooms and, black olives. All of our strombolis are a foot long and use our homemade dough. They also come with a side of our homemade marina sauce. After baking we brush our signature garlic parmesan butter on.

Fresh Salads

Classic Dinner Salad

A fresh bed of lettuce, with tomatoes, black olives, pepperoni, and real cheese. All of our salads are made when you order them. We use fresh cut lettuce and tomatoes on all of our salads. All of pizza pans salads are large.

Antipasto Salad

Includes ham, pepperoni, salami, mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, and black olives. All of our salads are made when you order them. We use fresh cut lettuce and tomatoes on all of our salads. All of pizza pans salads are large.

Grilled Chicken Salad

Our classic dinner salad topped with seasoned grilled chicken. All of our salads are made when you order them. We use fresh cut lettuce and tomatoes on all of our salads. All of pizza pans salads are large.

Veggie Salad

Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, black olives & banana peppers. . All of our salads are made when you order them. We use fresh cut lettuce and tomatoes on all of our salads. All of pizza pans salads are large.

Oven Baked Subs

Italian Sub

Pepperoni, salami, and ham topped with mozzarella, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and Italian dressing. All of our subs are made to order and feature our 9 inch homemade hoagie rolls. All of our subs are hand baked using our patented pizza pan heat vision goggles.

Grilled Chicken Club Sub

Seasoned chicken topped with bacon, real cheese, lettuce and tomatoes. All of our subs are made to order and feature our 9 inch homemade hoagie rolls. All of our subs are hand baked using our patented pizza pan heat vision goggles©️.

Chicken Parmesan Sub

Seasoned fried chicken in our homemade marinara, topped with real cheese. All of our subs are made to order and feature our 9-inch homemade hoagie rolls. All of our subs are hand baked using our patented pizza pan heat vision goggles©️.

Meatball Sub

Italian meatballs in our homemade sauce, topped with real cheese, onions and green peppers. All of our subs are made to order and feature our 9-inch homemade hoagie rolls. All of our subs are hand baked using our patented pizza pan heat vision goggles©️.

Meat Lovers Sub

Sausage, pepperoni, bacon and ham topped with real cheese. All of our subs are made to order and feature our 9 inch homemade hoagie rolls. All of our subs are hand baked using our patented pizza pan heat vision goggles©️.

Veggie Sub

Mushroom, onion, green peppers, black olives, banana peppers, topped with real cheese, lettuce and tomatoes. All of our subs are made to order and feature our 9 inch homemade hoagie rolls. All of our subs are hand baked using our patented pizza pan heat vision goggles©️.

Traditional Chicken Wings (Deep Fried Bone-in)

Wings (Bone-in) (5 pcs)

Wings (Bone-in) (10 pcs)

All wings come plain and you choose your sauce or just keep them plain. Crispy deep-fried chicken wings deep fried when you order. Nothing in our kitchen is made to order so you receive the freshest food possible whether you order pick up, delivery, or door dash delivery. All wings come plain and you can choose a sauce for us to hand toss them in or just keep them plain.

Wings (Bone-in) (20 pcs)

Pizza Pans Famous BBQ Baby Back Ribs

Single Slab Baby Back Rib Dinner

Some of the best ribs you will eat. If you like tender, delicious baby back ribs you will love pizza pan baby back ribs. Comes with our homemade bbq sauce on the ribs, 2 piece off garlic toast, and french fries. All of our ribs are slow-cooked and made to order and feature our homemade bbq sauce. Our ribs are very tender and coke off the bone with ease. Try then and you won't be disappointed.

1 Slab of BBQ Baby Back Ribs

Photos

+19 photos

+18 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Doordash

Ubereats

Seamless

Order

Recent Reviews

I ordered this pizza because it was the only late night alternative to Domino's or Papa John's. I don't like fast food pizza so I tried Pizza Pan. To my surprise it really wasn't bad at all. In fact I would order it again. Medium Thickness, spicey yet sweet sauce, decent mozzarella, and light density dough. So not bad at all. It's bot my first pick, but not an awful choice.

June 2025

Giving this pizza a solid 3. The sauce is good and the crust taste is too. Very lightly baked, so if we order again I'd ask for well done. Slightly reminiscent of chef boy ar dee pizza that you can make at home.

June 2025

The gentleman (assuming owner) was incredibly nice! The food is absolutely amazing and not greasy or overloaded with sauce like most other pizza places anymore. I will definitely be a returning customer!

April 2025

More Reviews